Wuthering Heights

For those understandably enamored of the 1939 Laurence Olivier-Merle Oberon version, this "Masterpiece Classic" retelling of "Wuthering Heights" does offer a few modern compensations, starting with an intense Tom Hardy as Heathcliff, who, along with Charlotte Riley's less-impressive Cathy, occupies the center of Emily Bronte's obsessive love quadrangle.

With:
Heathcliff - Tom Hardy Cathy - Charlotte Riley Hindley - Burn Gorman Edgar Linton - Andrew Lincoln Isabella - Rosalind Halstead Nelly - Sarah Lancashire Catherine - Rebecca Night Linton - Tom Payne

For those understandably enamored of the 1939 Laurence Olivier-Merle Oberon version, this “Masterpiece Classic” retelling of “Wuthering Heights” does offer a few modern compensations, starting with an intense Tom Hardy as Heathcliff, who, along with Charlotte Riley’s less-impressive Cathy, occupies the center of Emily Bronte’s obsessive love quadrangle. Writer Peter Bowker (“Blackpool”) has widened the lens to include the characters’ heirs, but the last hour of this 2½-hour production (presented in two unequal parts) lacks quite the wallop that part one delivers once it gets rolling.

The first 15 minutes or so, frankly, is a bit of a muddle, starting with Cathy’s grown daughter, Catherine (Rebecca Night), before flashing back to tell the elder generation’s story. (It doesn’t help that any effort to age the characters through makeup is virtually nonexistent, so the key players look 25 pretty much all the way through, even when they’re older.)

Beginning in the late 18th century, Bronte’s dark story centers on Cathy and her adopted brother Heathcliff, a poor Gypsy lad, who her blood brother Hindley (Burn Gorman) instantly resents and torments at every turn. Treated like a servant once his father dies, Heathcliff’s passion for Cathy is shaken when she is injured and ends up convalescing in the care of the aristocratic Edgar Linton (Andrew Lincoln), who soon proposes to her.

An angry Heathcliff flees, but he returns with a cryptic note on Cathy’s wedding day, and reveals himself later, having mysteriously won his fortune. Still powerfully drawn to Cathy and vice versa, he finally weds Linton’s sister Isabella (Rosalind Halstead), primarily as an act of spite after learning his beloved is pregnant.

Bowker and director Coky Giedroyc (who also oversaw “Masterpiece’s” upcoming “Oliver Twist”) capitalize on present-day latitude to incorporate more visceral elements into the story, including the depiction of Heathcliff’s cruelty toward the poor Isabella, a macabre scene that involves digging up a grave and Ruth Barrett’s percussive, jarringly modern score.

Yet while Hardy — with his brooding, deep-set eyes and perpetual scowl — is an extremely compelling presence (and also plays the sadistic Bill Sykes in “Twist”), Riley proves a less convincing object of that desire. Nor is the final act — despite its theme of undying love — the three-hankie affair that many will fondly remember, partly because the next generation proves relatively lackluster compared with the first.

For all that, it’s still an extremely handsome production, following “Tess of the D’Urbervilles” in what thus far looks to be a laudable season for the PBS showcase, embracing the slogan that something needn’t be black and white to feel like a classic.

Wuthering Heights

Two-part movie; PBS, Sun. Jan. 18, 25, 9 p.m.

Production: Filmed in the U.K. by Mammoth Screen and WGBH/Boston. Executive producers, Peter Bowker, Michele Buck, Damien Timmer, Hugo Heppell, Rebecca Eaton; producer, Radford Neville; director, Coky Giedroyc; writer, Bowker, based on the novel by Emily Bronte;

Crew: Camera, Ulf Brantas; production designer, Grenville Horner; editor, Mark Thornton; music, Ruth Barrett; casting, Susie Parriss. RUNNING TIME: 2½ HOURS.

Cast: Heathcliff - Tom Hardy Cathy - Charlotte Riley Hindley - Burn Gorman Edgar Linton - Andrew Lincoln Isabella - Rosalind Halstead Nelly - Sarah Lancashire Catherine - Rebecca Night Linton - Tom Payne

More Scene

  • Guillermo del Toro, Greta Gerwig and

    Timothée Chalamet Says He'd Love to Work With Christopher Nolan or Guillermo del Toro

    For those understandably enamored of the 1939 Laurence Olivier-Merle Oberon version, this “Masterpiece Classic” retelling of “Wuthering Heights” does offer a few modern compensations, starting with an intense Tom Hardy as Heathcliff, who, along with Charlotte Riley’s less-impressive Cathy, occupies the center of Emily Bronte’s obsessive love quadrangle. Writer Peter Bowker (“Blackpool”) has widened the […]

  • Tracee Ellis Ross

    Tracee Ellis Ross at Image Makers Awards: 'Clothing Started as Armor for Me'

    For those understandably enamored of the 1939 Laurence Olivier-Merle Oberon version, this “Masterpiece Classic” retelling of “Wuthering Heights” does offer a few modern compensations, starting with an intense Tom Hardy as Heathcliff, who, along with Charlotte Riley’s less-impressive Cathy, occupies the center of Emily Bronte’s obsessive love quadrangle. Writer Peter Bowker (“Blackpool”) has widened the […]

  • 'Salute to Service' Honored Industry Support

    Variety's 'Salute to Service' Presented by National Geographic Celebrates Industry Supporters of Troops, Veterans

    For those understandably enamored of the 1939 Laurence Olivier-Merle Oberon version, this “Masterpiece Classic” retelling of “Wuthering Heights” does offer a few modern compensations, starting with an intense Tom Hardy as Heathcliff, who, along with Charlotte Riley’s less-impressive Cathy, occupies the center of Emily Bronte’s obsessive love quadrangle. Writer Peter Bowker (“Blackpool”) has widened the […]

  • Rob Riggle Salute to Service

    Rob Riggle on Work With Veterans at Variety, National Geographic's Salute to Service: 'It's Who I Am'

    For those understandably enamored of the 1939 Laurence Olivier-Merle Oberon version, this “Masterpiece Classic” retelling of “Wuthering Heights” does offer a few modern compensations, starting with an intense Tom Hardy as Heathcliff, who, along with Charlotte Riley’s less-impressive Cathy, occupies the center of Emily Bronte’s obsessive love quadrangle. Writer Peter Bowker (“Blackpool”) has widened the […]

  • Golden Globes Timeline

    Inside the Glamorous Golden Globes After-Parties

    For those understandably enamored of the 1939 Laurence Olivier-Merle Oberon version, this “Masterpiece Classic” retelling of “Wuthering Heights” does offer a few modern compensations, starting with an intense Tom Hardy as Heathcliff, who, along with Charlotte Riley’s less-impressive Cathy, occupies the center of Emily Bronte’s obsessive love quadrangle. Writer Peter Bowker (“Blackpool”) has widened the […]

  • HFPA 75th Annual Golden Globe Awards,

    Allison Janney, Sam Rockwell, More Winners Get Trophies Engraved at First-Ever HFPA Golden Globes Party

    For those understandably enamored of the 1939 Laurence Olivier-Merle Oberon version, this “Masterpiece Classic” retelling of “Wuthering Heights” does offer a few modern compensations, starting with an intense Tom Hardy as Heathcliff, who, along with Charlotte Riley’s less-impressive Cathy, occupies the center of Emily Bronte’s obsessive love quadrangle. Writer Peter Bowker (“Blackpool”) has widened the […]

  • Damian Lewis and Malin AkermanShowtime Golden

    Golden Globe 2018 Pre-Parties: BAFTA Los Angeles Tea, Showtime, ICM and More

    For those understandably enamored of the 1939 Laurence Olivier-Merle Oberon version, this “Masterpiece Classic” retelling of “Wuthering Heights” does offer a few modern compensations, starting with an intense Tom Hardy as Heathcliff, who, along with Charlotte Riley’s less-impressive Cathy, occupies the center of Emily Bronte’s obsessive love quadrangle. Writer Peter Bowker (“Blackpool”) has widened the […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content