Film Review: ‘Herb & Dorothy 50×50’

'Herb & Dorothy' sequel provides the happy ending to the art collectors' tale, as their trove is spread around the country.

With:

Herbert Vogel, Dorothy Vogel, Ruth Fine.

Before he passed away, Herbert Vogel and wife Dorothy quietly amassed a staggering collection of minimalist art, purchased on his modest government salary and crammed for decades inside their tiny New York apartment. “Herb & Dorothy” director Megumi Sasaki was hugely influential in validating the Vogels in the first place, and now that their trove has found a home — many homes, in fact, since the couple decided to donate 50 pieces to museums in all 50 states — follow-up docu “Herb & Dorothy 50×50” puts the happy ending on their hoarding-done-right story. Modest theatrical launch should encourage homevid and institutional collections.

While hardly a rehash, Sasaki’s sequel resurrects many of the themes and questions from the 2008 pic, which not only inspired middle-class auds to consider art-buying (often thought to be a luxury of the rich and famous) but also forced them to examine their notions of what qualifies as art, since the Vogels’ taste favored inexpensive conceptual pieces by artists who later hit it big. Sasaki also widens her focus, offering insights into the state of contemporary art museums, nearly all of which are limited to the taste of their donors.

In that respect, the Vogels may prove to be as influential as Samuel H. Kress, who used his fortune to amass (and later share with the public) one of the great collections of post-Renaissance painting. Traveling from New York to Hawaii, and hitting a dozen or so stops along the way, the film demonstrates how thirsty museums are for such gifts and how the various institutions use these often-challenging works to foster art appreciation.

On the road, Herb grows increasingly quiet, both soaking up the curious attention his newfound celebrity generates and, possibly, silently judging the odd mix of admirers and sycophants who surround them (Herb initially opposed the National Gallery’s proposal to split the collection). When not traveling to their collection’s far-flung new homes, Dorothy keeps watch from her nearly-empty apartment via the “Fifty Works for Fifty States” site; her story is bittersweet, since Herb’s death finally curbed her impulse to acquire.

Much like a work of art, the film invites a range of reactions, though it’s far easier to process than the daubs, doodles and other weird works
that now hang all over the country.

Film Review: 'Herb & Dorothy 50x50'

Reviewed online, Los Angeles, Aug. 25, 2013. Running time: 86 MIN.

Production:

(Documentary) A Fine Line Media release and presentation. Produced by Megumi Sasaki.

Crew:

Directed by Megumi Sasaki. Camera (color, HD), Erik Shirai; ditor, Bernadine Colish; music, David Majzlin; sound, Koji Kawasaki, Marianna LaFollette, Richard Levengood, John Shea; re-recording mixer, Peter Levin; associate producers, Yuki Murai, Takeshi Yamasaki, Jack Chiueh, Helio Bodini.

With:

Herbert Vogel, Dorothy Vogel, Ruth Fine.

More Film

  • Korea Box Office: 'Believer' Wins as

    Korea Box Office: 'Believer' Wins as ‘Solo’ Opens Fourth

    Before he passed away, Herbert Vogel and wife Dorothy quietly amassed a staggering collection of minimalist art, purchased on his modest government salary and crammed for decades inside their tiny New York apartment. “Herb & Dorothy” director Megumi Sasaki was hugely influential in validating the Vogels in the first place, and now that their trove […]

  • Andrei Cretulescu Finds New Romanian Rhythm

    Andrei Cretulescu Finds New Romanian Rhythm in 'Charleston’

    Before he passed away, Herbert Vogel and wife Dorothy quietly amassed a staggering collection of minimalist art, purchased on his modest government salary and crammed for decades inside their tiny New York apartment. “Herb & Dorothy” director Megumi Sasaki was hugely influential in validating the Vogels in the first place, and now that their trove […]

  • China Box Office: 'Solo' Opens Third

    China Box Office: 'Solo' Opens Third Behind 'How Long' and 'Avengers'

    Before he passed away, Herbert Vogel and wife Dorothy quietly amassed a staggering collection of minimalist art, purchased on his modest government salary and crammed for decades inside their tiny New York apartment. “Herb & Dorothy” director Megumi Sasaki was hugely influential in validating the Vogels in the first place, and now that their trove […]

  • Solo A Star Wars Story

    'Solo: A Star Wars Story' Stumbles Overseas With $65 Million Launch

    Before he passed away, Herbert Vogel and wife Dorothy quietly amassed a staggering collection of minimalist art, purchased on his modest government salary and crammed for decades inside their tiny New York apartment. “Herb & Dorothy” director Megumi Sasaki was hugely influential in validating the Vogels in the first place, and now that their trove […]

  • 'Solo': What That Surprise Cameo Means

    'Solo': What a 'Character Too Secret to Ever Name' Means for the 'Star Wars' Spinoff

    Before he passed away, Herbert Vogel and wife Dorothy quietly amassed a staggering collection of minimalist art, purchased on his modest government salary and crammed for decades inside their tiny New York apartment. “Herb & Dorothy” director Megumi Sasaki was hugely influential in validating the Vogels in the first place, and now that their trove […]

  • Solo A Star Wars Story

    Box Office: 'Solo: A Star Wars Story' Looks to Edge Past $100 Million For Holiday Weekend

    Before he passed away, Herbert Vogel and wife Dorothy quietly amassed a staggering collection of minimalist art, purchased on his modest government salary and crammed for decades inside their tiny New York apartment. “Herb & Dorothy” director Megumi Sasaki was hugely influential in validating the Vogels in the first place, and now that their trove […]

  • Rebel Wilson and Taye Diggs

    Concert Review: 'Beauty and the Beast' Gets Adoring Tribute at Hollywood Bowl

    Before he passed away, Herbert Vogel and wife Dorothy quietly amassed a staggering collection of minimalist art, purchased on his modest government salary and crammed for decades inside their tiny New York apartment. “Herb & Dorothy” director Megumi Sasaki was hugely influential in validating the Vogels in the first place, and now that their trove […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content