TV Review: ‘Mob City’

Mob City TV Review

Frank Darabont's period 'L.A. Noir' adaptation proves great looking but dramatically hollow

Great-looking but dramatically flaccid, “Mob City” mines the same territory as “L.A. Confidential” and James Ellroy’s noir thrillers, with hollow results. Loosely adapted by writer-director Frank Darabont from the nonfiction book “L.A. Noir,” this exceptionally well-cast series nearly chokes on its own murkiness, and initially indulges in talky interludes that exhaust tolerance for period jargon. TNT scheduled back-to-back episodes for three successive weeks, ostensibly to create a limited-event feel but also (in the glass-half-full department) condensing the show’s footprint if viewers don’t respond. Set in 1947 — the same year as the Black Dahlia murder — it’s a noble effort and a squandered opportunity.

Reuniting Darabont with “The Walking Dead” co-stars John Bernthal and Jeffrey DeMunn, the project centers on Bernthal’s Det. Joe Teague, a taciturn ex-Marine working as part of an elite unit within the L.A. Police Dept. Calling the shots is ambitious chief-to-be William Parker (Neal McDonough), even as mobsters like Mickey Cohen (Jeremy Luke) and Bugsy Siegel (Ed Burns) are exerting their power and influence throughout the city.

In the premiere, Joe gets drawn into an extortion attempt run against a mobster by a comedian (Simon Pegg), whose circle includes a classic femme fatale (Alexa Davalos, seemingly trying to channel a young Lauren Bacall).

Saying much more about whether Teague is a dirty cop on a force full of them, or what otherwise motivates him, would run afoul of spoiler warnings, but suffice to say none of the twists are so unexpected that you can’t see them telegraphed via Western Union.

Darabont does cleverly employ flashbacks to depict the roots of L.A.’s criminal underbelly — revealing windows into the characters’ pasts — while filling his world with hard men who speak in clipped sentences. In that regard, casting actors like Robert Knepper, Milo Ventimiglia and DeMunn among the assorted cops and robbers certainly lends a patina of quality to the proceedings, but can’t trump the general sluggishness of the presentation — or, for aficionados of the period, the fact these same hoods and heroes have been fictionalized with more verve elsewhere.

The third and fourth hours do settle down and offer a bit more narrative clarity than the premiere but contain other questionable choices, like a poorly mounted shootout aboard a merry-go-round.

In some respects, with its stylized look and violence, “Mob City” bears less resemblance to its obvious predecessors (which beyond “L.A. Confidential” would include the short-lived “Crime Story” and, in mixing mob fact and fiction, “Boardwalk Empire”) than the screen adaptation of “Sin City,” Frank Miller’s hyper-violent graphic novel, which reveled in atmosphere at the expense of substance.

Darabont hardly needs redemption, but having unloaded on AMC over the circumstances regarding his “Dead” exit, it would have been nice if his next project was, well, better. As for TNT, the network has delivered a handsome, much-anticipated pilot, only to have the promos and marketing outshine the finished product. Then again, as crimes against television go, that one’s so common as to qualify as a misdemeanor.

TV Review: 'Mob City'

(Series; TNT, Wed. Dec. 4, 9 p.m.)


Filmed in Los Angeles by TNT Originals.


Executive producers, Frank Darabont, Michael De Luca, Elliot Webb; co-executive producers, Alissa Phillips, Dana Renee Ashmore; producers, Paul Bernard, Wayne Carmona; writer-director, Darabont; based on the book “L.A. Noir: The Struggle for the Soul of America’s Most Seductive City” by John Buntin; camera, David Tattersall; production designer, Gregory Melton; editor, Hunter M. Via; music, Mark Isham; casting, Deborah Aquila, Tricia Wood, Jennifer Smith. 120 MIN.


Jon Bernthal, Milo Ventimiglia, Neal McDonough, Alexa Davalos, Jeffrey DeMunn, Gregory Itzin, Robert Knepper, Jeremy Luke, Ed Burns

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 4

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Dave Smith says:

    Well, the limited 6-episode run of the (first?) season has now ended – time for an update on this show. I found that I liked it better and better as time went by, so that by the end of episode 6 I was looking for a new season to continue the saga of Mickey Cohen and William Parker, as set out in Buntin’s book.

    There’s a lot more left to tell, and I’d like to see Darabont given a chance to tell it.

  2. pourya says:

    do me a favor , just dont review tv shows anymore

  3. add says:

    The dumbest critic on the planet strikes again. This slob wouldn’t know a good TV show if it bit him on the ass. What a pathetic moron.

  4. Jean Marie Otte says:

    Mob City is an intelligent show that doesn’t spoon feed the audience . Darabont’s solid noir genre keeps you in the appropriate era with classic speak. Shocking twists keep you on the edge of your seat. Brilliant scripts, direction, and acting all complemented with beautiful production value. This will be my new favorite show.

More TV News from Variety