You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

S.O.S. State of Security: Richard A. Clarke’s Quest for Truth

This strident pic hasn't got enough new to say to invade theatrical venues.

Cast:
With: Richard A. Clarke, Paul Eaton, Daniel Prieto, Pietar Zatko.

Richard A. Clarke, the counterterrorism advisor who publicly apologized for the government’s failure at the 9/11 commission hearings, is given hagiographic treatment in scattershot docu “S.O.S. State of Security: Richard A. Clarke’s Quest for Truth.” As the pic’s overstuffed title suggests, helmer Michele Ohayon’s crams too much in: a career profile of Clarke, analysis of how vulnerable America still is to terrorist attack, and denunciation of wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. Left-leaning auds won’t fail but to agree, but this strident pic hasn’t got enough new to say to invade theatrical venues. Public broadcasters and politically minded fests should offer rescue.

Per her statement, helmer Ohayon (“Steal a Pencil for Me”) was approached by Clarke himself to make a documentary inspired by his 2008 nonfiction tome “Your Government Failed You: Breaking the Cycle of National Disasters.” Presumably, the resulting docu is faithful to the book, since it certainly feels like a promotional effort.

Clarke makes cogent points throughout about how the U.S. government let its citizens down and cost lives by failing to heed warnings about threats from Al Qaeda, while archive footage reprises his principled stand before the 9/11 commission. Assorted former colleagues semi-affectionately acknowledge his gruff personality, but by and large, interviewees from the CIA and Dept. of Homeland Security support his stated views on the failure of intelligence that led to the Iraq War and the wastefulness of how money is spent on security.

All that’s fair enough, but there are too many other strands at play. Various interviewees explain in alarming fashion how the ports of Los Angeles and Boston, for example, still present targets highly vulnerable to attack, as do ordinary shopping malls in Middle America. A liberal Muslim cleric tries to explain how Islam is essentially peace-loving, while his children share their own experiences of bullying in school in the wake of 9/11. A hacker whom Clarke recruited as an advisor when he was czar of cyber-security explains how easily even the most firewalled database in the world could be broken into by a determined guy with a computer.

Sequences showing Clarke guiding grad students at Harvard through mock situation-room scenarios seem less germane, and look highly staged for the camera. Frequent shots of Clarke studiously tapping his keyboard or looking thoughtful add tacky, TV-profile flavor.

That the pic flows at all from one idea to the next is a minor miracle of editing, credited to Edgar Burcksen. That said, the splicing in “S.O.S.” would be more deserving of praise if it didn’t blot its copybook with so many heavyhanded, thumping cutaways to illustrate points with painful literalness. The score by Joseph Julian Gonzalez is bombastic and overbearing.

S.O.S. State of Security: Richard A. Clarke's Quest for Truth

Production: A Sidney Kimmel Entertainment presentation of a Diamond Lane Film production. (International sales: Diamond Lane Film, Los Angeles.) Produced by Michele Ohayon, Gary J. Prebula, Len Sherman. Executive producers, Gary Ungar. Directed, written by Michele Ohayon.

Crew: Camera (color/B&W, HD), Theo van de Sande; editor, Edgar Burcksen; music, Joseph Julian Gonzalez; sound, Susumu Tokuno, Percy Urgana; sound supervisor, Michael Bard. Reviewed at Berlin Film Festival (Berlinale Special), Feb. 19, 2010. Running time: 102 MIN.

With: With: Richard A. Clarke, Paul Eaton, Daniel Prieto, Pietar Zatko.

More Film

  • Jerrod Carmichael and Lil Rel Howery

    Busan Facetime: Director Kamila Andini on Balancing Motherhood and Filmmaking

    Richard A. Clarke, the counterterrorism advisor who publicly apologized for the government’s failure at the 9/11 commission hearings, is given hagiographic treatment in scattershot docu “S.O.S. State of Security: Richard A. Clarke’s Quest for Truth.” As the pic’s overstuffed title suggests, helmer Michele Ohayon’s crams too much in: a career profile of Clarke, analysis of […]

  • VidAngel logo

    VidAngel Declares Bankruptcy to Put Copyright Fight on Hold

    Richard A. Clarke, the counterterrorism advisor who publicly apologized for the government’s failure at the 9/11 commission hearings, is given hagiographic treatment in scattershot docu “S.O.S. State of Security: Richard A. Clarke’s Quest for Truth.” As the pic’s overstuffed title suggests, helmer Michele Ohayon’s crams too much in: a career profile of Clarke, analysis of […]

  • Morgan Freeman Colin Powell

    Morgan Freeman to Play Colin Powell in Biopic

    Richard A. Clarke, the counterterrorism advisor who publicly apologized for the government’s failure at the 9/11 commission hearings, is given hagiographic treatment in scattershot docu “S.O.S. State of Security: Richard A. Clarke’s Quest for Truth.” As the pic’s overstuffed title suggests, helmer Michele Ohayon’s crams too much in: a career profile of Clarke, analysis of […]

  • Channing Tatum

    Channing Tatum Pulls Sexual Abuse Movie, Cutting Ties With Weinstein Company

    Richard A. Clarke, the counterterrorism advisor who publicly apologized for the government’s failure at the 9/11 commission hearings, is given hagiographic treatment in scattershot docu “S.O.S. State of Security: Richard A. Clarke’s Quest for Truth.” As the pic’s overstuffed title suggests, helmer Michele Ohayon’s crams too much in: a career profile of Clarke, analysis of […]

  • DSCF3404.raf

    Los Angeles Feature Film Production Increases 7.6% in Third Quarter

    Richard A. Clarke, the counterterrorism advisor who publicly apologized for the government’s failure at the 9/11 commission hearings, is given hagiographic treatment in scattershot docu “S.O.S. State of Security: Richard A. Clarke’s Quest for Truth.” As the pic’s overstuffed title suggests, helmer Michele Ohayon’s crams too much in: a career profile of Clarke, analysis of […]

  • Brigsby Bear and Kyle Mooney'Brigsby Bear'

    L.A. Film Festival Moving to September From June, Partnering With Arclight

    Richard A. Clarke, the counterterrorism advisor who publicly apologized for the government’s failure at the 9/11 commission hearings, is given hagiographic treatment in scattershot docu “S.O.S. State of Security: Richard A. Clarke’s Quest for Truth.” As the pic’s overstuffed title suggests, helmer Michele Ohayon’s crams too much in: a career profile of Clarke, analysis of […]

  • Oscars: Netflix, Errol Morris Defy Convention

    Oscars: Netflix and Errol Morris Defy Convention With Hybrid Doc 'Wormwood'

    Richard A. Clarke, the counterterrorism advisor who publicly apologized for the government’s failure at the 9/11 commission hearings, is given hagiographic treatment in scattershot docu “S.O.S. State of Security: Richard A. Clarke’s Quest for Truth.” As the pic’s overstuffed title suggests, helmer Michele Ohayon’s crams too much in: a career profile of Clarke, analysis of […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content