Film Review: ‘Next Year Jerusalem’

Next Year Jerusalem Review

A trip to the Holy Land for eight nursing-home residents gets bland treatment in David Gaynes' documentary.

Eight residents of a Connecticut nursing home take a trip to Israel. No, this isn’t the opening line from “Old Jews Telling Jokes”; it’s David Gaynes’ documentary “Next Year Jerusalem,” a predictably banal celebration of scrappy alter kockers (from Fairfield County’s Jewish Home for the Elderly) who pay a visit to the Holy Land. Sure, some of these dames and geezers are fun, and it’s heartening to see them pushing themselves for what’s likely their last expedition, yet Gaynes forgets that even schmaltz needs salt and pepper. Jewish fests and synagogue movie nights will attract the blue-rinse crowd.

Whose idea was it to bring this group, average age 91, to Israel? Probably Andrew Banoff, president of the Jewish Home for the Elderly (and listed as executive producer), or maybe it came from the residents themselves. There’s wry Sandy Levin, gentlemanly Leslie Novis, rakish Bill Wein, enthusiastic Helen Downs and, sure to be everyone’s favorite, warmly tenacious Selma Rosenblatt. Several need wheelchairs, others get by with walkers, and most find the daily tedium of life in a nursing home to be, well, tedious.

Notwithstanding logistical and medical problems, the trip goes off without a hitch. Downs, apparently the sole Christian apart from the caregivers, gets her feet wet in the Jordan. A game Harry Shell gets waylaid by parasitic Hasidim who want to make him more Jewish at the Western Wall. Regine Arouette connects with a fellow “hidden child” Holocaust survivor at Yad Vashem. And that’s basically it: They go with cautious yet excited optimism, they tour with zeal, they return exhausted but with a sense of fulfillment.

“Next Year Jerusalem” is chockablock with missed opportunities: Apart from nurse Donnette Banton, a radiant presence, none of the caregivers get screentime, though their stories and interactions with their charges could have added some much-needed substance. What Israel means for the elderly travelers is left unaddressed; Arouette’s undoubtedly fascinating story is passed over; and apart from some very generic lines about the approaching inevitability of death, no one has even a remotely philosophical thing to offer about life and its finite hold on our consciousness. The whole documentary is kind of like a child visiting a grandmother in a nursing home: Genial pleasantries are exchanged, a few hoary jokes are told, and then it’s time to go back to a room that never disguises its resemblance to a hospital ward.

Gaynes throws in a lot of unnecessary filler, especially shots of clouds, in order to get past the 60-minute mark. Otherwise, tech credits are standard, with innocuous music accompanying the journey.

Film Review: 'Next Year Jerusalem'

Reviewed online, Rome, June 1, 2014. Running time: 72 MIN.


(Documentary) A First Run Features release of a JHE175 Pictures production. Produced by David Gaynes, Jessica Wolfson. Executive producer, Andrew Banoff.


Directed, written by David Gaynes. Camera (color, HD), Gaynes; editor, Aaron Wolfe; music, Christopher Garofalo; sound, Eric Budney, Alex Noyes; sound designer, Noyes; associate producers, Carrie Frank, Deana Bedor.


Sandy Levin, Juna Wein, Bill Wein, Leslie Novis, Selma Rosenblatt, Andrew Banoff, Helen Downs, Harry Shell, Regine Arouette, Steven Shulman, Ellen Ashkins, Donnette Banton, Audrey Stein, Ya’akov Sivak, Yusuf Bader.
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety