You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Appeals Court Rejects Tennis Channel’s Carriage Claim Against Comcast

Court overturns ruling that Comcast placed channel on less desirable cable system tiers

The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals has overturned the FCC’s ruling that Comcast unfairly placed Tennis Channel on less desirable cable system tiers from other sports channels in which Comcast has a significant stake.

The ruling was a blow to Tennis Channel’s protracted battle with the cable giant, one that has been watched closely in the industry as it represents the one of the few significant efforts to test program carriage regulations.

The three-judge panel of the D.C. Circuit ruled that the FCC, in siding with the Tennis Channel on Tuesday, “failed to identify adequate evidence of unlawful discrimination.” The opinion was written by Senior Circuit Judge Stephen Williams, an appointee of President Ronald Reagan. Two other judge each filed concurring opinions.

In a statement, Tennis Channel said that they are “disappointed with today’s decision and respectfully disagree.”

They added that “Comcast’s clear pattern of discrimination against Tennis Channel in favor of the competing networks that it owns — as detailed at length by the FCC — warrants further review of the panel’s decision and we intent to seek that review.”

Comcast placed Tennis Channel on a more expensive and less broadly distributed sports tier, but the D.C. Circuit ruled that Comcast’s rejection of efforts to obtain broader carriage was “simply ‘a straight up financial analysis,” as one of its executives put it.”

“Neither Tennis not the Commission has invoked the concept that an otherwise valid business consideration is here merely pretextual cover for some deeper discriminatory purpose,” Williams wrote in the opinion.

In a statement, Comcast said that they are “pleased” with the ruling and that “Tennis Channel received exactly the carriage it bargained for and agreed to. Comcast’s decision to carry Tennis Channel was the product of legitimate business considerations, not affiliation.”

More Biz

  • Harvey Weinstein

    Harvard University to Revoke Harvey Weinstein's Du Bois Medal

    The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals has overturned the FCC’s ruling that Comcast unfairly placed Tennis Channel on less desirable cable system tiers from other sports channels in which Comcast has a significant stake. The ruling was a blow to Tennis Channel’s protracted battle with the cable giant, one that has been watched closely in […]

  • Calif. lawmaker calls for ban of

    California Lawmaker Calls for Ban on Secret Settlements for Sexual Harassment (EXCLUSIVE)

    The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals has overturned the FCC’s ruling that Comcast unfairly placed Tennis Channel on less desirable cable system tiers from other sports channels in which Comcast has a significant stake. The ruling was a blow to Tennis Channel’s protracted battle with the cable giant, one that has been watched closely in […]

  • David Cross Says Charlyne Yi Is

    David Cross Accused of Racist Behavior by Charlyne Yi

    The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals has overturned the FCC’s ruling that Comcast unfairly placed Tennis Channel on less desirable cable system tiers from other sports channels in which Comcast has a significant stake. The ruling was a blow to Tennis Channel’s protracted battle with the cable giant, one that has been watched closely in […]

  • law and finance hollywood new leaders

    Hollywood's New Leaders in Law and Finance

    The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals has overturned the FCC’s ruling that Comcast unfairly placed Tennis Channel on less desirable cable system tiers from other sports channels in which Comcast has a significant stake. The ruling was a blow to Tennis Channel’s protracted battle with the cable giant, one that has been watched closely in […]

  • 10 Assistants to Watch hollywood new

    Variety's 10 Assistants to Watch Class of 2017

    The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals has overturned the FCC’s ruling that Comcast unfairly placed Tennis Channel on less desirable cable system tiers from other sports channels in which Comcast has a significant stake. The ruling was a blow to Tennis Channel’s protracted battle with the cable giant, one that has been watched closely in […]

  • Yu Dong, chairman and CEO of

    China’s Bona Poised to Raise $215 Million Through Local IPO

    The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals has overturned the FCC’s ruling that Comcast unfairly placed Tennis Channel on less desirable cable system tiers from other sports channels in which Comcast has a significant stake. The ruling was a blow to Tennis Channel’s protracted battle with the cable giant, one that has been watched closely in […]

  • R Stanton Dodge draftkings

    Dish Network Top Lawyer R. Stanton Dodge Exits to Join DraftKings

    The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals has overturned the FCC’s ruling that Comcast unfairly placed Tennis Channel on less desirable cable system tiers from other sports channels in which Comcast has a significant stake. The ruling was a blow to Tennis Channel’s protracted battle with the cable giant, one that has been watched closely in […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content