The Collection

Strictly for auds who enjoy the grisly Grand Guignol spectacle of the "Saw" franchise but could do without the moral lectures and melodramatic mythology, "The Collection" is an energetic but utterly weightless exercise in slice-and-dice cinema.

With:
With: Josh Stewart, Emma Fitzpatrick, Lee Tergesen, Christopher McDonald, Shannon Kane, Tim Griffin, Andre Royo, Randall Archer.

Strictly for auds who enjoy the grisly Grand Guignol spectacle of the “Saw” franchise but could do without the moral lectures and melodramatic mythology, “The Collection” is an energetic but utterly weightless exercise in slice-and-dice cinema. This sequel to 2009 chiller “The Collector” is in many ways bigger (more characters, more locations, more carnage), but in no way better than its predecessor. Theatrical is merely a pit-stop on the road to home viewing for a product with niche appeal even among horror buffs.

Picking up where “The Collector” left off, “The Collection” establishes an anonymous urban locale terrorized by a psycho killer with no method to his madness. Without the luxury of the first film’s slow-burn opening act, the sequel leans on pre-existing iconography to build tension: the Collector’s black mask obscuring everything but his beady eyes and predatory mouth; the red trunk he uses to “collect” a lone survivor of each massacre; an ominous tripwire connected to something sharp and lethal. Once filmmakers (and “Saw” sequel alums) Marcus Dunstan and Patrick Melton hurriedly introduce new protagonist Elena (Emma Fitzpatrick), it’s off to the races for nonstop, nonsensical brutality.

Elena and pals head to a secret underground club (the password is “nevermore,” natch) where the Collector waits in the shadows with a plan to orchestrate mass murder. In what should be one of the film’s standout setpieces, dozens of clubgoers are simultaneously slaughtered by a massive combine-harvester blade rigged to descend from the ceiling. But the sequence is little more than a jumble of frenetically cut-together closeups, and the first of many examples of the film’s “more is more” philosophy coming into conflict with the constraints of a low budget.

While Elena is dragged off to the villain’s secret lair, the pic reintroduces the first film’s scrappy survivor, Arkin (Josh Stewart), who manages to break free only to be recruited by Elena’s mysterious protector, Lucello (Lee Tergesen). Lucello has assembled a team to hunt down the Collector and rescue Elena, and they need Arkin’s help. But this time he’s on the Collector’s home turf: The rundown Hotel Argento (wink, wink), a more elaborate version of the booby-trapped mansion from part one.

If “The Collector” was inspired by the suspenseful setup of “Wait Until Dark,” Dunstan and Melton take their cues this time from one of the great genre sequels: James Cameron’s “Aliens,” with its team of tough-talking grunts navigating perilous terrain as they battle an unstoppable foe. Still, the raison d’etre remains gore, gore and more gore. There’s no attempt to explain how the Collector sets up his elaborate traps, and only the vaguest speculation as to what motivates his insatiable bloodlust, which could be frightening if his actions weren’t so preposterous.

Performance and tech credits are adequate by genre standards, though the only imaginative contribution comes in the design of the Collector’s depraved displays of disemboweled victims and stitched-together body parts. He’s quite the interior decorator.

Pic manages to end on a satisfying note that may or may not lead to a third installment. Perhaps the limited amount of title variations — “The Collected”? “The Collectors”? — will spare everyone the unnecessary trouble.

The Collection

Production: An LD Entertainment release of a Liddell Entertainment and Fortress Features production. Produced by Mickey Liddell, Jennifer Monroe, Julie Richardson, Brett Forbes, Patrick Rizzotti. Executive producers, Tom Luse, Pete Shilaimon. Co-producers, Christopher Lockhart, Todd Ulman, Josh Stewart, Stephen Accetta, Todd Ulman. Directed by Marcus Dunstan. Screenplay, Patrick Melton, Dunstan.

Crew: Camera (Technicolor, widescreen), Sam McCurdy; editor, Mark Stevens, Kevin Greutert; music, Charlie Clouser; music supervisor, Tricia Holloway; production designer, Graham "Grace" Walker; art director, Doug Fick; set decorator, Kristen Donaldson Walker; costume designer, Eulyn Womble; sound (Dolby Digital), Shirley Libby; supervising sound editor, Walter Newman; re-recording mixers, Dan Hiland, Gary Rodgers; visual effects supervisor, David Karlak; visual effects, Yashinki Studios, Eyelandarts Studios, Hoax Films; make-up f/x creator, Gary J. Tunnicliffe; stunt coordinator, Hiro Koda, Banzai Vitale; assistant director, Alisa Fredericks; second unit director, David Karlak; second unit camera, Marc Dobiecki; casting, Joseph Middleton, Tineka Becker. Reviewed at Arclight Cinemas, Hollywood, Nov. 26, 2012. (In Fantastic Fest, Screamfest.) MPAA Rating: R. Running time: 82 MIN.

With: With: Josh Stewart, Emma Fitzpatrick, Lee Tergesen, Christopher McDonald, Shannon Kane, Tim Griffin, Andre Royo, Randall Archer.

More Film

  • Rashida Jones John Lasseter

    Rashida Jones Denies That She Left 'Toy Story 4' Over Unwanted Advance From John Lasseter

    Strictly for auds who enjoy the grisly Grand Guignol spectacle of the “Saw” franchise but could do without the moral lectures and melodramatic mythology, “The Collection” is an energetic but utterly weightless exercise in slice-and-dice cinema. This sequel to 2009 chiller “The Collector” is in many ways bigger (more characters, more locations, more carnage), but […]

  • Dominique McElligott

    Film News Roundup: Dominique McElligott, Beau Bridges Join Boyd Holbrook's 'Two/One'

    Strictly for auds who enjoy the grisly Grand Guignol spectacle of the “Saw” franchise but could do without the moral lectures and melodramatic mythology, “The Collection” is an energetic but utterly weightless exercise in slice-and-dice cinema. This sequel to 2009 chiller “The Collector” is in many ways bigger (more characters, more locations, more carnage), but […]

  • Coco Pixar

    John Lasseter Allegations Cast Shadow Over Disney-Pixar's 'Coco' Debut

    Strictly for auds who enjoy the grisly Grand Guignol spectacle of the “Saw” franchise but could do without the moral lectures and melodramatic mythology, “The Collection” is an energetic but utterly weightless exercise in slice-and-dice cinema. This sequel to 2009 chiller “The Collector” is in many ways bigger (more characters, more locations, more carnage), but […]

  • John Lasseter

    Pixar's John Lasseter Was the Subject of a 'Whisper Network' for More Than Two Decades

    Strictly for auds who enjoy the grisly Grand Guignol spectacle of the “Saw” franchise but could do without the moral lectures and melodramatic mythology, “The Collection” is an energetic but utterly weightless exercise in slice-and-dice cinema. This sequel to 2009 chiller “The Collector” is in many ways bigger (more characters, more locations, more carnage), but […]

  • Andy Serkis Flarsky

    Andy Serkis Joins Seth Rogen and Charlize Theron in 'Flarsky'

    Strictly for auds who enjoy the grisly Grand Guignol spectacle of the “Saw” franchise but could do without the moral lectures and melodramatic mythology, “The Collection” is an energetic but utterly weightless exercise in slice-and-dice cinema. This sequel to 2009 chiller “The Collector” is in many ways bigger (more characters, more locations, more carnage), but […]

  • John Lasseter Pixar

    John Lasseter Takes Leave of Absence From Disney/Pixar, Apologizes for Unwanted Hugs

    Strictly for auds who enjoy the grisly Grand Guignol spectacle of the “Saw” franchise but could do without the moral lectures and melodramatic mythology, “The Collection” is an energetic but utterly weightless exercise in slice-and-dice cinema. This sequel to 2009 chiller “The Collector” is in many ways bigger (more characters, more locations, more carnage), but […]

  • at&t time warner merger

    AT&T-Time Warner Merger: Does the DOJ Have a Case?

    Strictly for auds who enjoy the grisly Grand Guignol spectacle of the “Saw” franchise but could do without the moral lectures and melodramatic mythology, “The Collection” is an energetic but utterly weightless exercise in slice-and-dice cinema. This sequel to 2009 chiller “The Collector” is in many ways bigger (more characters, more locations, more carnage), but […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content