General Nil

A history lesson sapped of energy.

With:
(Polish, Russian dialogue)

A history lesson sapped of energy, Ryszard Bugajski’s “General Nil” relates in blandly conventional terms the final years of WWII Polish freedom fighter Gen. Emil “Nil” Fieldorf, an enemy of both Nazis and Soviets. That Fieldorf led the antifascist underground during wartime proves meaningless to the invading Soviet masters, who deem him persona non grata — and worse — for leading a guerrilla fight against the occupiers from the East. History buffs will take some interest in a figure little known beyond his native land, but they’ll have to wait for the DVD.

A flash-forward to a Siberian-bound train in 1947 establishes the film’s lumpy back-and-forth narrative structure, showing Fieldorf (Olgierd Lukaszewicz) ailing under severe conditions and aided by young supporter Michal (Maciej Radel). Bugajski, whose international rep rests on his 1982 drama, “Interrogation,” proves to be a solid handler of action, as Fieldorf is seen in 1944 Warsaw devising a bold daylight attack against Nazi HQ.

A vague jump in time situates Fieldorf in the midst of a conspiracy against the new Soviet threat (the rebel operation is codenamed “No,” with Fieldorf known as “Gen. Nil”). Fieldorf’s worry that a lack of Allied support for Polish resistance to USSR occupation shadows the rest of the film’s dramatic beats as the action finally settles in for a year-by-year account of Fieldorf’s new postwar life from 1947-53. Standard biopic devices the general’s difficult domestic life with wife Janina (Alicja Juchiewicz), who has chafed under the strain of his long absences from home, and efforts by friends, who urge him to emigrate, join the establishment or form some sort of resistance.

Since a tragic fate is a foregone conclusion, even for viewers with no knowledge of Fieldorf’s career, “General Nil” becomes a stodgy account of early Cold War politics, and betrays the whiff of a patriotic, nationalist brand of cinema. It hardly helps that Lukaszewicz is not the kind of actor to command attention the way Fieldorf commanded men; a strange lack of charisma hinders the actor’s ability to transcend the material’s mechanical nature.

Production values are topnotch in the old-school “tradition of quality” mode, including a chiaroscuro tone informing Piotr Sliskowski’s cinematography and a wide range of historically authentic settings designed by Aniko Kiss.

General Nil

Poland

Production: A Wytwornia Film Studio/Monolith Films/Polish Telecommunications presentation. Produced by Wlodzimierz Niderhaus. Co-producers, Mamusz Lukomski, Dominique Lesage, Francois-Arnaud Remael. Directed by Ryszard Bugajski. Screenplay, Krzysztof Lukaszewicz, Bugajski.

Crew: Camera (color, widescreen), Piotr Sliskowski; editor, Ewa Romanowska-Rozewwicz; music, Shane Harvey; production designer, Aniko Kiss; costume designers, Malgorzata Zacharska, Andrzej Szenajch; sound (Dolby Digital), Alexander Musialowski. Reviewed on DVD, Los Angeles, April 1, 2010. (In Polish Film Festival Los Angeles, 2009 Montreal World Film Festival.) Running time: 120 MIN.

With: (Polish, Russian dialogue)

More Film

  • Rebel Wilson and Taye Diggs

    Concert Review: 'Beauty and the Beast' Gets Adoring Tribute at Hollywood Bowl

    A history lesson sapped of energy, Ryszard Bugajski’s “General Nil” relates in blandly conventional terms the final years of WWII Polish freedom fighter Gen. Emil “Nil” Fieldorf, an enemy of both Nazis and Soviets. That Fieldorf led the antifascist underground during wartime proves meaningless to the invading Soviet masters, who deem him persona non grata […]

  • Solo a Star Wars Story Deadpool

    It's Official: Deadpool Is Now Cooler Than Han Solo

    A history lesson sapped of energy, Ryszard Bugajski’s “General Nil” relates in blandly conventional terms the final years of WWII Polish freedom fighter Gen. Emil “Nil” Fieldorf, an enemy of both Nazis and Soviets. That Fieldorf led the antifascist underground during wartime proves meaningless to the invading Soviet masters, who deem him persona non grata […]

  • solo a star wars story

    Box Office: 'Solo: A Star Wars Story' Headed for Underwhelming Holiday Weekend Debut

    A history lesson sapped of energy, Ryszard Bugajski’s “General Nil” relates in blandly conventional terms the final years of WWII Polish freedom fighter Gen. Emil “Nil” Fieldorf, an enemy of both Nazis and Soviets. That Fieldorf led the antifascist underground during wartime proves meaningless to the invading Soviet masters, who deem him persona non grata […]

  • solo a star wars story

    How the Kasdans Settled the Biggest Debate in 'Star Wars' History With 'Solo'

    A history lesson sapped of energy, Ryszard Bugajski’s “General Nil” relates in blandly conventional terms the final years of WWII Polish freedom fighter Gen. Emil “Nil” Fieldorf, an enemy of both Nazis and Soviets. That Fieldorf led the antifascist underground during wartime proves meaningless to the invading Soviet masters, who deem him persona non grata […]

  • Morgan Freeman Sexual Harassment

    Morgan Freeman Issues New Statement: 'I Did Not Assault Women'

    A history lesson sapped of energy, Ryszard Bugajski’s “General Nil” relates in blandly conventional terms the final years of WWII Polish freedom fighter Gen. Emil “Nil” Fieldorf, an enemy of both Nazis and Soviets. That Fieldorf led the antifascist underground during wartime proves meaningless to the invading Soviet masters, who deem him persona non grata […]

  • Euphoria Review

    Cannes Film Review: 'Euphoria'

    A history lesson sapped of energy, Ryszard Bugajski’s “General Nil” relates in blandly conventional terms the final years of WWII Polish freedom fighter Gen. Emil “Nil” Fieldorf, an enemy of both Nazis and Soviets. That Fieldorf led the antifascist underground during wartime proves meaningless to the invading Soviet masters, who deem him persona non grata […]

  • David Permut

    David Permut, Naomi Kawase Join Shanghai Festival Jury

    A history lesson sapped of energy, Ryszard Bugajski’s “General Nil” relates in blandly conventional terms the final years of WWII Polish freedom fighter Gen. Emil “Nil” Fieldorf, an enemy of both Nazis and Soviets. That Fieldorf led the antifascist underground during wartime proves meaningless to the invading Soviet masters, who deem him persona non grata […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content