Film Review: ‘Trash’

Rio Film Festival Trash Movie

Stephen Daldry’s Brazilian answer to 'Slumdog Millionaire' features a trio of charismatic slum-dwelling kids who stumble upon evidence certain to bring down a corrupt politico.

Cleanly scripted in pure Hollywood fashion by Richard Curtis (with Felipe Braga translating it into Portuguese), Stephen Daldry’s “Trash” won’t be confused for a real Brazilian production: Its storyline, staging and inevitably positive spin unmistakably mark it as offshore, notwithstanding the participation of Fernando Meirelles’ 02 Filmes. A South American answer of sorts to “Slumdog Millionaire,” the pic features a trio of charismatic kids living next to a Rio garbage dump who stumble upon evidence certain to bring down a corrupt politico. Audience-friendly to a fault, “Trash” should be a modest money earner for Universal Intl., which will no doubt pitch it along “Slumdog” lines.

Andy Mulligan’s source novel was geared toward adolescents, but the film feels like more adult fare simply because young teens aren’t exactly known for their attraction to subtitles. English makes up a small percentage of the dialogue, mostly coming from Martin Sheen and Rooney Mara, the necessary U.S. stars, one guesses, to ensure a decent budget and increase chances for worldwide success. Brazilian headliners Selton Mello and Wagner Moura are safe guarantors of South American interest, and the anti-corruption lines at the end, aimed at Brazilian viewers, testify to the producers’ desire to work all angles. A co-director credit to acting coach Christian Duurvoort no doubt signals his heavy involvement in guiding local actors in their own language.

“Trash” works in large part thanks to the infectious energy and sheer pleasure in comradeship exuded by the three young teen boys, all around 14 years old (Daldry’s facility with boy actors once again stands him in good stead). The kids live in a lakeside favela, spending their days sorting trash at the municipal dump next door. Superb editing by Elliot Graham economically yet clearly crams in all the needed information in the first 10 minutes or so as characters are introduced.

White-collar guy Jose Angelo (Moura) is captured during a police raid just after tossing a wallet onto a passing garbage truck. While Jose is tortured and killed by the cops in one part of town, Raphael (Rickson Tevis) finds the portfolio in his local trash heap, and shares the cash with friend Gardo (Eduardo Luis). When cops come sniffing around, offering a reward for the return of the wallet, Raphael gets suspicious and starts wondering about the key he found inside. The boys confide in sewer-dwelling peer Rato (Gabriel Weinstein), who recognizes the key as belonging to a set of lockers downtown.

In the locker, they find a piece of paper with some code, and then head back to the favela and Father Julliard (Sheen), whose computer is their window to the world (illiteracy rates have fallen significantly in Rio’s favelas, so it’s not so farfetched that these kids are Google-fluent). The good priest is of that stock-in-trade, a social-activist man of the cloth who takes swigs from the communion cup, arrived from the States decades earlier to minister to the poor. He’s assisted by newcomer Olivia (Mara), who teaches the boys English, among other undefined tasks. “Don’t waste your life fighting battles that make you bitter or make you dead,” says Julliard to Olivia, succinctly signaling his Acme brand of priestly tired cynicism.

The line also stands in contrast to the boys’ refusal to give up when they sense they’re on the verge of discovering something important, no matter the danger. When Rafael doesn’t show up for garbage-picking duty, sadistic police inspector Frederico (Mello) gets suspicious and tries to dispose of the boy, but he survives and overhears the cops mention mayoral candidate Antonio Santos (Stepan Nercessian). With Olivia’s help, Gardo goes to a maximum-security prison to see Clemente (Nelson Xavier), uncle to Jose Angelo and the addressee of a letter the boys found. Following this cheesily over-emotional meeting, the kids scope out Santos’ home and learn that Jose Angelo stole around $4 million in payoff money, along with Santos’ ledger detailing all the bribery payments.

Daldry cleverly weaves in excerpts from a direct-to-camera video the boys make, using the device to compact information in a less didactic manner, and to deepen the trio’s palpable bond. In plot terms, this is classic underdogs-beat-the-system material, down to an improbably happy ending that bears no relation to the realism Daldry haphazardly aims for (and frequently misses); a late revelation about Jose Angelo’s daughter is particularly silly. Far better are the exciting chase sequences, and to Daldry’s credit, he avoids using the usual Rio locations, saving the pic from turning into a tourism promo. Oddly, religion plays an important role, not just through Father Julliard but in the frequent references to God’s protection and the like; the film could be retitled “Our Lady of Trash,” given its subtle implication that faith protects the kids from Frederico’s evil designs.

Cavils melt before the 1,000-watt charms of Tevis, Luis and Weinstein, all non-pros whose joy before the camera, and in each others’ company, transcends the more standard elements in the material. These kids deserve their own TV series. Sheen does what he can with a stereotyped character, but Mara’s role suffers from a lack of personality.

Unfailingly attractive lensing by Adriano Goldman (“Jane Eyre,” “August: Osage County”) is especially good at including the environment around the characters, despite a tendency to make it all look a bit too pretty. Although the favela sits on stilts in a rubbish-strewn lake (made for the occasion), next to the city dump, this is a remarkably clean production  even Rato’s body sores seem more pancake makeup than uncomfortable lesions. Antonio Pinto’s intrusive music has an annoying habit of anticipating action and mood.

Film Review: 'Trash'

Reviewed at Rio de Janeiro Film Festival (closer), Sept. 30, 2014. Running time: 113 MIN.  


(U.K.) A Universal Pictures Intl. (worldwide) release of a Universal presentation of a Working Title Films production, in association with O2 Filmes, PeaPie Films. Produced by Tim Bevan, Eric Fellner, Kris Thykier. Executive producers, Bel Berlinck, Andrea Barata Ribeiro, Fernando Meirelles, Amelia Granger, Liza Chasin.


Directed by Stephen Daldry. Co-director (Brazil), Christian Duurvoort. Screenplay, Richard Curtis, based on the novel by Andy Mulligan; script consultant, Felipe Braga. Camera (color, widescreen), Adriano Goldman; editor, Elliot Graham; music, Antonio Pinto; production designer, Tule Peak; art director, Pedro Equi; costume designer, Bia Salgado; sound (Dolby digital), Glenn Freemantle, Paulo Ricardo Nunes; visual effects supervisor, Adam Rowland; stunt coordinator, Marcio Caldas; line producer, Cristina Abi; associate producers, Marieke Spencer, Pip Williams; assistant directors, Richard Styles, Isabel Valiante; casting, Chico Accioly.  


Selton Mello, Wagner Moura, Rooney Mara, Martin Sheen, Rickson Tevis, Eduardo Luis, Gabriel Weinstein, Nelson Xavier, Stepan Nercessian, Teca Pereira, Conceicao Camarotti, Jesuita Barbosa, Charles Paraventi, Enrique Diaz, Leandro Firmino, Gisele Froes, Andre Ramiro, Magdale Alves, Maria Eduarda Lima Botelho, Jose Dumont, Christiane Amanpour. (Portuguese, English dialogue)

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 5

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. why is it that there are no any biographical entries of the four kids???

  2. fox5411 says:

    Genuinely wonderful movie with a brilliant sound track and well produced. Wish some of the characters played by Martin Sheen and Rooney Mara had been better developed. There was only so much they could do to develop them any further as actors. Both Rara and Sheen are world class actors . Stereotyped characters for Rara and Sheen limited their performances. Still a great film!

  3. Sandra Lamb says:

    I have been waiting for a US release on this movie, but cannot find one. Any word on if/when it will be released her in the States?

  4. María Brewer says:

    A person Who slightly knows about Latin American culture would understand better that religion is an essential part of it, specially among simple people who seeks hope and comfort through it. So it is completely right done and accurate the religion reference in the movie represented on the boy’s constant prayer. For people with Latin American roots it does not seems exaggerated but completely natural. A brief review of religious statistic in Latin Americans countries would help you understand it better.

  5. Norma Dietrich says:

    I want trash dated December 27-2014

More Film News from Variety