You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

NYTimes Public Ed Admits LAT Piece Was Cruddy

The New York Times’ public editor has essentially acknowledged that his paper’s article this week about the Los Angeles Times was a piece of dreck.

“It’s the kind of story that, given its implications, could have used more language — and descriptions of evidence — to support its premises,” he concluded.

Yep. The lamest defense from the editor involved was that the reporter, Jeremy Peters — who presented little evidence to back up his assertions — had more quotes in his notes, but those weren’t used. What does that even mean — that we don’t have to make our case in print, because we have it on file?

As one former LA Times colleague noted, the piece said as much about the New York Times — and its tendency to overreach with such articles, especially in its Monday media-business coverage — as it did the Los Angeles Times, inasmuch as most of the criticism could have been registered a couple of years ago. (Kevin Roderick made a similar point — as in “Why now?” — on his indispensible blog, Laobserved.com.)

That said, I’m hardly one to give the LA Times a pass, and the paper still has its head-scratching, follow-the-herd moments, like today’s trio of pieces — including one by op-ed columnist Meghan Daum — about the MTV series “Skins.” Talk about a serious case of overkill, as if the issue of overly sexualized teens in media is brand new.

Still, the NY Times piece was a mess, and it’s nice to see the public editor admit as much.

 

More Voices

  • TV Television problems Expenses Placeholder

    Netflix Has Secret Weapon in Hollywood's Multibillion-Dollar Arms Race

    The New York Times’ public editor has essentially acknowledged that his paper’s article this week about the Los Angeles Times was a piece of dreck. “It’s the kind of story that, given its implications, could have used more language — and descriptions of evidence — to support its premises,” he concluded. Yep. The lamest defense […]

  • sweeney Todd Barrow Street Theatre

    Commercial Off Broadway Isn't Dead -- It's Turning Into Broadway

    The New York Times’ public editor has essentially acknowledged that his paper’s article this week about the Los Angeles Times was a piece of dreck. “It’s the kind of story that, given its implications, could have used more language — and descriptions of evidence — to support its premises,” he concluded. Yep. The lamest defense […]

  • Edie Windsor Appreciation

    GLAAD President Reflects on Edie Windsor's Impact on LGBTQ Community

    The New York Times’ public editor has essentially acknowledged that his paper’s article this week about the Los Angeles Times was a piece of dreck. “It’s the kind of story that, given its implications, could have used more language — and descriptions of evidence — to support its premises,” he concluded. Yep. The lamest defense […]

  • Game of Thrones

    Networks' Streaming Apps Make Minimal Revenue Impact (For Now)

    The New York Times’ public editor has essentially acknowledged that his paper’s article this week about the Los Angeles Times was a piece of dreck. “It’s the kind of story that, given its implications, could have used more language — and descriptions of evidence — to support its premises,” he concluded. Yep. The lamest defense […]

  • Avatar

    3D Shows Enduring Value, Delivering Entertainment Not Found at Home (Guest Column)

    The New York Times’ public editor has essentially acknowledged that his paper’s article this week about the Los Angeles Times was a piece of dreck. “It’s the kind of story that, given its implications, could have used more language — and descriptions of evidence — to support its premises,” he concluded. Yep. The lamest defense […]

  • Spotify hand changing free to fee

    Why Spotify Should Ditch Its Free Tier, Add Streaming Fees

    The New York Times’ public editor has essentially acknowledged that his paper’s article this week about the Los Angeles Times was a piece of dreck. “It’s the kind of story that, given its implications, could have used more language — and descriptions of evidence — to support its premises,” he concluded. Yep. The lamest defense […]

  • Fox News Revenue Falls

    Fox News' Recent Struggles Puts Parent Company's Growth at Risk

    The New York Times’ public editor has essentially acknowledged that his paper’s article this week about the Los Angeles Times was a piece of dreck. “It’s the kind of story that, given its implications, could have used more language — and descriptions of evidence — to support its premises,” he concluded. Yep. The lamest defense […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content