Legit Review: ‘Miss Julie’

'Miss Julie' stage review

For Sigmund Freud, it was anatomy. For Neil LaBute, destiny has always been about looks. Good looks, especially in men, mean that you’re a privileged, caddish user. How appropriate then that LaBute’s adaptation of August Strindberg’s “Miss Julie,” being given its world premiere at the Geffen, should find helmer Jo Bonney casting an actor with male-model good looks to be John, the rough upstart servant who attempts to switch roles with the heiress Julie. It’s inspired miscasting.

Or is putting Logan Marshall-Green together with Lily Rabe merely casting against type, and adding texture to an already multi-level battle of the sexes and classes? Frankly, Marshall-Green’s features are finer than Rabe’s. Also, his clear tenor is placed slightly higher than her raspy contralto. And when she snorts with laughter or burps after drinking too much wine, we believe Rabe. We don’t quite buy Marshall-Green when he sucks his teeth or drops a consonant at the end of a phrase.

A few minutes into this “Miss Julie,” you might think that the Geffen Playhouse started out with a traditionally cast “The Heiress” and then switched plays after losing a few key supporting players. Julie’s fall at the hands of this John isn’t so devastating. But the injustice of her money and his lack of it is more pronounced.

To drop yet another title into this review, the casting in James Cameron’s “Titanic” had a similar leveling effect. Leonardo DiCaprio looks to the manner born once he dons a tuxedo, while it’s Kate Winslet who looks more at home dancing with the masses in steerage.

Just in time for yet another movie adaptation of “The Great Gatsby,” Bonney and LaBute update Strindberg’s 1888 classic to 1929 and move it to a Long Island estate, adding a “bitch” here and a “shit” there.

As much as this Julie and John go at each other, they’re never the ones in control. Julie’s offstage father pulls the purse strings and John’s servant-girlfriend (Laura Heisler) is pregnant and speaks with a Yiddish flair despite calling herself Kristine.

Maybe looks aren’t what they’re cracked up to be after all.

Miss Julie

(Audrey Skirball Kenis Theater, Los Angeles; 117 seats; $99 top)

A Geffen Playhouse presentation of a play in one act by August Strindberg, adapted by Neil LaBute. Directed by Jo Bonney. Set, Myung Hee Cho; costumes, Christina Haatainen Jones; lighting, Lap Chi Chu; sound, Vincent Olivieri. Opened and reviewed May 1, 2013. Running time: 1 HOUR, 40 MIN.

With: Lily Rabe, Logan Marshall-Green, Laura Heisler

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 4

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. evers says:

    Perhaps the reviewer, so determined to define a actress’ worth by her beauty, should not have been assigned to review a classic play that examines gender roles. This variety reader would have appreciated an examination of their powerful performances, the success of the new adaption or perhaps even why this play is still relevant….all of which would have been infinitely more interesting than this simplistic assessment of “model-looks”. Shameful, Variety.

  2. Tita says:

    This review borders on offensive, not to mention moronic. Let me go ahead and engage the absurdity of boiling this amazing piece down to an actor’s facial structure. One would expect such a tasteless review in a tabloid but not here. Depressing frankly. Not to mention the fact that Ms. Rabe is undoubtedly a classic beauty with looks that rival any other beautiful actress in stage or film today. But more than anything, both she and Logan Marshall-Green are magical to watch. Their chemistry is undeniable and their performances riveting. It is a rare treat in Los Angeles to see anything that even approaches this caliber of work.

  3. Kay says:

    I’ve seen the play. Here’s what this review could have said: The chemistry between Rabe and Marshall-Green is off the charts. The play is a 100 minute roller coaster ride and the audience leaves feeling like they were on that ride themselves. It is a delight, in a tv and film town, to see theatre professionals at work. Rabe especially delivers a Broadway caliber performance. Angelenos should go just to see what real acting work looks like. A review that focuses on how the actors LOOK helps me not at all. In a nut shell; Rabe is fearless, the chemistry is palpable, go see this if you can. The run is almost sold out… as it should be.

  4. Steve Lewallen says:

    What an absurd review. Does Mr. Hofler like this production, and recommend people see it, or not? References to Titanic, The Heiress, and The Great Gatsby abound, but I have no idea what he thinks of this play.

More Legit News from Variety