Review: ‘South Solitary’

Spectacular locations only partially compensate for lukewarm soul-searching and comic romance.

Spectacular locations only partially compensate for lukewarm soul-searching and comic romance in overlong period piece “South Solitary.” Sydney fest opener, about an insecure spinster who accompanies her persnickety uncle to a remote lighthouse and inches toward a sort-of relationship with a taciturn WWI vet, is long on meandering dialogue and short on rewarding character connections. Toplining “Lord of the Rings” alumni Miranda Otto and Marton Csokas, scripter-helmer Shirley Barrett’s first feature since overlooked gem “Walk the Talk” (2000) will likely struggle to attract mature upscale target auds on July 15 domestic release. Modest fest travels and offshore ancillary are indicated.

In some respects, Barrett’s highly anticipated (in Oz) return thematically recalls “Love Serenade,” her bouncy 1996 Camera d’Or-winning debut about romantically maladroit sisters falling for an unusual man in an out-of-the-way place. Big difference here is that the male in “Solitary” is barely seen for the first hour and utters too little of consequence when he finally hits the spotlight.

Early running is dominated by George Wadsworth (Barry Otto, father of Miranda), a lighthouse keeper and fusspot sent in 1927 to take charge of the isolated South Solitary beacon following the suicide of its former guardian. The installation has been poorly run in the interim by assistant keepers Harry Stanley (Rohan Nichol) and Fleet (Csokas), a withdrawn Welshman with unspecified mental scarring apparently related to WWI.

By Wadsworth’s side (and arriving with a symbolic lamb in her arms, no less) is his 35-year-old niece, Meredith (Miranda Otto). Shamed and devoid of income since having had an affair with a married man, Meredith has no choice but to rely on her only relative’s support and silently suffer his haughtiness and cruelty. Chipper in the face of everything, Meredith makes little headway in her attempts to befriend Harry’s straight-talking wife, Alma (Essie Davis), and young daughter, Nettie (Annie Martin), an oddball whose treasured box filled with her picked-off scabs may leave some viewers clucking in distaste.

With Fleet barely visible yet clearly marked as the catalyst, the narrative loses propulsion with extended scenes of Meredith wandering around the water and wind-battered locale before falling into a passionless affair with Harry. But soon afterward, the screenplay abruptly jettisons the Stanley family and Wadsworth, leaving Meredith and Fleet alone to slowly and chastely heal each other’s wounds.

Interplay between the two lost souls is well performed and not without its pleasures. Fleet’s deadpan observations on assorted topics are amusing, and Meredith’s growing sense of self injects a welcome note of optimism. But for all the talk and symbolic visuals of lonely lights searching the darkness, the script fails to get fully under the skin of its central couple and engender the emotional investment crucial to this type of slow-burn character study.

Lensing around Cape Nelson and Cape Otway lighthouses in Southern Victoria by d.p. Anna Howard is never less than striking. Production design and costuming are impeccable; string-based score veers toward the twee at times. Other technical contributions are of a high standard.

South Solitary



An Icon Film Distribution release of a Screen Australia presentation of Macgowan Films production, in association with Omnilab Media, Film Victoria, Screen. (International sales: E1 Entertainment, Toronto.) Produced by Marian Macgowan. Executive producers, Philip Keir, Emile Sherman, Sarah Radclyffe. Co - producer, Miranda Culley. Directed, written by Shirley Barrett.


Camera (color), Anna Howard; editor, Denise Haratzis; music, Mary Finsterer; production designer, Paul Heath; art director, Jane Murphy; costume designer, Edie Kurzer; sound (Dolby Digital), Gary Wilkins; visual effects supervisor, Soren Jensen; line producer, Barbara Gibbs; assistant director, John Powditch; second unit camera, Martin Johnson; casting, Anne Robinson. Reviewed at Sydney Film Festival (opener, noncompeting), June 2, 2010. Running time: 120 MIN.


Miranda Otto, Marton Csokas, Essie Davis, Rohan Nichol, Barry Otto, Annie Martin, Reef Ireland, Benson Adams, Graham Tait.
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety