You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

TV Review: ‘The Goldbergs’

Another coming-of-age comedy that's better on paper than in the execution

Cast:

Wendi McLendon-Covey, Patton Oswalt, Sean Giambrone, Troy Gentile, Hayley Orrantia, George Segal, Jeff Garlin

The best part about “The Goldbergs,” alas, comes at the very end, when we see video footage of the actual characters who inspired this autobiographical comedy. It’s a link to humanity and reality in a half-hour that often feels shrill and exaggerated — something that desperately wants to be this generation’s “The Wonder Years,” albeit by leaping back to a moment not long before that ABC series made its debut. There’s a lot of coming-of-age nostalgia in the ether (Hulu’s “Moone Boy” trod much the same territory), but series creator Adam Goldberg’s prism on his past too often feels like a good idea, and a missed opportunity.

It’s 1985, and Goldberg’s alter ego is 12-year-old Adam (Sean Giambrone), who has a new videocamera he uses to torment his older sister (Hayley Orrantia), brother (Troy Gentile) and parents, Murray (Jeff Garlin, in near-cardiac-arrest mode) and Beverly (Wendi McLendon-Covey, the show’s strongest asset).

Narrated by Patton Oswalt, the series recalls a time when there were “no parenting blogs or peanut allergies,” and in that respect, it should resonate with those currently obsessing about such things regarding their own kids.

As fertile as the mid-1980s are for comedy, however, the pilot is too often grating — with a little of Garlin, in particular, going a long way. And while Goldberg’s household was no doubt a boisterous place, filled with expressions of affection disguised as hurled insults (a recurring bit translates Murray’s broadsides onscreen), in old-fashioned TV terms, “The Goldbergs” simply aren’t particularly good company.

There are, naturally, a lot of pubescent possibilities, such as Adam’s grandfather (George Segal) dragging him to the Waffle House, coaxing him to flirt with a slightly older girl who has caught the lad’s eye.

Still, writers are so inextricably drawn to their own wonder years, there’s no shortage of material devoted to it. And that sets the bar pretty high for such an exercise — particularly if it has to adhere to broadcast content standards — unless you’re roughly Adam’s age, in which case all this seems minty fresh.

Those closing scenes, however, do offer at least a ray of hope, if “The Goldbergs” can find a way to connect the historical to the fanciful. (As a side note, based on the real family photo, one of Adam’s siblings underwent a sex change for sitcom purposes.)

Without threading that needle, however, any criticism directed at “The Goldbergs” won’t require subtextual translation.

TV Review: 'The Goldbergs'

(Series; ABC, Tues. Sept. 24, 9 p.m.)

Production:

Filmed in Los Angeles by Happy Madison in association with Sony Pictures Television.

Crew:

Executive producers, Adam F. Goldberg, Doug Robinson, Seth Gordon; director, Gordon; writer, Goldberg. 30 MIN.

Cast:

Wendi McLendon-Covey, Patton Oswalt, Sean Giambrone, Troy Gentile, Hayley Orrantia, George Segal, Jeff Garlin

More TV

  • Bill OReilly Roger Ailes Sexual Harrassment

    Bill O'Reilly, Roger Ailes Still Loom Over Fox's Business (Analysis)

    The best part about “The Goldbergs,” alas, comes at the very end, when we see video footage of the actual characters who inspired this autobiographical comedy. It’s a link to humanity and reality in a half-hour that often feels shrill and exaggerated — something that desperately wants to be this generation’s “The Wonder Years,” albeit […]

  • RuPaul

    RuPaul Reveals the Queens Competing in 'RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars' Season 3

    The best part about “The Goldbergs,” alas, comes at the very end, when we see video footage of the actual characters who inspired this autobiographical comedy. It’s a link to humanity and reality in a half-hour that often feels shrill and exaggerated — something that desperately wants to be this generation’s “The Wonder Years,” albeit […]

  • Donald Trump

    SAG-AFTRA Supports 'Unencumbered Press' After Trump's License Revocation Threat

    The best part about “The Goldbergs,” alas, comes at the very end, when we see video footage of the actual characters who inspired this autobiographical comedy. It’s a link to humanity and reality in a half-hour that often feels shrill and exaggerated — something that desperately wants to be this generation’s “The Wonder Years,” albeit […]

  • Brent Briscoe Dead: 'Twin Peaks' and

    Brent Briscoe, 'Twin Peaks' and 'Parks and Recreation' Actor, Dies at 56

    The best part about “The Goldbergs,” alas, comes at the very end, when we see video footage of the actual characters who inspired this autobiographical comedy. It’s a link to humanity and reality in a half-hour that often feels shrill and exaggerated — something that desperately wants to be this generation’s “The Wonder Years,” albeit […]

  • 'Magnum P.I.' Reboot in Development at

    'Magnum P.I.' Reboot in Development at CBS From Peter Lenkov With Production Commitment

    The best part about “The Goldbergs,” alas, comes at the very end, when we see video footage of the actual characters who inspired this autobiographical comedy. It’s a link to humanity and reality in a half-hour that often feels shrill and exaggerated — something that desperately wants to be this generation’s “The Wonder Years,” albeit […]

  • YouTube logo

    TV News Roundup: YouTube Greenlights Tinder-Themed Comedy 'Swipe Right'

    The best part about “The Goldbergs,” alas, comes at the very end, when we see video footage of the actual characters who inspired this autobiographical comedy. It’s a link to humanity and reality in a half-hour that often feels shrill and exaggerated — something that desperately wants to be this generation’s “The Wonder Years,” albeit […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content