Contender: ‘Martha Marcy May Marlene’

The Contenders 2011

Before “Martha Marcy May Marlene” debuted at Sundance, its chief talking point was that annoyingly alliterative title. Initially regarded as a possible hindrance, the tongue-twister has instead proved to be as memorable as anything in Sean Durkin’s quietly disquieting debut feature, which emerged from Park City with a directing prize, a Fox Searchlight distribution deal and rave reviews for Elizabeth Olsen’s lead performance as a lost soul on the run from a violent cult.

Handily overcoming any potentially unflattering associations with her older sisters Mary-Kate and Ashley, the fledgling actress gives a haunted, complex, almost completely interior performance that could land her a slot in the competitive actress race. Longer shots for thesping honors are Olsen’s co-stars Sarah Paulson, brittle and emotional as the protagonist’s concerned older sister, and John Hawkes, as imposing here as a Charles Manson-esque figure as he was in his Oscar-nominated turn in “Winter’s Bone.”

Uncommonly assured for a first-time filmmaker, Durkin may still be considered too green for a directing nomination. But his talent for understatement could find favor with the writers’ branch: Expanding on his similarly fest-friendly short “Mary Last Seen,” the script drifts eerily between two converging timeframes assembled with the cunning, snap-together precision of a trap in the woods.

Release date: Oct. 21
Fox Searchlight
Read the Variety review

More Film

  • MATANGI / MAYA / M.I.A.

    Sundance: First Look at Poster for M.I.A. Documentary

    Before “Martha Marcy May Marlene” debuted at Sundance, its chief talking point was that annoyingly alliterative title. Initially regarded as a possible hindrance, the tongue-twister has instead proved to be as memorable as anything in Sean Durkin’s quietly disquieting debut feature, which emerged from Park City with a directing prize, a Fox Searchlight distribution deal […]

  • Carey Mulligan Says Dee Rees Would

    Carey Mulligan: If Dee Rees Was a White Man, She'd Be Directing the Next 'Star Wars'

    Before “Martha Marcy May Marlene” debuted at Sundance, its chief talking point was that annoyingly alliterative title. Initially regarded as a possible hindrance, the tongue-twister has instead proved to be as memorable as anything in Sean Durkin’s quietly disquieting debut feature, which emerged from Park City with a directing prize, a Fox Searchlight distribution deal […]

  • Inventing Tomorrow

    Sundance Film Review: ‘Inventing Tomorrow’

    Before “Martha Marcy May Marlene” debuted at Sundance, its chief talking point was that annoyingly alliterative title. Initially regarded as a possible hindrance, the tongue-twister has instead proved to be as memorable as anything in Sean Durkin’s quietly disquieting debut feature, which emerged from Park City with a directing prize, a Fox Searchlight distribution deal […]

  • MFFF: Lise Akoka and Romane Gueret

    MyFrenchFilmFestival: Filmmakers Lise Akoka and Romane Gueret Discuss Their Competition Short ‘Chasse Royale’

    Before “Martha Marcy May Marlene” debuted at Sundance, its chief talking point was that annoyingly alliterative title. Initially regarded as a possible hindrance, the tongue-twister has instead proved to be as memorable as anything in Sean Durkin’s quietly disquieting debut feature, which emerged from Park City with a directing prize, a Fox Searchlight distribution deal […]

  • Nicolas CageVariety Studio at Sundance Presented

    Nicolas Cage on High Movie Prices, Not Playing Superman and Sundance Action Movie 'Mandy'

    Before “Martha Marcy May Marlene” debuted at Sundance, its chief talking point was that annoyingly alliterative title. Initially regarded as a possible hindrance, the tongue-twister has instead proved to be as memorable as anything in Sean Durkin’s quietly disquieting debut feature, which emerged from Park City with a directing prize, a Fox Searchlight distribution deal […]

  • 'Lizzie' Review

    Sundance Film Review: 'Lizzie'

    Evocative visuals and a strong cast ham-handedly reframe the infamous ax murderess as a heroine slaying the patriarchy.

  • Elsie Fisher appears in I Think

    Sundance Film Review: 'Eighth Grade'

    Before “Martha Marcy May Marlene” debuted at Sundance, its chief talking point was that annoyingly alliterative title. Initially regarded as a possible hindrance, the tongue-twister has instead proved to be as memorable as anything in Sean Durkin’s quietly disquieting debut feature, which emerged from Park City with a directing prize, a Fox Searchlight distribution deal […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content