Review: ‘You Deserve It’

'You Deserve It'

A hodgepodge of other gameshows that culminates with the cash being handed over to a needy (and yes, deserving) individual, a la "Queen for a Day."

Credit ABC with perseverance, if not necessarily originality, in its commitment to feel-good reality TV, despite middling performers like “Secret Millionaire.” A producer of that show, Chris Coelen, is part of the team behind “You Deserve It,” a hodgepodge of other gameshows that culminates with the cash being handed over to a needy (and yes, deserving) individual, a la “Queen for a Day.” The money-raising procedure is sort of a Frankenshow — stitched together from old used parts — but as do-gooder holiday filler goes, ABC could do worse.

“The Bachelor’s” Chris Harrison is as much cheerleader as host in this context, as each episode opens by introducing a person, who can certainly use a sizable chunk of cash, being secretly lauded by their friends and relatives. One of those altruistic souls will play for the money, which the unsuspecting beneficiary will be presented — Surprise! Publisher’s Clearinghouse giveaway-style — at the conclusion.

The game itself is basically a modest twist on Twenty Questions, with each brief clue subtracting from the starting total by luck-of-the-draw increments, a la “Deal or No Deal.” The more clues — and they’re especially cryptic, blunting the play-along element — the more the prize drops in each round, with a final puzzle that starts at $250,000.

Even with dumb players, it’s a pretty good prescription for sizable purses. And given the waterworks that flow in the previewed episodes, if ABC doesn’t have a tissue sponsor tie-in, it’s missing a real opportunity.

The premiere features a friend playing for a widowed mother of two, while another hour has a daughter competing for her mom, who has done many good works in South Central L.A. If there’s one truly off-putting note, it’s a hyper-caffeinated Brooke Burns, who gets to deliver the good news to the understandably overwhelmed recipient.

Although there has been much speculation about whether viewers will gravitate toward uplifting material as a balm for the moribund economy, since ABC scored with “Extreme Makeover: Home Edition,” there’s been scant evidence to buttress such notions other than CBS’ “Undercover Boss.” Nevertheless, ABC seems committed to keep tugging at the heartstrings, eventually hoping to play a happy tune.

Based on its merits “You Deserve It” probably isn’t the show to do it, but a kickstart behind “Dancing With the Stars” ought to give the series a fighting chance — at least to return as a utility player. If so, it would mark a break from the perception that no good-deed-doing show goes unpunished.

You Deserve It

ABC, Mon. Nov. 21, 10 p.m.


Produced by Kinetic Content. Executive producers, Chris Coelen, Dick de Rijk, Matilda Zoltowski, Jeff Krask; supervising producers, John Quinn, Aaron Solomon; director, Ron de Moraes; head writer, Solomon;


camera, Don Mann; production designer: John Ivo Gilles; lead editor, Ryan Ely; music, Vanacore Music, Nathan DeVore; casting, Paul Gordon. 60 MIN.


With: Chris Harrison, Brooke Burns

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More TV News from Variety