You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

NYT Upfront Slapdown: Carr Disses Itzkoff on Kimmel

New York Times columnist David Carr was too polite, apparently, to formally slap someone working for his own paper, but his latest column not-so-subtly debunked Times contributor Dave Itzkoff’s take on Jimmy Kimmel’s performance at ABC’s May 19 upfront presentation.

As I stated in an earlier post, Itzkoff seemed inordinately shocked that Kimmel could keep his job after ridiculing ABC’s failure rate with new series during a brief standup turn at the event. Of course, the latenight host reserved his most pointed gags for NBC, saying the network was destroying itself by moving Jay Leno to primetime, but never mind.

Like me, Carr has been to the rodeo a few times before, so he pointed out that “some reports” about Kimmel were wrong — without indicating that said reports were disseminated under the aegis of his own paper.

“Contrary to some reports, he killed,” Carr wrote of Kimmel. “The room, stuffed to the gills with people who have been force-fed upfront claptrap for years, shook up and down with convulsive laughter. In years past, networks have been subjected to friendly fire from Triumph the Insult Comic Dog, Drew Carey and Conan O’Brien as a knowing nod to all the hyperbole, so everyone there was in on the joke.”

Not a big deal, really, except A) I think the Times probably should have spelled out the fact that Carr was presumably taking exception to the paper’s own coverage; and B) this is another small sign of what can happen when reporters are assigned to a beat who lack perspective or history. Suddenly, Kimmel’s barbs at ABC are a story because the familiar blather associated with the upfronts is all minty fresh to them.

So kudos to Carr for setting the record straight. Sort of.

More Voices

  • Hayes Theater

    'Torch Song,' Second Stage and the $64 Million Broadway Bet

    New York Times columnist David Carr was too polite, apparently, to formally slap someone working for his own paper, but his latest column not-so-subtly debunked Times contributor Dave Itzkoff’s take on Jimmy Kimmel’s performance at ABC’s May 19 upfront presentation. As I stated in an earlier post, Itzkoff seemed inordinately shocked that Kimmel could keep his job after […]

  • Phantom of the Opera Broadway

    What Broadway Learned From 'The Phantom of the Opera'

    New York Times columnist David Carr was too polite, apparently, to formally slap someone working for his own paper, but his latest column not-so-subtly debunked Times contributor Dave Itzkoff’s take on Jimmy Kimmel’s performance at ABC’s May 19 upfront presentation. As I stated in an earlier post, Itzkoff seemed inordinately shocked that Kimmel could keep his job after […]

  • lil yachty

    Fall Out Boy's Pete Wentz: Rock Is Alive — But You Might Not Know It When You Hear It (Guest Column)

    New York Times columnist David Carr was too polite, apparently, to formally slap someone working for his own paper, but his latest column not-so-subtly debunked Times contributor Dave Itzkoff’s take on Jimmy Kimmel’s performance at ABC’s May 19 upfront presentation. As I stated in an earlier post, Itzkoff seemed inordinately shocked that Kimmel could keep his job after […]

  • RWS Entertainment Group Marquee Holland America

    RWS Entertainment Launches Theatrical Development Department (EXCLUSIVE)

    New York Times columnist David Carr was too polite, apparently, to formally slap someone working for his own paper, but his latest column not-so-subtly debunked Times contributor Dave Itzkoff’s take on Jimmy Kimmel’s performance at ABC’s May 19 upfront presentation. As I stated in an earlier post, Itzkoff seemed inordinately shocked that Kimmel could keep his job after […]

  • Hamilton West End Production.

    ‘Hamilton,’ Broadway and the Duel Over Paperless Tickets

    New York Times columnist David Carr was too polite, apparently, to formally slap someone working for his own paper, but his latest column not-so-subtly debunked Times contributor Dave Itzkoff’s take on Jimmy Kimmel’s performance at ABC’s May 19 upfront presentation. As I stated in an earlier post, Itzkoff seemed inordinately shocked that Kimmel could keep his job after […]

  • HadestownNew York Theatre WorkshopBy Anaïs MitchellDeveloped

    Streaming to Broadway: How New Titles, Talent Grow Buzz Online

    New York Times columnist David Carr was too polite, apparently, to formally slap someone working for his own paper, but his latest column not-so-subtly debunked Times contributor Dave Itzkoff’s take on Jimmy Kimmel’s performance at ABC’s May 19 upfront presentation. As I stated in an earlier post, Itzkoff seemed inordinately shocked that Kimmel could keep his job after […]

  • Randall Arney Geffen Playhouse

    What No NYC Nonprofit Theater Likes to Talk About

    New York Times columnist David Carr was too polite, apparently, to formally slap someone working for his own paper, but his latest column not-so-subtly debunked Times contributor Dave Itzkoff’s take on Jimmy Kimmel’s performance at ABC’s May 19 upfront presentation. As I stated in an earlier post, Itzkoff seemed inordinately shocked that Kimmel could keep his job after […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content