Review: ‘A Surprise in Texas’

'A Surprise in Texas'

The title is misleading, since there's very little that is startling about the final verdict.

The title is misleading, since there’s very little that is startling about the final verdict in “A Surprise in Texas,” Peter Rosen’s workmanlike docu about the 13th Van Cliburn Intl. Piano Competition in Fort Worth, Texas. Even viewers who can’t tell the difference between an octave and an eggplant will be able to guess early on, thanks to Rosen’s disproportional allotment of screen time to competitors, which of the six finalists will triumph. Currently playing limited theatrical runs (as is another Van Cliburn docu, “They Came to Play”), pic will air on PBS in October.

Not surprisingly for a pic commissioned by the Van Cliburn Foundation, “Surprise” sounds mostly admiring and upbeat notes while following young pianists — ranging in age from late teens to mid-20s — through three grueling weeks of performances before demanding judges and capacity crowds during the 2009 competition. Juror Menahem Pressler frankly notes that, among all the hopefuls that ever have won top honors at the every-four-years competition, there have been only “a handful that have meant something to the world of music.” But the grand prizes include not only cash but recording contracts and performance tours, so the stakes are high and the competition intense.

Long before the lineup is reduced from 29 participants to 12 semifinalists, and then to six finalists for a decisive round of performances with the Fort Worth Symphony Orchestra, a clear favorite emerges: Nobuyuki Tsujii, a blind young virtuoso from Japan. Accompanied by his doting mother, Tsujii — whose childlike enthusiasm is by turns engaging and offputting — is encouraged by his well-to-do Texas hosts, John and Carol Davidson, who blithely dismiss any carping by a local music critic about their guest’s competition performances. The audience’s standing ovation, they pointedly note, counts for more.

Among the other competitors, only two make similarly strong impressions: Zhang Haochen, a boyish Chinese pianist who comes off like a not-so-distant relation of the “McLovin’ ” character played by Christopher Mintz-Plasse in “Superbad,” and Yeol Eum-son, a charming South Korean who prepares for her performances with a regimen of rope-skipping and stretching exercises.

For all the intriguing and/or affecting backstage glances at the competitors on their own, “Surprise” is most effective as a study of the demanding challenges of musicianship when, during its final third, Rosen covers the give-and-take sessions each competitor has with conductor James Condon prior to their final performances with the Fort Worth Symphony. Condon proves a charismatic screen presence, and his interplay with the competitors — along with his subsequent comments on that interplay — probably should have been the entire focus of another pic.

Classical music buffs will enjoy the varied selections played throughout, but may regret that “Surprise” offers only excerpts, not complete performances. Pic makes clever use of split-screen imagery during expository and scene-setting sequences.

A Surprise in Texas


A Peter Rosen Prods. release of a Peter Rosen production. Produced by Rosen. Executive producer, Richard Rodzinksi. Co-producer, Molly McBride. Directed by Peter Rosen. Performances directed by Karen McLaughlin.


Camera (color), Rosen, Ginny Martin, Joel Shapiro; editors, Rosen, Bob Jorissen, Brian Williams; sound, Matt Gundy. Reviewed on DVD, Houston, May 20, 2010. Running time: 92 MIN.


Nobuyuki Tsujii, Zhang Haochen, Yeol Eum-son, Di Wu, Evgeni Bozhanov, Mariangela Vacatello, Menahem Pressler, John Giorrano, James Condon, John Davidson, Carol Davidson.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety