Review: ‘After Lucia’

'After Lucia'

The hot-button topic of school bullying provides an attention-grabbing hook for "After Lucia," the grimly persuasive sophomore feature from Mexican writer-helmer-producer Michel Franco ("Daniel and Ana").

The hot-button topic of school bullying provides an attention-grabbing hook for “After Lucia,” the grimly persuasive sophomore feature from Mexican writer-helmer-producer Michel Franco (“Daniel and Ana”). Suggesting that teenage cruelty is no different in Mexico City than in any other major Western metropolis, pic depicts a distressing downward spiral for its pretty, charismatic protag after one drunken misstep. Rigorous arthouse styling and deliberate pace will limit peer approval from the youthful demographic depicted; instead, look for graduation to niche theatrical and global fest outings following pic’s berth in Cannes’ Un Certain Regard.

The titular Lucia, recently deceased, is the ghost that casts a shadow over the film’s two main characters: her daughter, Ale (Tessa Ia, “The Burning Plain”), and husband, Roberto (Hernan Mendoza), a chef. The grieving pair have left their life in Puerto Vallarta, making a fresh start in the capital, where Roberto plans to open a restaurant, and where their sparsely furnished apartment is an apt metaphor for the emptiness they feel.

Ale, short for Alejandra, has no trouble falling in with the popular kids at school, led by self-anointed queen bee Camilla (Tamara Yazbek Bernal) and handsome Jose (Gonzalo Vega Sisto). But when she heads off with the privileged gang for a weekend of teenage hedonism and has drunken bathroom sex with Jose, a cell-phone video of the incident soon goes viral. With Ale having earned the enmity of Camilla, who sees Jose as hers, and Manuel (Juan Carlos Barranco), who had his own designs on the new girl, her fate is sealed.

Ale’s selfless decision not to be a burden to her depressed father, and in fact to step into Mom’s shoes as his reliable support network, is an understandable adolescent error. And while her new school effectively polices the student population through random drugs testing of urine samples, there is no scientific evaluation for being a victim of bullying. The abuse escalates and turns troublingly criminal on a class trip to Veracruz.

In no particular rush to articulate what exactly his characters are thinking and feeling, or to provide easy mood cues through music (there is none), Franco aims to engage through careful withholding. For all but the most impatient auds, pic should sustain interest in how Ale, who initially resists her tormentors, gradually shuts down and submits to shocking degradation.

Pic benefits from Ia’s heartfelt lead performance and convincingly natural turns from the non-professionals who play her classmate tormentors and, per the press notes, are in fact the actress’ real-life friends. Absent musical accompaniment, a steady whir of Foley effects contributes a sense of unease; final sequence, which brings Roberto to the fore, is wholly gripping.

After Lucia



A Pop Films, Lemon Films and Filmadora Nacional production in co-production wit Stromboli Films and Trebol Stone. (International sales: BAC Films, Paris.) Produced by Michel Franco, Marco Polo Constandse, Elias Menasse, Fernando Rovzar, Alexis Fridman. Executive producers, Moises Zonana, Billy Rovzar. Co-producer, Juliette Sol. Directed, written by Michel Franco.


Camera (color), Chuy Chavez; editors, Franco, Antonio Bribiesca; costume designer, Evelyn Robles; sound designers, Jose Miguel Enriquez, Federico Gonzalez Jordan, Manuel Danoi; line producer, Jesus Aramburu; associate producer, Hedi Zardi; assistant director, Nosha Sauma. Reviewed at Cannes Film Festival (Un Certain Regard), May 16, 2012. Running time: 103 MIN.


Tessa Ia, Hernan Mendoza, Gonzalo Vega Sisto, Tamara Yazbek Bernal, Paloma Cervantez, Juan Carlos Barranco, Francisco Rueda, Diego Canales.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety