Adding ‘Red Dawn Fantasy’ to Gun-Control Issue

In my contribution to Variety’s special report on media and violence, I discuss two unwitting elements movies and news introduce to the problem: Creating the perception of a scary world, which makes more people feel like they need a gun for protection; and “Dirty Harry” syndrome, where, as the NRA so eloquently put it, all it takes to stop a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun — even if said “good guy” is just an ordinary citizen.

The blog Talkingpointsmemo, however, has an additional facet that is worth noting — what a reader refers to as the “‘Red Dawn’ Fantasy,” citing the 1980s era (and since remade) movie in which a group of plucky Americans defend themselves from foreign invaders.

Quoting from the site: If you ask those who insist they must own one or more assault rifles and
semi-automatic pistols with high capacity magazines, the answer you’ll
hear over and over again is: I want to be ready to defend America
against the Commies, the terrorists, the immigrant invaders, the United
Nations, and yes, even the government of the United States of America.
That’s the Red Dawn fantasy.

As someone who once had a guy in Valdosta, Georgia, tell me how he needed his guns to fight off the government or terrorists, I think they’re on to something there. (Valdosta — with a population of 56,000 — seems like a less likely target than Los Angeles, but I sensed pretty soon trying to reason with him wasn’t going to make either of us any happier.)

Of course, to hear the most ardent 2nd Amendment advocates tell it, the need for guns right now includes the ability to overthrow a U.S. dictatorship, which is certainly ambitious, given that even AK-47s are no match for tanks, missiles and nukes, which is a point “The Daily Show” also made in its brilliant coverage of the issue since returning from its holiday break.

The point is there is all sorts of mythology and romance surrounding gun ownership, much of it stoked — in some ways subconsciously — by the very media the NRA has targeted as a cause of violence in society that merits more attention than guns.

As I stated the first time around, the media are a factor. It’s just not in the way many people like to think.

 

More Voices

  • The Lion King Broadway

    How 'The Lion King' Ushered in the Era of the Blockbuster on Broadway

    In my contribution to Variety’s special report on media and violence, I discuss two unwitting elements movies and news introduce to the problem: Creating the perception of a scary world, which makes more people feel like they need a gun for protection; and “Dirty Harry” syndrome, where, as the NRA so eloquently put it, all […]

  • Kevin Spacey Clarance Darrow Broadway

    Broadway Gets Serious About Sexual Harassment

    In my contribution to Variety’s special report on media and violence, I discuss two unwitting elements movies and news introduce to the problem: Creating the perception of a scary world, which makes more people feel like they need a gun for protection; and “Dirty Harry” syndrome, where, as the NRA so eloquently put it, all […]

  • Scrips Discovery Partnership

    A Merger Between Scripps and Discovery Could Be a Smart Fit

    In my contribution to Variety’s special report on media and violence, I discuss two unwitting elements movies and news introduce to the problem: Creating the perception of a scary world, which makes more people feel like they need a gun for protection; and “Dirty Harry” syndrome, where, as the NRA so eloquently put it, all […]

  • profiles theatre Sexual Harassment

    Sexual Harassment in the Theater: How Chicago Fought Back

    In my contribution to Variety’s special report on media and violence, I discuss two unwitting elements movies and news introduce to the problem: Creating the perception of a scary world, which makes more people feel like they need a gun for protection; and “Dirty Harry” syndrome, where, as the NRA so eloquently put it, all […]

  • TV Television problems Expenses Placeholder

    Netflix Has Secret Weapon in Hollywood's Multibillion-Dollar Arms Race

    In my contribution to Variety’s special report on media and violence, I discuss two unwitting elements movies and news introduce to the problem: Creating the perception of a scary world, which makes more people feel like they need a gun for protection; and “Dirty Harry” syndrome, where, as the NRA so eloquently put it, all […]

  • sweeney Todd Barrow Street Theatre

    Commercial Off Broadway Isn't Dead -- It's Turning Into Broadway

    In my contribution to Variety’s special report on media and violence, I discuss two unwitting elements movies and news introduce to the problem: Creating the perception of a scary world, which makes more people feel like they need a gun for protection; and “Dirty Harry” syndrome, where, as the NRA so eloquently put it, all […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content