Review: ‘The Flowers of Kirkuk’

A worthy message is suffocated by soap-style dialogue and plotting in "The Flowers of Kirkuk."

A worthy message is suffocated by soap-style dialogue and plotting in “The Flowers of Kirkuk,” the sophomore feature from Italian-based Kurdish helmer Fariborz Kamkari. Set in Iraq during the last year of the Iran-Iraq War, the pic recounts the impossible love between an Arab woman and a Kurdish man, but admirable sentiments are lost in a script that tries patience and believability. Star Morjana Alaoui, so memorable in her debut, “Marock,” deserves a better vehicle for her talents. Commercial prospects are unlikely to survive probable critical drubbing, while the presence of superior Kurdish product may limit fest travel.

On receiving a letter from her fiance, Sherko (model Ertem Eser), saying they must never see each other again, medical intern Najla (Alaoui) drops her studies in Italy to return to Iraq and confront Sherko on his mysterious change of heart. It’s 1988, when the Kurdish parts of the country are especially riven by internal strife; Kamkari’s inclusion of a very tired shot of a doll run over by an army truck signals his lack of subtlety.

Najla finally locates Sherko in a Kurdish enclave, but not before assisting in a difficult childbirth, when as soon as the baby pops out, the new mother (Shilan Rahmani) warns Najla to stay away. Medical ethics and true love transcend ethnic tensions, but Najla’s cartoonishly macho/devout cousin Rasheed (Ashraf Hamdi) does all he can to keep the pair apart, while rising army officer Mokhtar (Mohamed Zouaoui, far more nuanced) tries to convince Najla he’s real husband material.

By the time Najla’s arrested and placed in a theatrically blood-splattered torture room, “Flowers” starts to resemble a grade-C anti-Nazi pic from the 1940s, with situations that beggar belief coupled with lines such as “Kirkuk is no place for love.” Vet thesp Mohammed Bakri bookends the pic as Sherko 20 years on, returning to the scene after Saddam Hussein’s fall in a superfluous attempt to evoke the bittersweet relief of Iraqi-Kurdish semi-independence.

Whispered poetry, accompanied by guitar music, does not help evoke a mood of longing, and the real tragedy of the Kurdish genocide is subsumed by contrived meller situations. Kamkari hasn’t been able to smooth out the clumsiness of execution apparent in his debut feature, “The Forbidden Chapter,” despite Alaoui’s charisma and Eser’s visual charms. Lensing is solid if unremarkable, utilizing largely controlled handheld camerawork to convey a sense of instability. Overly artificial lighting, however, will play better on TV.

The Flowers of Kirkuk



A Medusa (in Italy)/Columbus Film (in Switzerland) release of a Far Out Films, T&C Film, Oskar, RSI/SRG SSR, Visual K Prod. production, in collaboration with RAI Cinema. (International sales: Adriana Chiesa Enterprises, Rome.) Produced by Fabrizia Falzetti. Co-producers, Marcel Hoehn, Dorotea Morlicchio, Francesca Morlicchio, Claudio Tesauro, Carlo Nizzo, Michelangelo Morlicchio, Giulia Fretta, Fekri Baroshi. Directed by Fariborz Kamkari. Screenplay, Fariborz Kamkari, Naseh Kamkari.


Camera (color), Marco Carosi; editor, Marco Spoletini; music, Orchestra di Piazza Vittorio; production designers, Malak Djahan Khazai, Sima Yazdanfar; costume designers, Khazai, Simona Marra; sound (Dolby Digital), Patrick Becker, Marta Billingsley, Alessandro Giacco; casting, Nicolas Lublin. Reviewed at Rome Film Festival (competing), Nov. 1, 2010. Running time: 120 MIN.


Morjana Alaoui, Ertem Eser, Mohamed Zouaoui, Mohammed Bakri, Maryam Hassouni, Ashraf Hamdi, Falah Fleyeh, Shilan Rahmani, Sarkaw Gorany, Fehd Benchesmi. (Arabic, Kurdish dialogue)

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety