Review: ‘Goats’


This monotonously deadpan coming-of-age comedy has little to recommend it beyond some beautiful widescreen cinematography and the momentary kick of seeing David Duchovny looking like a stoned Jesus.

As it sounds, “Goats” is a bleating animal, pretty but rather dumb. Waywardly splitting its time between the Tucson foothills and the adolescent hero’s East Coast prep school, this monotonously deadpan coming-of-age comedy has little to recommend it beyond some beautiful widescreen cinematography and the momentary kick of seeing David Duchovny looking like a stoned Jesus as Goat Man, the boy’s pot-growing, goat-trekking surrogate dad. Genial but gratingly irrelevant and none too witty, the pic herds its talented actors into a narrative desert. What does a goat say? Na-a-a-a.

Adapted by Mark Jude Poirier from his like-titled novel, “Goats” follows Ellis Whitman (Graham Phillips, from TV’s “The Good Wife”), a 15-year-old Arizonan whose idle rich father, Frank (Ty Burrell), lives in D.C. with bland wife Judy (Keri Russell), and whose narcissistic New Age mom, Wendy (Vera Farmiga, in a serape), appears less devoted to him than to her “healing vortex workshops” and boy-toy du jour Bennet (Justin Kirk). Thus the kid’s parental unit is Goat Man, aka Javier, with whom he smokes copious amounts of grass while roaming the barren hills alongside Lance and Frieda, Javier’s beloved goats.

Shunted off to Gates Academy at summer’s end, Ellis waits impatiently for a medicinal care package from Goat Man; is coerced by Coach (Anthony Anderson) into joining the track team; and falls in love at first sight with dining-hall employee Minnie (Dakota Johnson), who shocks him by being not only well read but well known for sexually servicing the Gates student body for extra cash.

On weekends and holidays, owing to his folks’ ample reserves, Ellis visits Dad, largely defined by his “poetry glasses,” and Mom, whose latest spiritual practice has her writhing on the floor. As per generic formula, the kid inches his way closer to reconciliation with both parents. By default, the pic’s biggest surprises find the Speedo-sporting Bennet “free-ballin'” in a scene out of vintage Farrelly Brothers farce, and Goat Man cleaning up his act about halfway through, shedding roughly a pound of hair.

The overall vibe of first-time director Christopher Neil is certainly mellow, but his movie is still a bong hit short of a decent buzz. Farmiga seems to be having a smidgen of fun as wacky Wendy, although Neil never lets the camera get close enough to the character for the viewer to know what makes her tick. Playing straight man to the screwball ensemble, handsome young Phillips is but a blank slate.

Tech credits, including Wyatt Troll’s lovely landscape shooting, are as professional as the humor is pedestrian.



A Red Crown, Sandia Media production, in association with the Arlook Group, Eva Daniels Prods., Light Iron. (International sales: WME Global, Los Angeles; Cinetic Media, New York.) Produced by Daniela Taplin Lundberg, Shannon Lail, Eric Kopeloff. Executive producers, Daniel Crown, Riva Marker, Richard Arlook, Eva Maria Daniels, Peter Fruchtman, Juan Carlos Segura G., Michael Scott Saunders, Jai Stefan, Peter Touche, Todd Traina. Co-producers, Todd J. Labarowski, Tommee May, Anne O'Shea, Jett Steiger. Co-executive producers, Steve Boymel, Paul Buchheit. Directed by Christopher Neil. Screenplay, Mark Jude Poirier, from his novel.


Camera (color, widescreen), Wyatt Troll; editors, Jeremiah O'Driscoll, Kevin Tent, Craig McKay; music, Woody Jackson, Jason Schwartzman; production designer, Mark Duran; set decorator, Wil Pfau; costume designer, Kate Deblasio; sound, Diana Cleland, Rodney Gurule, Graham Gardner; visual effects supervisors, Geoffrey Baumann, Jesse James Chisholm; line producer, Brent Morris; associate producers, Lauren Grimshaw, Gary Podell, Robert Weinberg, Mark Yeh; assistant directors, Jonathan Southard, Christopher Bryson; casting, Nicole Daniels, Courtney Sheinin. Reviewed at Sundance Film Festival (Premieres), Jan. 24, 2012. Running time: 94 MIN.


Goat Man - David Duchovny
Wendy - Vera Farmiga
Ellis - Graham Phillips
Frank - Ty Burrell
Bennet - Justin Kirk
Judy - Keri Russell
Coach - Anthony Anderson
Minnie - Dakota Johnson
Aubrey - Adelaide Kane
Barney - Nicholas Lobue

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety