‘Homeland’ Finale Recap: Carrie Mathison Faces Big Dilemma Back Home

Mike Pont/Getty Images
Courtesy of Showtime

After the explosive action and plot twists of the previous three episodes, “Homeland” closed its fourth season on a quieter note, with Carrie Mathison looking inward to slay a few personal dragons.

SPOILER ALERT: Stop reading if you have not seen the Dec. 21 episode of “Homeland,” “Long Time Coming.”

The season that saw Carrie get back to what she does best — tenaciously fighting terrorists — ended with her trying to adjust to dealing with the stuff of everyday life: being a mother, dealing with the loss of her father and the painful reconnection with her long-AWOL mother.

Even the requisite cliffhanger moment to keep us primed for season five revolves around Carrie facing a moral gut-check rather than the imminent danger of a bomb going off or specific attack unfolding. In fact, the dilemma Carrie stumbles into in the closing moments of “Long Time Coming,” is the epitome of what “Homeland” does so well — examining the gray areas of U.S. foreign policy.

How much do you compromise basic principles for the sake of making expedient progress? How much wiggle room is there to negotiate with sworn enemies when they offer something that could further the cause of U.S. security? It’s all the more powerful that “Homeland” would return to form in asking these questions in a fictionalized drama during the same month that the country and the world was rocked by the findings of the Senate’s investigation into CIA’s use of torture in the real war on terrorism.

All of this taken together made for a powerful episode, written by exec producer Meredith Stiehm and directed by exec producer Lesli Linka Glatter. As has been the case in every episode of season four, star Claire Danes was masterful in her portrayal of a woman facing anguish and deeply conflicted feelings in every area of her life.

Compared to the last two episodes, the finale was less of a roller coaster ride for Danes as there were no shootouts, no bombs exploding and no running through the streets of Islamabad. But Danes had to bring it in so many other ways, including her angry confrontation with her long-lost mother and her effort to deal with Quinn’s very dramatic — and very romantic — proposal. For once, Carrie was perfectly reasonable in telling Quinn not to pressure her on a decision and to give her time to think. It’s her dumb luck that she falls for the high strung type.

Seeing her deliver an emotional eulogy for her father or take her daughter to the park reminded us that between the drama of her job and the trauma of her bipolar condition, we don’t often get to see Carrie doing everyday- type things. She herself is the first to admit that she can’t possibly have something so normal as a relationship with Peter Quinn, who finally shows up at her father’s funeral service. “I’ll f—- it up,” she tells Quinn when he tenderly asks her to run away from the CIA with him. “I know how this goes. This will end badly.”

By the end of the episode, she’s ready to give Quinn the answer he wants … except that he’s off on a dangerous covert operation involving Syria. And then she’s rattled by learning that Saul Berenson, the beacon of decency throughout her career in the CIA, appears to be willing to go along with fellow CIA veteran Dar Adal’s ultra-covert plan to cut a kind of detente deal with Haqqani and the Pakistani military in order to return to work at the agency, perhaps as the boss again. And the fact that Adal was seen riding in the car with Haqqani when Carrie was ready to shoot him the previous week’s episode indicates how long the plan has been in the works. Carrie can’t believe Adal is willing to “dishonor the memory” of the more than three dozen embassy workers by cutting a deal with the devil — even if it might help the U.S. achieve other worthy goals.

“Not every choice we make is blessed with moral clarity,” Adal tells Saul. He’s a shameless seducer: “Come back. Lead us. The agency is waiting for you with open arms.” Saul, having been fired from his private contractor job, is desperate enough to get back to the CIA that he lets himself be wooed. If Haqqani is deemed off-limits by the CIA, that unfortunate video of Saul working from the wrong script will not be released. It seems a dicey bargain, but again, Saul is desperate. He’s like a person let out of prison after 30 years with no ability to live a “normal” life on the outside.

The intrepid Quinn is in the same boat, much as he thinks he yearns for a life of bouncing a baby on his knee and helping with the dishes.

Considering the season as a whole, there’s plenty of praise to go around, from sharp writing and directing to strong performances by Rupert Friend (Peter Quinn), Laila Robins (Martha Boyd), Tracy Letts (Andrew Lockhart), Nazanin Boniadi (Fara Sherazi), Nimrat Kaur (Tasneem) and Numan Acar (Haqqani). But at its core, this show turns on the relationship between Carrie and Saul, and the relationships they maintain separately in the wider world. The hard work done by Danes and Mandy Patinkin this season made “Homeland” unmissable again.

Carrie has had her ups and downs this season but for the most part she’s been in a pretty good head space. We’ve seen her be a leader under pressure, and we’ve seen her accept her failures. She was humbled by her father’s death and enlightened by the visit with her mother, which allayed her fears about trying to make a go of a relationship with her bipolar condition. She took in the tough love from her sister, Maggie, who first chastised her for chasing their mother, Ellen, away, and then reminded Carrie that she also left her daughter shortly after she was born. Those words are sure to echo in Carrie’s head, as much as she protested that it was always her intention to return to being a mother.

“I’m walking the line,” Carrie tells her sister, assuring her that she is on her meds. The fact that Carrie appears to be in such a basically healthy place as the season ends — notwithstanding some heartbreak to come regarding Quinn — may be the most shocking twist of all for “Homeland.”

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 8

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. JSB says:

    I think probably 90% of the audience was completely annoyed with this detour into these characters’ cloying personal issues, much like they were with the Brody family sidebar in Seasons 1-2 – and the 10% of the audience who thought this was an appropriate-interesting-season-ender probably were the people who were waiting for Quinn and Carrie to kiss. The focus, the epicentre of this story which made it a true original is long-gone, and nothing – not even the excitement and violence of a Kathryn Bigelow film that unfolded in this season – can take away from the fact that Nick Brody was the straw that stirred this drink (apologies to Reggie J :-) ), and kept this show from being your now-typical knee-jerk-neo-con-post-9-11 fantasy of paranoia and bluster, like the last show these writer-producers put on TV.

  2. Leftbanker says:

    The writers/producers completely shanghaied what had been the best season this show has given us. With America, the Taliban, and Pakistan in the balance we are supposed to care about some CIA employee’s relationship with her mother? Don’t answer that because it was rhetorical. This season has been brilliant and pure thriller and suddenly they introduce a baby (who no one cares about) and a mother who heretofore has not been mentioned. Make a choice: soap opera or dynamite thriller. You can’t have both.

    • Don Q. Public says:

      Indeed. This season (like previous seasons) showcased some fantastically dynamic female characters Carrie Mathison (Claire Danes), Fara Sherazi (Nazanin Boniadi), Nimrat Kaur (Tasneem Qureshi), and Martha Boyd (Laila Robins), balancing roles that include career and family. Though Claire Danes has spent much of her career playing weepy, simpering characters, Homeland is a true exception that showcases her acting range. As for the accusations made to you about “well roundedness” and “sexism,” I hardly read your comments as such. On the contrary, your criticisms were aimed most specifically at plot, and tangentially to characters. Without much research, one could find similar, specific criticisms made by reputable journalists, writers and entertainment experts. I find it utterly hysterical that in a drama about terrorism, where once again, (mostly) white heroes battle (mostly) brown villains, that the charge of sexism is leveled at you for your “chauvinism.” But, you are an easy mark, because why on earth would a sexist pig like you even watch a show like Homeland, replete with ball-busting bitchez! At least there’s still sufficient space in the conversation for someone else to squeal “Nazi.” As for your particular point about Carrie’s mother Ellen Mathison (Victoria Clark), I agree. Carrie’s life seems well-rounded enough at this point, without needlessly widening the circle, and spinning an otherwise tough, gritty season into a disjointed telenovela. Perhaps with the actual death of James Rebhorn (Frank Mathison), they needed to introduce Carrie’s and Maggie’s mother (Amy Hargreaves) to further textualize Carrie (and to continue the familial storyline), in preparation for Peter Quinn (Rupert Friend) arrival back home in a permanent vegetative state (or better yet, in a body bag) for the “Mathison gals” to snivel about during season 5. Let’s just hope that Saul’s long lost daughter stays hidden next year. By the way, what word do “breeders” use to insult the childless?

    • Jackoff says:

      Its called forming a well rounded character, you need the main focus to be on her work but you also need backstory and personal parts of her person life to you understand the decisons she makes and just to understand me completely as a person. I’m a man and find your comments slightly sexist because if this was a man this comment would have never occured from the likes of you.

  3. Jon Waggoner says:

    This was truly a finale for me. Sophomoric script was lame. I’m done having no desire to continue riding this train wreck of a series. RIP Homeland

  4. bobbobwhite says:

    If this series has run its course and is now degenerating into a soap opera mostly about the character’s personal lives instead of concentrating wholly on the the initial threat of terrorism, I do not intend to watch season 5. It is clear that the producers have run out of gripping plot ideas that made this series so interesting in the beginning.

  5. Sonny says:

    This finale is awesome and awesomely unexpected. It’s totally different from the finale of the previous seasons. After a couple of episodes full of twists, violence and bloodbath, the finale is very quite. There’s no drama, no shocking twist or cliffhangers but a lot of sentiments and feelings of normal people dealing with sad situations. The explanation of Dar Adal’s presence in Haqqani’s car is very plausible. Dar Adal that everyone already saw as a traitor in last episode, actually had a good move in the espionage world. Let us not forget that espionage is no other than a world with no place for morals. That’s why Saul kind of accepted that.

    The brief making-out of Carrie and Quinn is necessary to keep the audience’s interest. It’s the prelude of the next season. It’s good to have them separated for awhile. When these two stay permanently together, it announces the end of the series. Quinn is gone in black-op missions but we know we won’t lose him. The fact that he is sent to Syria might be a hint for next season. Syria is the territory of the terrorist ISIS. Saul’s “betrayal” is the trigger of another kind of relationship between him and Carrie if Carrie is still with the CIA and Saul the next director. Now we can expect Saul-Dar Adal team to face new plots next year.

    I only hope that Haqqani’s story isn’t over yet. With him, there still is that woman Tasneem (spelling?) that I want to see executed by Quinn. I just regret that Fara isn’t revenged. Maybe next season?

    The tribute to actor James Rebhorn is touching.

  6. anti climatice stinkaroo

More TV News from Variety