Maura Tierney, Lauren Graham and the ‘Sliding Doors’ of ‘Parenthood’

Maura3Lauren

Speaking of alternate universes, after three episodes of NBC’s “Parenthood” I’m still finding it hard to watch any scene with Lauren Graham and not think of how Maura Tierney would have played it, had she not had to bow out of the series because of cancer.

It’s more than distracting — it’s almost certainly affecting my overall feelings about the show in a negative way. And I don’t mean that as a criticism of Graham. It’s just that Tierney is such a forceful, edgy presence (as was the case in the original, unaired pilot shown to the press last summer) that the lightness Graham brings to the role seems almost frivolous — even when she’s upset about something. When Graham’s Sarah Braverman can’t find a job or fights with her daughter, I just feel that however much it affects her, it would affect Tierney’s Sarah more profoundly.

In general, watching “Parenthood” is a bit of a bipolar experience. I bow to no one in my admiration for showrunner Jason Katims, the genius behind “Friday Night Lights,” but frankly, “Parenthood” is to “Lights” as Graham is to Tierney. It’s just softer and less compelling.

Storylines that would he handled with nuance on “Lights” are much more on the nose in “Parenthood.” Example: Two weeks in a row, “Parenthood” has given us scenes of other parents staring daggers at Erika Christensen’s thanklessly besieged Julia. Each time it was awfully heavy-handed, let alone how it felt to see it in back-to-back episodes.

Ramos But to continue the yin-yang theme, just when I’m ready to give up on “Parenthood,” the show will give me a scene with a line of dialogue or an approach that feels entirely fresh. Craig T. Nelson, who himself suffered from coming on more than a bit too strong in the show’s premiere, had a wonderfully nuanced moment when he copped to the marital problems he’s been having with wife Camille (Bonnie Bedelia). And Graham, to her credit, provided a great sounding board. I’ve also liked the way “Parenthood” has rescued Sarah Ramos (pictured) from her robotic performance as the younger sister on former NBC family drama “American Dreams” and let her show how much life she has as an actress.

By the way, I’m not at all ignorant of the fact that after the ratings struggles of “Lights,” on-the-nose moments and lighter performances might be exactly what Katims and “Parenthood” are going for. But it’s not as if “Parenthood” is knocking it out of the park in the ratings, so if there are choices being made, count one viewer who’d like to see the show err on the side of brilliant subtlety.

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 4

Leave a Reply

4 Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Karen says:

    Sure, Maura can do humor. Anybody can say something funny and it’d be funny. Lauren Graham perfects comedic timing which is something that so few people can really do. She brings the most bland, dull lines to life. But she can also transition to drama so well. She does tears and frustration as well as she does comedy. Overall, I just think LG is a better actress.

  2. Jon Weisman says:

    I’d just say that NewsRadio would prove beyond a doubt that Maura can do lightheartedness and humor.

  3. Joanne says:

    @Karen
    Maura Tierney does lightheartedness and humor very well. She was great in “Newsradio” and can absolutely hold her own opposite some of the best comedians in the business.
    I love Lauren. I think she will get many awards for this portrayal (both actresses are long overdue), but I do believe Maura could have brought so much more to the role.

  4. Karen says:

    I love MT but I can’t imagine her in this role at all. She’s a good actress but she isn’t anywhere near as charming as Lauren Graham. She plays the drama so well but she cannot do lightheartedness and humor at all. Lauren Graham can do both and she does them beautifully. MT would have made the character too much of a downer.

More TV News from Variety

Loading