Deadliest Warrior

Wow. Reality concepts don't come any goofier than "Deadliest Warrior," which sounds like an argument that guys would have after way too many beers -- as in, "Who would win in a fight, a Samurai or a Viking?" Alas, that's a later episode of this oddball series, which opens with an Apache-Gladiator matchup.

With:
Narrator: Drew Skye.

Wow. Reality concepts don’t come any goofier than “Deadliest Warrior,” which sounds like an argument that guys would have after way too many beers — as in, “Who would win in a fight, a Samurai or a Viking?” Alas, that’s a later episode of this oddball series, which opens with an Apache-Gladiator matchup. Even generous sprays of blood (and there are those) can’t redeem a show that’s 90% filler before its final showdown, in which two stuntmen play out a “fight” based on computer simulations. All told, it makes a Universal Studios stunt show look like “Masterpiece Theatre.”

Actually, there is precedent for using computer modeling to stage mythical fights, though that historically involved pitting boxing champions from different eras, say, against each other. Here, it’s really an excuse for further time-wasting in the gear-head TV genre, inasmuch as the show employs life-like mannequins to demonstrate the killing power of ancient weapons before putting them to use in the climactic mock contest.

In the premiere, that means letting experts on Apache and Roman gladiator fighting techniques sing their respective praises, almost like ESPN analysts. Future faceoffs will include (and I swear, I’m not making this up) Pirate vs. Knight, Yakuza vs. Mafia, Maori vs. Shaolin Monks, William Wallace vs. Shaka Zulu, Ninja vs. Spartan, Green Beret vs. Spetnaz, and Taliban vs. IRA — and honestly, I can’t wait to see who the advocate for the Taliban is.

The three series “regulars” include a biomedical engineer, an ER doctor and computer expert Max Geiger, who runs the battle-simulation program. This actually yields hundreds of possible outcomes, but the producers demonstrate just one of them, based on the percentages of who would win more often.

Then again, even that degree of explanation gives “Deadliest Warrior” more thought than it probably deserves. And while I’m all for stupid, violent TV that blatantly rips off the narration in “300,” Spike has nevertheless demonstrated that it’s possible to underestimate your intended audience’s intelligence even if they really are a bunch of beer-guzzling louts.

Put another way, in the battle of Critic vs. Cynical Low-Brow TV, score this as a one-sided ass-kicking.

Deadliest Warrior

Spike, Tues. April 7, 10 p.m.

Production: Produced by MorningStar Entertainment. Executive producers, Gary Tarpanian, Paninee Theeranuntawat; supervising producer, Tim Prokop; senior producer, Melody Shafir; director; Prokop.

Crew: Senior story producer, Gary Benthin; lead editor, Jeff Schiro; music, Michael Richard Plowman; stunt coordinator/choreographer, Alan Noel Vega. RUNNING TIME: 60 MIN.

Cast: Narrator: Drew Skye.

More TV

  • 'Picnic at Hanging Rock' Team on

    'Picnic at Hanging Rock' Team on Novel Inspiration for Their 'Enchanted Chiller'

    Wow. Reality concepts don’t come any goofier than “Deadliest Warrior,” which sounds like an argument that guys would have after way too many beers — as in, “Who would win in a fight, a Samurai or a Viking?” Alas, that’s a later episode of this oddball series, which opens with an Apache-Gladiator matchup. Even generous […]

  • Baskets renewed

    'Baskets' Renewed by FX for Season 4

    Wow. Reality concepts don’t come any goofier than “Deadliest Warrior,” which sounds like an argument that guys would have after way too many beers — as in, “Who would win in a fight, a Samurai or a Viking?” Alas, that’s a later episode of this oddball series, which opens with an Apache-Gladiator matchup. Even generous […]

  • Checco Varese

    Checco Varese Becomes Go-to Cinematographer for Launching TV Shows

    Wow. Reality concepts don’t come any goofier than “Deadliest Warrior,” which sounds like an argument that guys would have after way too many beers — as in, “Who would win in a fight, a Samurai or a Viking?” Alas, that’s a later episode of this oddball series, which opens with an Apache-Gladiator matchup. Even generous […]

  • BEVERLY HILLS, CA - MAY 23:

    'Solo: A Star Wars Story,' 'Coco' Composers Honored at ASCAP Screen Music Awards

    Wow. Reality concepts don’t come any goofier than “Deadliest Warrior,” which sounds like an argument that guys would have after way too many beers — as in, “Who would win in a fight, a Samurai or a Viking?” Alas, that’s a later episode of this oddball series, which opens with an Apache-Gladiator matchup. Even generous […]

  • Marlee Matlin Facetime Portrait

    Marlee Matlin Talks Trio of TV Roles: 'There's No Box I Fit Into'

    Wow. Reality concepts don’t come any goofier than “Deadliest Warrior,” which sounds like an argument that guys would have after way too many beers — as in, “Who would win in a fight, a Samurai or a Viking?” Alas, that’s a later episode of this oddball series, which opens with an Apache-Gladiator matchup. Even generous […]

  • John Wells photographed at John Wells

    John Wells' Company Finds New Digs as Industry Sees Rapid Changes

    Wow. Reality concepts don’t come any goofier than “Deadliest Warrior,” which sounds like an argument that guys would have after way too many beers — as in, “Who would win in a fight, a Samurai or a Viking?” Alas, that’s a later episode of this oddball series, which opens with an Apache-Gladiator matchup. Even generous […]

  • Movistar +, Netflix, Set Carriage Partnership

    Movistar +, Netflix Strike Carriage Partnership

    Wow. Reality concepts don’t come any goofier than “Deadliest Warrior,” which sounds like an argument that guys would have after way too many beers — as in, “Who would win in a fight, a Samurai or a Viking?” Alas, that’s a later episode of this oddball series, which opens with an Apache-Gladiator matchup. Even generous […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content