Kirby, Marvel suit lingers on

At stake are licensing rights and royalties

A legal battle between comics giant Marvel and the estate of famed illustrator and longtime Stan Lee collaborator Jack Kirby is showing no sign of ending.

Kirby’s family claims that Marvel should no longer retain the copyright for the work Kirby, who died in 1994, did on such iconic superheroes as Iron Man, X-Men, the Incredible Hulk and Spider-Man.

Marvel sued, seeking a court to declare that Kirby’s art had been “work for hire” and, as a result, the comicbook maker retained control. At stake are licensing rights and lucrative royalties.

In late November, a New York federal judge ruled in what amounted to a split decision on a counter-suit filed by the Kirby family. The court refused to throw out the Kirby estate’s effort to terminate Marvel’s copyrights.

At the same time, the court did say it would not compel Marvel to pay damages or return artwork that never made it back to Kirby after the comic book company allegedly contracted to do so in the mid-1980s.

More from Variety Visionary: Stan Lee:
Stan Lee ready to drop the puck | Lee busy with plenty of projects in pipeline | Kirby, Marvel suit lingers on

More Film

  • James Bond Skyfall

    Universal Wins International Rights to James Bond 25

    A legal battle between comics giant Marvel and the estate of famed illustrator and longtime Stan Lee collaborator Jack Kirby is showing no sign of ending. Kirby’s family claims that Marvel should no longer retain the copyright for the work Kirby, who died in 1994, did on such iconic superheroes as Iron Man, X-Men, the […]

  • In 'That Summer,' the Stars of

    In 'That Summer,' the Stars of 'Grey Gardens' Look More Unhinged Than Ever

    A legal battle between comics giant Marvel and the estate of famed illustrator and longtime Stan Lee collaborator Jack Kirby is showing no sign of ending. Kirby’s family claims that Marvel should no longer retain the copyright for the work Kirby, who died in 1994, did on such iconic superheroes as Iron Man, X-Men, the […]

  • Alice Eve's Comedy 'Bees Make Honey'

    Film News Roundup: Alice Eve's Comedy 'Bees Make Honey' Set for July Release

    A legal battle between comics giant Marvel and the estate of famed illustrator and longtime Stan Lee collaborator Jack Kirby is showing no sign of ending. Kirby’s family claims that Marvel should no longer retain the copyright for the work Kirby, who died in 1994, did on such iconic superheroes as Iron Man, X-Men, the […]

  • China Appoints Wang Xiaohui as Film

    China Appoints Wang Xiaohui as Film Bureau Chief

    A legal battle between comics giant Marvel and the estate of famed illustrator and longtime Stan Lee collaborator Jack Kirby is showing no sign of ending. Kirby’s family claims that Marvel should no longer retain the copyright for the work Kirby, who died in 1994, did on such iconic superheroes as Iron Man, X-Men, the […]

  • Morgan Freeman Sexual Harassment

    Morgan Freeman Pulled From Visa Marketing After Harassment Allegations

    A legal battle between comics giant Marvel and the estate of famed illustrator and longtime Stan Lee collaborator Jack Kirby is showing no sign of ending. Kirby’s family claims that Marvel should no longer retain the copyright for the work Kirby, who died in 1994, did on such iconic superheroes as Iron Man, X-Men, the […]

  • Boba Fett movie

    ‘Star Wars:’ A Boba Fett Movie Is in the Works

    A legal battle between comics giant Marvel and the estate of famed illustrator and longtime Stan Lee collaborator Jack Kirby is showing no sign of ending. Kirby’s family claims that Marvel should no longer retain the copyright for the work Kirby, who died in 1994, did on such iconic superheroes as Iron Man, X-Men, the […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content