SAG Awards: Predictions in an Unpredictable Year

Sag Awards Nominations Predictions

Sorry critics, but the SAG Awards are the first of the true precursor honors that indicate which way the Academy Awards may be leading. The nominees are voted on by 4,200 SAG members selected at random every year — 2,100 vote on film awards, 2,100 vote on TV awards. The full SAG-AFTRA voting body then selects the winners, who will be announced in a ceremony on Jan. 25, 2015. The nominees will be announced on Dec. 10 at an ungodly hour.

Last year, all four SAG award winners in film went on to score the Academy Award. (The fifth category, best ensemble, has no Oscar equivalent, though many erroneously associate it with best picture.) Still, there are always some anomalies in matching up the races every year — I still wonder if voters thought they were casting ballots for Melanie Laurent in “Inglourious Basterds” the year Diane Kruger got a nod.

And because the nominations are announced early, it’s not always possible for voters to see all the films. Every year, there is a film that gets shut out because screeners didn’t go out in time – -last year it was “The Wolf of Wall Street,” the year before it was “Django Unchained.” This year, “Selma” failed to get screeners out on time — a shame, considering the fantastic performances in the film. There are also several actors who have been unable to promote their films as much as others, which also can hurt their odds in such a competitive year.

Here is a completely unscientific take on the likely nominees we’ll hear called Wednesday morning.

Supporting Actress:
Likely Nominees: Patricia Arquette, “Boyhood”; Meryl Streep, “Into the Woods”; Keira Knightley, “The Imitation Game”; Emma Stone, “Birdman”; Jessica Chastain, “A Most Violent Year”
Possibilities: Laura Dern, “Wild”; Sienna Miller, “American Sniper”; Naomi Watts, “Birdman”

There are three locks for this category: Arquette, Streep and Knightley. Chastain’s film has yet to be seen by many voters, but if they pop in their screeners, her turn as a mob-connected housewife is tough to ignore. And actors love her. Emma Stone’s Broadway commitments to “Cabaret” have kept her out of circulation and she has to compete with three other great supporting actress in her film — including possible nominee Naomi Watts. But actors love “Birdman” and her. Laura Dern is a very strong possibility to bump one of the nominees for her excellent work in “Wild.” And it’s hard to know SAG’s response to “American Sniper” just yet, but Sienna Miller could have an impact as the wife of Navy SEAL Chris Kyle.

Supporting Actor:
Likely Nominees: J.K. Simmons, “Whiplash”; Edward Norton, “Birdman”; Mark Ruffalo, “Foxcatcher”; Ethan Hawke, “Boyhood”; Robert Duvall, “The Judge”
Possibilities: Josh Brolin, “Inherent Vice”; Tom Wilkinson, “Selma”; Miyavi, “Unbroken”

Supporting actor has really come down to two showy performances: Simmons and Norton. While more subtle work doesn’t always garner awards attention, Ruffalo and Hawke are respected actors who do great work in their films. The fifth slot likely belongs to Duvall, the standout of “The Judge.” SAG loves Duvall — they nominated him for “Get Low” when Oscar failed to. But even those who don’t love “Inherent Vice” think highly of Brolin’s work as a hippie-hating cop. Possible spoilers are brewing with Miyavi and the great Wilkinson but “Selma” has to overcome the no-screener obstacle.

Likely Nominees: Michael Keaton, “Birdman”; Eddie Redmayne, “The Theory of Everything”; Benedict Cumberbatch, “The Imitation Game”; Steve Carell, “Foxcatcher”; Bradley Cooper, “American Sniper”
Possibilities: Timothy Spall, “Mr. Turner”; Jake Gyllenhaal, “Nightcrawler”; David Oyelowo, “Selma”; Ralph Fiennes, “The Grand Budapest Hotel,” Jack O’Connell, “Unbroken”; Oscar Isaac, “A Most Violent Year”

By far the most competitive category, made up of great performances that actors adore. If screeners had gone out in time, I would consider Oyelowo more of a sure thing — still, don’t wouldn’t count him out for Golden Globe or Oscar noms. Comedy is tough to be recognized for, but Fiennes is great in “Grand Budapest” and if SAG responds to the movie, it could be a surprise nominee. The same could be said of O’Connell and Isaac. Spall and Gyllenhaal have smaller movies with passionate fanbases, and could displace one of the expected nominees — most likely Carell or Cooper.  Keaton, Redmayne and Cumberbatch are the only safe bets in this race.

Likely Nominees: Julianne Moore, “Still Alice”; Reese Witherspoon, “Wild”; Hilary Swank, “The Homesman”; Felicity Jones, “The Theory of Everything”; Rosamund Pike, “Gone Girl”
Possibilities: Marion Cotillard, “Two Days, One Night”; Amy Adams, “Big Eyes”; Jennifer Aniston, “Cake”; Jenny Slate, “Obvious Child”

The prize is Moore’s to lose, but Witherspoon will provide some serious competition. Jones and Pike are fresh discoveries (though both have been working for years) in strong female roles during a year that lacked them. The remaining spot is likely going to Swank, who gets a meaty role and is appreciated by her fellow actors — SAG recognized her for “Conviction” when Oscar failed to. Cotillard is fantastic, but few have seen the Belgian film she stars in. Audiences are enjoying Aniston’s transformative work, but it’s unclear if “Cake” screeners have gone out. And Adams is beloved, but if she couldn’t score a nom for “American Hustle” last year, she might have an even harder battle with the coolly-received “Big Eyes.” So how great would an out-of-left-field choice like Slate be? Actors love her, “Obvious Child” was an indie hit — don’t count her out.

Likely Nominees: “Boyhood,” “Birdman,” “Into the Woods,” “Foxcatcher,” “The Imitation Game”
Possibilities: “Selma,” “Unbroken,” “The Grand Budapest Hotel,” “The Theory of Everything,” “Interstellar”

No matter how many times it’s said, best ensemble at SAG does not translate to best picture at the Oscars. Just ask “American Hustle,” “The Help” or “Inglourious Basterds.” SAG tends to go for big and starry, which is why “Birdman,” “The Imitation Game” and “Into the Woods” are sitting pretty. “Woods” also has the benefit of being a musical, which SAG voters love — remember the two nominations for “Nine”? Breaking the big ensemble rule is “Boyhood,” which is just too adored to overlook. The last spot is a tough call. If screeners had gone out for “Selma,” it would be a sure thing. Paramount had the same problem last year with “The Wolf of Wall Street,” but that didn’t affect its Oscar recognition. Hopefully enough voters went to screenings to see the film. “Unbroken” has played well to SAG crowds, but who knows how the epic fares on home TVs. “Interstellar” is a big hit with a great cast, but if Christopher Nolan couldn’t get ensemble love for “The Dark Knight” or “Inception,” it seems unlikely. “Theory” has two surefire acting nominees and while it’s seen as a two-hander, that might be enough. Sometimes voters like to throw in a wild card, and few are wilder or more fun than “Grand Budapest.” But I suspect the last slot will go to another small ensemble with the superbly acted “Foxcatcher.”

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 12

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. james says:

    In my opinion Bradley Cooper is the best actor of the year and American Sniper is the best film of the year.

  2. Tenaya says:

    Was super bummed about “Selma” screeners not getting out. Hoping Oyelowo will be nominated anyway, if his performance is as amazing as many are saying. “Cake” screener did get out, and I’m hoping Aniston will be nominated, too. Her portrayal of a woman living with chronic pain brought tears to my eyes, in little moments that surprised me. I agree with Juliet that Knightly was great in “The Imitation Game,” too. :)

  3. Juliet says:

    I thought Knightley was not just good, but great in The Imitation Game. She took a role that could have fallen by the wayside and infused it with spirit and gravitas and she nailed that performance. The best I’ve seen her. I think she would well deserve a SAG nomination.

  4. Paul says:

    Agata Trzebuchowska for Ida should be nominated!

  5. Emil says:

    Hey, Diane Kruger was great in “Inglorious Basterds”, why the hate? Weinstein should’ve never dumped “The Immigrant” — it now looks like his best shot at Best Actress. And Cotillard should be in the conversation for both roles.

  6. steve barr says:

    Cotilard is fantastic in The Immigrant . No one saw it. Harvey Weinstein dumped the fim .

  7. ts garp says:

    As a member of SAG, who has never been on a nominating committee, i can safely say that year-in and year-out these nominations are embarrassing. I really wish they would put the nominations in the hands of working actors, so these nominations were more respectable and didn’t just go to the actors with the best PR team.

  8. jj says:

    I hear Marion Cotillard gives hands down the best performance of the year. So let’s not pretend she doesn’t.

  9. Stergios says:

    I don’t think Naomi Watts’ otherwise great turn in Birdman will be prefered to Emma Stone’s amazing performance.

    • Ryan says:

      Agreed. The emma stone character is much more profound.watts is amazing but stone is better. And no sure why keira knightley is a lock? She was good but stone,arquette,chastain are way better.

      • Stergios says:

        So well said! Watts is expectedly brilliant in Birdman, but Stone simply knocks it out of the park. She’s clearly better there. I think Keira Knightley is really good in The Imitation Game but in a year when we had astonishing female performances in supporting roles like Julianne Moore’s in Maps to the stars, Agata Kulesza’s in Ida (both performances are co-leading but are clearly considered as supporting for The Oscars), Carrie Coon’s in Gone Girl and Laura Dern’s in Wild, it’s probably a little too much to watch Knightley being considered a lock. Personally, I liked her even more in Begin Again and Laggies this year, but whatever.

  10. Tali Adina says:

    Reblogged this on Uncanny Pop and commented:

More Film News from Variety