Review: ‘We Are What We Are’

Jorge Michel Grau's "We Are What We Are" reps a skillfully mannered genre-bender that tackles the queasy subject of cannibalism.

Doing for an impoverished Mexican family what “Let the Right One In” did for Swedish kids in puberty, Jorge Michel Grau’s “We Are What We Are” reps a skillfully mannered genre-bender that tackles the queasy subject of cannibalism. Focusing with superb aesthetics on a clan of flesh-eaters who, following their father’s demise, are forced to bring home the bacon themselves, pic begins by tracing the death’s effect on three sheltered siblings and then heads slowly but surely toward thriller territory before culminating in mucha sangre. A meaty diet of arthouses and cult followers awaits this Cannes Directors’ Fortnight selection.

At first, it’s hard to tell where this portrait of a family rattled by the death of their patriarch (Humberto Yanez) and suffering amid Mexico City’s gloomy urban sprawl is headed. While auds have already seen dad keel over at the shopping mall, his wife Patricia (Carmen Beato), sons Alfredo (Francisco Barreiro, doing sharp work) and Julian (Alan Chavez), and commanding daughter Sabina (Paulina Gaitan of “Sin Nombre”) seem more bothered by the fact that he hasn’t made it home to deliver what seems to be an essential household item — a human body, preferably one that’s still alive and ready to be sacrificed in a gory ritual that takes place on the dining room table. After that, it’s chow time.

Julian and Alfredo are promptly assigned to take care of the hunt, but the former is too aggressive and the latter too wimpy to score the right bait, which does not make Mom happy. When a side plot develops about a dopey detective (Jorge Zarate) who’s on their trail, it becomes clear that debuting helmer Grau is actually telling two stories at once: The first a classic cop-vs.-killer chiller that builds its suspense in convincing ways, the second a dark look into family dynamics and how kids cope with responsibilities they’re not necessarily ready, or willing, to inherit.

Skillfully weaving the narrative together via Santiago Sanchez’s constantly tracking widescreen compositions and Enrico Chapela’s moody chamber music, Grau shows an assured directorial hand, keeping much of the worst violence off-camera before plunging into a convincing crop of prosthetics and corn syrup in the closing scenes. He also reveals a sly sense of humor that makes the tough material easy enough to stomach, with several moments scoring laughs during a Cannes screening.

Like the vampire rites in “Let the Right One In,” cannibalism is more strongly alluded to than actually witnessed onscreen. When the gruesome act finally does arrive, it comes as a disturbing reminder that “We Are What We Are” is essentially about members of a very troubled family who are what they eat.

We Are What We Are



A Centro de Capacitacion Cinematografica, Fondo Para La Produccion Cinematografica de Calidad Mexico production. (International sales: Wild Bunch, Paris.) Produced by Nicolas Celis. Executive producers, Liliana Pardo, Henner Hofmann. Directed, written by Jorge Michel Grau.


Camera (color, Panavision widescreen), Santiago Sanchez; editor, Rodrigo Rios; music, Enrico Chapela; production designer, Alejandro Garcia; costume designer, Fernanda Velez; sound (Dolby Digital), Alex Munoz; sound designer, Frederico Schmucler; visual effects supervisor, Michael Hoffman; makeup designer, Francesca Della Benetta; assistant director, Erik Baeza; casting, April Therese Shannon, Ehectal Garcia. Reviewed at Cannes Film Festival (Directors' Fortnight), May 15, 2010. Running time: 89 MIN.


Francisco Barreiro, Alan Chavez, Paulina Gaitan, Carmen Beato, Jorge Zarate, Esteban Soberanes, Humberto Yanez.
(Spanish dialogue)

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety