Melissa McCarthy’s ‘Tammy’ Is Just Not Funny, Say Critics

Tammy Movie Melissa McCarthy

Melissa McCarthy’s “Tammy” kicked off its Independence Day weekend release with a solid $1.3 million at the Tuesday night box office, but critics are saying McCarthy and husband Ben Falcone’s dream project is just not that funny.

McCarthy plays the title role in “Tammy,” the story of a fired fast-food employee who takes a road trip with her alcoholic and promiscuous grandmother (Susan Sarandon). Toni Collette and Kathy Bates also star.

Reviews so far have not been so kind, with the film earning only a 21% approval rate on Rotten Tomatoes.

Variety’s Justin Chang called the movie a middling misfire” which “never rises above the level of amiable mediocrity.” But critics’ assessments of the raunchy comedy go south from there.

Perhaps the most scathing takedown comes from the New York Observer’s Rex Reed, who previously came under fire for comments about McCarthy’s size. “‘Tammy’is not just a celebration of everything vulgar and stupid in the dumbing down of American movies. It’s a rambling, pointless and labored attempt to cash in on Ms. McCarthy’s fan base without respect for any audience with a collective IQ of 10. And it’s about as funny as a liver transplant,” writes Reed.

USA Today says,Tammy aspires to be a latter-day ‘Thelma & Louise,’ and since it co-stars Susan Sarandon, one could say at least it has its Louise. But that’s about it.”

Time’s Richard Corliss snarked that “Tammy” “could be an artifact from some alternate universe: the creatures there resemble Earthlings but have an entirely different and debased idea of what’s funny. Arriving in time for the July 4 weekend, ‘Tammy’ has the effect of a shoddily manufactured firecracker that weakly goes off in your hands — leaving no permanent damage, just a bitter memory.”

Some of the reviews were pretty harsh, with the Hollywood Reporter saying, “The film progresses from merely unfunny to unconvincing to dull.” The Seattle Times agrees: “It just isn’t very funny.”

Christy Lemire, writing on, was somewhat kinder, though she agreed with most reviewers that McCarthy’s shtick is starting to wear thin. But “the intention is admirable,” she wrote, “as is the focus on flawed female characters and the way they relate to each other.”

Still how dependent on reviews is the box office success of the film? “Tammy” is up against two other movies with less-than-favorable reviews this weekend—“Transformers: Age of Extinction” and “Deliver Us From Evil.”

Even with the critics’ disapproval, McCarthy’s star power may be enough to get people into the theaters.

“Tammy” is expected to earn $40 million over its first five days of release.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 8

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Martha christensen says:

    that show was so funny and she was a great actress

  2. Not funny says:

    She’s not even funny. She’s trying too hard to be funny, and it just feels forced
    and obnoxious.

  3. Caitlin says:

    It sucks that the movie didn’t turn out well. I really like Melissa McCarthy. Hopefully they learn from their mistakes and keep trying.

  4. Gail Powell says:

    I saw the movie the first day it came out and for a holiday flick, it was entertaining. But the plot that depicts such horrendous family dysfunction is frankly, depressing. Even though Tammy manages to rise above her dismal circumstances, it is through theft, elder sex, wrecked jet skis, lots of booze and tons of junk food–(Tammy loves sugar donuts and pies.) Really thinking through this movie left me thinking that the great middle of America seems to be obese, catty and loves their liquor way too much!

  5. ThomT says:

    McCarthy seems to be following in the footsteps of many male comedians before her (Sandler, Chase, Farrell, Carrey, etc.). Find a “character” and repeat it until it’s not only no longer funny but also not drawing a audience. Biggest difference here seems to be McCarthy was able to reach this point without doing a couple of seasons of SNL.

  6. NinaMarie says:

    I saw it today with my husband, and we had a laugh! I enjoyed it. Sure, it’s not “meaningful” and Academy Award material….it’s just silly fun. Lighten up.

  7. Kingslayer says:

    Her whole schtick was old by the time she did Bridesmaids. Everything she’s done since has been horrendous. She’s just not funny in general.

More Film News from Variety