Judge throws out scribes’ lawsuit

Similarities with 'God of War' due to cliche not copyright

A federal judge rejected claims that Sony’s “God of War” videogame infringes on a series of works from two Northern California screenwriters.

U.S. District Court Judge Marilyn Hall Patel, in a ruling issued on Tuesday, wrote that the similarities between screenplays written by Jonathan Bissoon-Dath and Jennifer B. Dath were merely “cliched and unprotected elements.”

“No reasonable trier of fact could conclude that ‘God of War’ is substantially similar to any of plaintiff’s works,” she wrote.

The screenwriters filed suit against Sony Computer Entertainment and David Jaffe, the lead designer of the “God of War” videogame. Their five treatments and screenplays are set against the backdrop of the Spartan attack on Athens, while “God of War” had the same ancient Greece setting.

Among other things, the plaintiffs argued that certain scenes and dialogue were similar or identical, such as scenes depicting a gathering of the gods. But Patel said such instances are “stock elements that have been used in literary and artistic works for years, if not millennia.” Moreover, she wrote, they “pointed to no persuasive similarity in dialogue or narration that would suggest actual copying.”

“God of War” was released in 2005 for PlayStation2.

More Scene

  • New York Premiere of Focus Features

    Stars Talk Daniel Day-Lewis Retirement at 'Phantom Thread' Premiere: 'We’d Like Him to Make More Films'

    A federal judge rejected claims that Sony’s “God of War” videogame infringes on a series of works from two Northern California screenwriters. U.S. District Court Judge Marilyn Hall Patel, in a ruling issued on Tuesday, wrote that the similarities between screenplays written by Jonathan Bissoon-Dath and Jennifer B. Dath were merely “cliched and unprotected elements.” […]

  • 'Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle' film

    Dwayne Johnson, Kevin Hart's 'Jumanji' Maintains 'Soul' of Robin Williams Original

    A federal judge rejected claims that Sony’s “God of War” videogame infringes on a series of works from two Northern California screenwriters. U.S. District Court Judge Marilyn Hall Patel, in a ruling issued on Tuesday, wrote that the similarities between screenplays written by Jonathan Bissoon-Dath and Jennifer B. Dath were merely “cliched and unprotected elements.” […]

  • John Cena Ferdinand

    'Ferdinand' Director on Why John Cena Was Perfect for Title Role

    A federal judge rejected claims that Sony’s “God of War” videogame infringes on a series of works from two Northern California screenwriters. U.S. District Court Judge Marilyn Hall Patel, in a ruling issued on Tuesday, wrote that the similarities between screenplays written by Jonathan Bissoon-Dath and Jennifer B. Dath were merely “cliched and unprotected elements.” […]

  • Asian-American Unforgettable Awards 2017

    'Westworld's' Leonardo Nam Says Seeing Asian Actors in ‘Star Wars’ ‘Feels Normal’

    A federal judge rejected claims that Sony’s “God of War” videogame infringes on a series of works from two Northern California screenwriters. U.S. District Court Judge Marilyn Hall Patel, in a ruling issued on Tuesday, wrote that the similarities between screenplays written by Jonathan Bissoon-Dath and Jennifer B. Dath were merely “cliched and unprotected elements.” […]

  • Mark Hamill'Star Wars: The Last Jedi'

    'Star Wars: The Last Jedi' Honors Late Carrie Fisher at Elaborate Premiere

    A federal judge rejected claims that Sony’s “God of War” videogame infringes on a series of works from two Northern California screenwriters. U.S. District Court Judge Marilyn Hall Patel, in a ruling issued on Tuesday, wrote that the similarities between screenplays written by Jonathan Bissoon-Dath and Jennifer B. Dath were merely “cliched and unprotected elements.” […]

  • Conan O'Brien Children's Defense Gala

    Kate Hudson, Conan O'Brien Attend Children's Defense Fund Gala: 'Some of You Literally Dodged Fire to Get Here'

    A federal judge rejected claims that Sony’s “God of War” videogame infringes on a series of works from two Northern California screenwriters. U.S. District Court Judge Marilyn Hall Patel, in a ruling issued on Tuesday, wrote that the similarities between screenplays written by Jonathan Bissoon-Dath and Jennifer B. Dath were merely “cliched and unprotected elements.” […]

  • Ajit Pai Free Speech

    FCC Chair Plays for Laughs at D.C. Event Amid Fierce Net Neutrality Debate

    A federal judge rejected claims that Sony’s “God of War” videogame infringes on a series of works from two Northern California screenwriters. U.S. District Court Judge Marilyn Hall Patel, in a ruling issued on Tuesday, wrote that the similarities between screenplays written by Jonathan Bissoon-Dath and Jennifer B. Dath were merely “cliched and unprotected elements.” […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content