As long as viewers set their expectations to "pretty good," the latest adaptation of Charles Dickens' seminal tale of social climbing and secret identities will satisfy.
As long as viewers set their expectations to “pretty good,” the latest adaptation of Charles Dickens’ seminal tale of social climbing and secret identities will satisfy. Lacking the epic scope — and length — of recent BBC/PBS Dickens minis “Bleak House” and “Little Dorrit,” “Expectations” still delivers the solid performances, sturdy period allure and comforting familiarity Masterpiece audiences crave.
Broadcast in three parts over Christmas season on BBC, PBS has opted to air the mini over two nights — one hour the first week and two hours the second. The opening segment focuses on young orphan Pip (an appropriately precocious Oscar Kennedy), who lives as a ward with his cantankerous adult sister (Claire Rushbrook) and her good-hearted blacksmith husband (Shaun Dooley).
Two chance encounters will forever change Pip’s life: first, with fugitive criminal Abel Magwitch (Ray Winstone), who demands Pip’s assistance in evading the law, only to be touched by the boy’s unexpected kindness; and second with reclusive spinster Miss Havisham (Gillian Anderson), a woman of great wealth who essentially rents Pip as a playmate for her aloof adopted daughter Estella (Izzy Meikle-Small).
Although the story has been adapted for TV numerous times (most recently in 1999 with Ioan Gruffudd and Charlotte Rampling) and David Lean’s 1946 Oscar-nominated version remains well regarded, director Brian Kirk (“Game of Thrones”) and writer Sarah Phelps (“EastEnders”) forge their own path by bringing Dickens into the era of 21st-century period pieces. In the mode of recent cinematic renditions of “Jane Eyre” and “Wuthering Heights,” this is a grittier, earthier “Great Expectations,” brimming with dark, portentous atmosphere and handsomely lensed by Florian Hoffmeister (“The Deep Blue Sea”) with attention to natural light.
Top-billed in their supporting roles, Winstone and Anderson vividly etch their own interpretations of iconic literary characters. Winstone’s gruff intensity kick-starts the mini with a jolt of energy, and he’s equally adept playing Magwitch’s more sensitive shades when the convict’s full scope is later revealed. But it’s Anderson who proves even more inventive in embodying Dickens’ infamous old maid, first of all simply by being not so old.
Anderson’s Havisham is a prisoner of youth, a ghostly woman-child who haunts her slowly deteriorating mansion like a wraith forever in search of her wedding day. With her frail appearance, ethereal movements and breathy high-pitched voice, Anderson’s performance may be a love-it-or-hate-it affair for some, but it’s indelible all the same.
Still, however pivotal Magwitch and Havisham are to the story, it’s still Pip’s tale, and the duty of carrying the majority of screentime falls on relative newcomer Douglas Booth. Playing Pip as a young man, the 19-year-old actor (“The Pillars of the Earth,” Boy George in a BBC telepic) pits his male-model looks against the not-always-attractive ambition that defines the character.
Part of Dickens’ lasting appeal lies in the ambiguities of his characters and his understanding that protagonists don’t need to be likable to hold our interest. The same goes for Pip’s great love, the inscrutable Estella (played with perilous magnetism as a young woman by Vanessa Kirby of “The Hour”). “Great Expectations” wouldn’t pass muster in the studio system today, but its status as an established classic makes it a safe bet for Masterpiece.
Abel Magwitch - Ray Winstone
Pip - Douglas Booth
Jaggers - David Suchet
Estella - Vanessa Kirby
Joe Gargery - Shaun Dooley
Herbert Pocket - Harry Lloyd
Mrs. Joe - Claire Rushbrook
Pumblechook - Mark Addy
Denby/Compeyson - Paul Rhys