First-time comedy winner guaranteed

Supporting actress noms neven won Emmy

Lead Actress – Comedy | Lead Actress – Drama | Supporting Actress – Comedy | Supporting Actress – Drama | Lead Actress – Mini/Movie
View the photo gallery

Although Emmy loves repeat winners, this year promises a change.

There will be a first-time winner in this category, because all are nominees who have never won or have won in a different category. The winners from the past two years — Kristen Chenoweth and Jean Smart of “Pushing Daisies” and “Samantha Who?” respectively — don’t have their shows on the air anymore.

That isn’t to say there aren’t repeat nominees in the running. Holland Taylor, who took home a supporting Emmy over 10 years ago for “The Practice,” is up a fourth time playing caustic matriarch Evelyn Harper on CBS’ hit sitcom “Two and a Half Men.” Versatile performers Kristen Wiig of “Saturday Night Live” and Jane Krakowski of “30 Rock,” meanwhile, shared a category nod last year. It’s the second nom for each.

The other half of this six-strong lineup is new to the Emmy fold. First-time nominee Jane Lynch is enjoying a banner year as the scheming, track-suited cheerleader coach Sue Sylvester on Fox’s multiple-Emmy-nominated “Glee.” (Lynch even has a companion nomination in the guest star category for “Two and a Half Men.”)

The season’s other breakout comedy hit was ABC’s witty, heartwarming sitcom “Modern Family,” which gets dual representation in this category for its pair of very different moms: Julie Bowen’s exasperated household wrangler Claire Dunphy, and Sofia Vergara’s Colombian spitfire Gloria Delgado-Pritchett.

As with last year, the supporting actress category boasts the widest range of show formats, from hourlong musical dramedy (“Glee”) to sketch variety (“Saturday Night Live”) to halfhour sitcoms, both single-camera (“30 Rock,” “Modern Family”) and multicams filmed before a live audience (“Two and a Half Men”).

Jane Lynch
Emmy pedigree: First nom
Best scene: Nearly all of “The Power of Madonna” episode, which chronicled Sue Sylvester’s multifaceted love of the pop star, including a delicious, Sue-centric recreation of the “Vogue” video.
Why she might win: Lynch’s pitch-perfect character is already a pop culture icon of antagonistic hilarity, and, arguably, the dominant face of 19-nominee “Glee.”
Maybe not: A small quibble, perhaps, but outright meanspiritedness doesn’t always translate to an award.

Julie Bowen
“Modern Family”
Emmy pedigree: First nom
Best scene: After a hotel bar stab at sexy role-playing with her husband Phil (Ty Burrell), Claire’s naked-under-her-coat gambit takes a decidedly humiliating turn on an escalator.
Why she might win: After years of sitcom wife moms, Bowen’s exasperatedly witty turn gave an often underwritten sitcom archetype new life.
Maybe not: It’s not a showy performance, and with supporting nods, broad can often win out over subtle.

Sofia Vergara
“Modern Family”
Emmy pedigree: First nom
Best scene: A sweet-voiced paean to the urban charm of her old rundown neighborhood turns into a hilariously vicious rant in the street when, after returning from a divey restaurant, Gloria discovers Cam’s car’s tires have been stripped.
Why she might win: Proving that she’s more than a hot body and a winning smile, Vergara’s comic verve trumped sexiness whenever she got the spotlight.
Maybe not: It’s a big cast, and she’s in the same category as her co-star Julie Bowen. Will they cancel each other out?

Kristen Wiig
“Saturday Night Live”
Emmy pedigree: One previous nom
Best scene: There’s no getting around the fantastic slow-build insanity of Wiig’s character Sue, a woman whose love of surprises and inability to deal with suspense is catastrophic.
Why she might win: Wiig has proven she is the leading comic light of the venerable sketch series, adept with everything from deadpan moments to over-the-top freakouts.
Maybe not: It has been proven routinely difficult for “SNL” players to win Emmys — much less get nominated — over these many years.

Jane Krakowski
“30 Rock”
Emmy pedigree: One previous nom
Best scene: Taking love of adulation to twisted extremes, Jenna (Krakowski) seeks out her longtime stalker to determine why he hasn’t been paying attention of late.
Why she might win: Appreciation for Krakowski’s riotous depiction of showbiz vanity only grows with each year of “30 Rock,” and for such a beloved Emmy show, it could be her time.
Maybe not: “30 Rock” has already been honored so much, she could get left by the wayside.

Holland Taylor
“Two and a Half Men”
Emmy pedigree: One win, plus five previous noms
Best scene: Evelyn enacts a campaign of strategic smothering on grown son Alan (Jon Cryer) when he’s forced to move in with her.
Why she might win: Old-school one-liner mastery has its champions, and Taylor is currently its week-in, week-out queen. Her many nominations for the role could also finally push her toward a win.
Maybe not: With performers of so many different comic stripes in this category, acknowledging Holland’s talents isn’t as easy a decision as in the years when three-camera sitcoms dominated.

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Scene News from Variety