Opera Review: ‘Tosca’


If ever there’s an opera that resists wild interpretations, it’s Puccini’s tale of revolution, authoritarianism and unbridled lust in old Rome.

John Caird is best known to Broadway and L.A. auds for his staging of “Nicholas Nickleby” and “Les Miserables,” but he also helms operas, such as “Tosca,” now on display at LA Opera. If ever there’s an opera that resists wild interpretations, it’s Puccini’s tale of revolution, authoritarianism and unbridled lust in old Rome. Caird tries to half-reinvent this warhorse, and he only half succeeds thanks to a vocally robust cast.

“Tosca” takes place in three very real Roman locales: the Church of Sant’Andrea delle Valle (act one), the Palazzo Farnese (act two) and the Castel Sant’Angelo (act three). Caird wisely sticks to the church to set up the action that has the jealous diva Tosca (Sondra Radvanovsky) bickering with her lover-revolutionary Cavaradossi (Marco Berti) while fending off the unwanted advances of police chief Baron Scarpia (Lado Ataneli).

Instead of a well-appointed study in the palazzo, however, Caird has Scarpia operating from a storage room in act two, as if this chief of police has fallen on hard times. And in act three, the roof of the castle has been converted to a prison yard. Which must be the reason Tosca slits her own throat before she jumps to her death only a story or two below.

Much more confusing is the little girl decked out in her white communion dress who wanders around the sets and ultimately beckons Tosca to commit suicide. If she’s to represent Tosca’s Roman Catholic conscience, Caird hasn’t read his Catechism lately.

Even more than the locales, Puccini’s music resists reinterpretations of the text. Like a movie score, it signals very specific action: Tosca’s entrance in the church, Tosca’s spotting of the knife that she’ll use to kill Scarpia, Tosca’s frightened departure from Scarpia’s study.

Caird doesn’t ignore these music cues; he just comes up with different visuals. For example, the expansive music that cues Cavaradossi’s entrance in act three now accompanies the hoisting of a dead revolutionary, and so on. None of these are improvements on the original; they’re just different and, for the most part, slightly less effective and extraneous.

“Tosca,” fortunately, lives or dies on its three principal singers. And this “Tosca” lives victoriously.

Radvanovsky’s “Vissi d’arte” incited an extended ovation. High C holds no terror for Berti. And Ataneli brings real elegance to fascism. In the pit, Placido Domingo is a most supportive conductor — he never swamps his singers with Puccini’s lush orchestrations — but sometimes he’s too supportive. He could shape the score more rather than follow his singers’ lead.

Opera Review: 'Tosca'

An LA Opera presentation of an opera in three acts, music by Giacomo Puccini, libretto by Giuseppe Giacosa and Luigi Illica.


(Dorothy Chandler Pavilion, Los Angeles; 3,000 seats, $270 top)


 Conducted by Placido Domingo. Directed by John Caird. Sets and costumes, Bunny Christie; lighting, Duane Schuler. Opened on May 18, 2013. Reviewed May 30. Running time: 2 HOURS, 40 MIN.


With: Joshua Bloom, Philip Cokorinos, Marco Berti, Sondra Radvanovksy, Lado Ataneli, Rodell Rosel, Daniel Armstrong, Eden McCoy, Hunter Phillips.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 1

Leave a Reply

1 Comment

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Sheldon Roth, MD says:

    We saw the same performance, and agree with the tone and thrust of the review. But, would add that the sets were dismal, un-imaginative, not equal to Puccini’s ‘silver macaroni exquisitely tangled,’ and the tenor’s delivery was uneven, often bellicose, and the direction bizarre. Costumes were leftovers from a high school production of La Boheme. The Variety reviewer was charitable, he should have heard the criticisms from all the subscribers seated around us.

More Legit News from Variety