Why the Oscars Best Supporting Actor Race Is a Hot Mess

Jared Leto vs. Michael Fassbender: Oscars

At least a dozen thesps are in serious consideration in a crowded field

This year’s Oscar race has had bloggers buzzing about the most cutthroat best actor category in years — with at least seven “locks” for five slots — but there’s an even bigger logjam in the supporting actor contest. When the nominees are announced in January, the Academy won’t be able to avoid snubbing some of the best performances of the year.

The one sure bet for a nomination is Jared Leto, electrifying as a cross dresser with AIDS in “Dallas Buyers Club.” Leto picked up both the New York Film Critics and L.A. Film Critics prizes, and he could very well win the Oscar, which would thrill fans of “My-So Called Life” and his band 30 Seconds to Mars. That’s one way to keep the Oscars young, even if many Academy voters have never heard of Jordan Catalano.

As a corrupt stockbroker in “The Wolf of Wall Street,” Jonah Hill is good enough to notch his second Oscar nomination after the one he picked up for 2011’s “Moneyball.” He not only keeps up with Leonardo DiCaprio, who delivers the gutsiest work of his career, but he swallows a live goldfish onscreen.

Beyond that, the race gets murkier. Michael Fassbender received kudos for his role as a hysterical plantation owner in “12 Years a Slave,” and he should make the cut too. But it’s not a guarantee. After he was overlooked for “Shame” a couple years ago, Fassbender decided that he wouldn’t campaign for an Oscar this year.

Tom Hanks, whose is in a tight best actor race with “Captain Phillips” (a movie that seems to lose momentum by the day), might instead land a nomination for playing Walt Disney — the most Oscar-nominated person in the history of the Academy — in “Saving Mr. Banks.” Hanks gives a sweet, multilayered performance, although some viewers actually prefer Colin Farrell as the alcoholic father of “Mary Poppins” creator P.L. Travers. But Farrell has never been nominated before, which gives the edge to Hanks.

If Hanks is in, does that mean the Academy will also find room for his “Captain Phillips” co-star? Barkhad Abdi has been a darling on the Q&A circuit, but that may not matter. Last year, all five actors nominated for supporting actor had won an Oscar before. In the modern awards season, packed with star-studded luncheons and panels, the trend has been to honor veterans over newcomers (which is why Brie Larson in “Short Term 12” is also a longshot in the best actress race).

It would be foolish to count out “American Hustle” in any acting category. Director David O. Russell’s last two films, “Silver Linings Playbook” and “The Fighter,” earned a stunning seven nominations for its actors. Although Jeremy Renner is good as a New Jersey mayor in the comedic romp loosely based on Abscam, Bradley Cooper is better as the cop who runs the sting operation.

Fox Searchlight is campaigning James Gandolfini for a posthumous Oscar for his lovable slob in “Enough Said.” The Oscars usually don’t honor comedy, but it’s hard to imagine Hollywood being so heartless as to not include him. Right? And he’s already earned an Independent Spirit Awards nomination for the role.

With so many names floating around, there could be a surprise or two. If “Nebraska” keeps building momentum coming off a strong showing with the critics, Will Forte could be a dark horse in the race. Even though his screen time exceeds Bruce Dern’s, he’s being campaigned in supporting. The same goes for Jake Gyllenhaal, who shares top billing in “Prisoners” with Hugh Jackman. In another year, he could have won for his nuanced detective, the best performance of his career.

It’s easy to play the “what if” game. There are other performances that may have gotten recognition in a less crowded season: Ben Foster as a Navy SEAL in “Lone Survivor,” Woody Harrelson’s or Casey Affleck’s dark turns in “Out of the Furnace,” Daniel Bruhl as a race car driver in “Rush” and James Franco as a scene-stealing drug lord in “Spring Breakers.” Then again, that role might have been too out there for the Academy in any year.

If I had to guess, it will be Leto, Hill, Fassbender, Hanks and Cooper. Oh, wait. And Gandolfini. I don’t know how they are going to narrow down the list to only five.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 16

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Rosa says:

    This article just got worse and lost its credibility as I kept reading. That fact that you know nothing of what your talking about. 1) you are going by the hype. Are we seriously still saying that Jonah Hill is an option? don’t. Bradley Cooper was only nominated because the competition last year was so weak. No gonna’ happen again. You said Daniel Bruhl played a race car driver. You didn’t even freaking know he played Niki Lauda? This article is so irrelevant. Bruhl will be nominated as Fassbender. As to who will win: The Academy loves guys like Christoph Waltz and Bruhl is one to compare.

  2. Parker says:

    I hope Michael gets nominated/wins and I think he’ll at least be nominated but he’s not even going to go to the oscars cause he’ll be filming something else. Still exposure I guess?

  3. kristy says:

    Jared Leto deserves to winan Oscar and more!!!!

  4. Jazz says:

    I wish Ben Foster would get some best supporting love for Ain’t Them Bodies Saints b/c his nuanced performance really blew me away. I’m sad people aren’t really talking about him and the film all that much even though I thought all the performances were solid.

  5. Michael Fassbender is not campaigning for Oscar because he’s working in New Zealand on two films. Stop trying to dramatize his reasons in order to get web traffic to any articles written about him here.

    • Parker says:

      He’s said that he isn’t campaigning for an oscar because he’s an actor, not a politician.

    • Bill B. says:

      Not true. Fassbinder has stated that he does not consider acting a competition and after struggling with it last year to no avail, he wants no part of it. He’s an actor, and a good one, but he’s not in the business of promoting himself for awards.

      • Jill says:

        Both true. Fassbender made those statements about not wishing to campaign (“I’m an actor, not a politician”) and he also is, or has been, in NZ working on Slow West since about October.

  6. Clark says:

    Ramin Setoodeh, who insulted the entire LGBT community by saying gay actors can’t play straight, is your Oscar pundit?? I’m DONE with Variety. You’ve lost all credibility.

  7. Laura Cunningham says:

    JARED LETO IS INCREDIBLE IN DALLAS BUYERS CLUB! He has to win! He was sooo dedicated to this role, he deserves an Oscar!

  8. Jake says:

    Fassbender is simply not as great and don’t get me started on abdi in captain Phillips.

  9. Belinda says:

    I don’t think it is fair to say Cooper is better than Renner, but he does do a good job with a much meatier role.

    • Lizzie says:

      Agree. Renner has the smallest and quietest role in the film, cooper plays a loud manic character with enough screen time to arguably be put in a leading actor category. They both do well in the film, but their parts are too different to rank. Id love to see them both in, but it ain’t gonna happen.

      Based on how both actors are struggling to be recognized individually in the minor award circuits thus far, it makes me wonder if they could cancel each other out come the big nomination day.

      • Lizzie

        Totally concur. I haven’t seen Hustle as yet but I think Cooper will sneak in because of his previous relationship with Oscar darling Russell thereby excluding Renner from consideration. I have seen Leto who is very good, Hill I found annoying and think Bruhl gives the best performance by far. Promos for Hustle have done Renner another disservice; sometimes not even showing him. Cooper/Lawrence are the loudest of the loud as it were. And the Academy likes that sort of thing.

More Film News from Variety