Review: ‘The Dancer and the Thief’

A TV feel pervades the grand-style filmmaking of "The Dancer and the Thief."

A TV feel pervades the grand-style filmmaking of “The Dancer and the Thief,” Fernando Trueba’s adaptation, together with son Jonas and author Antonio Skarmeta (“Il Postino”), of Skarmeta’s award-winning novel. Script and sentiment never escape that smallscreen aura, despite the presence of top thesp Ricardo Darin as an ex-con safecracker in Santiago, Chile, worshipped by a golden-tongued young thief in love with a mute ballet dancer. Lush lensing and blandly likable characters should work well with older auds in Spanish-lingo territories, but offshore, arthouse hearts are unlikely to be stolen.

After five years in the slammer, Nico Vergara Grey (Darin) is a reformed thief looking to reconnect with his wife Teresa (Ariadna Gil) and son. Also getting out of jail is Angel (Abel Ayala), a young man just past his teens locked up for “borrowing” a horse. Sleazy warden Santoro (Julio Jung), fearful Angel will want revenge after the warden brutally raped him (not seen), gives killer Marin (Luis Dubo) a week’s leave so he can murder the young man.

Nico’s wife wants nothing to do with him, while Angel pesters Nico to collaborate on a heist that will net them a hefty chunk of change left over from the days of the Pinochet dictatorship. Meanwhile, Angel has fallen in love with Victoria (Miranda Bodenhofer), a mute orphan with self-destructive tendencies, whose parents were killed during the junta.

Trueba’s long-anticipated return to feature films (after a nine-year hiatus making music docus) overplays Dickensian elements while undercutting expected tension: Curiously for a film with a safecracking protag, the climactic caper lacks tension and doesn’t even show Nico at the safe. Victoria, a dancing gamine whose artfully smudged face is just one of the film’s many prettified elements, is pure fairy tale: The script milks the trauma of her parents’ “disappearance,” but the weak predictability of it all feels cynically calculated to provoke tears.

Much of the problem lies in the script, which tidily reduces people to caricatures (the ballet-school judges in particular are especially flimsy), spouting lines more appropriate to dime-store novels. An inner-voice dialogue between Nico and Teresa, a la “Strange Interlude,” is used once, ineffectually, and then discarded, and the overall cloying sweetness does not sit well with the darker themes, nor the unsubtle homophobia that discolors the whole picture.

Lensing is pretty and slick, featuring warm tones that make everyone and everything attractive. Santiago and the snow-covered mountains near the city are beautifully shot, though neither offers up many distinguishing features.

The Dancer and the Thief



A Notro Films presentation of a Fernando Trueba production, with the participation of TVE. (International sales: 6 Sales, Madrid.) Produced by Jessica Huppert Berman. Executive producer, Cristina Huete. Directed by Fernando Trueba. Screenplay, Fernando Trueba, Jonas Trueba, Antonio Skarmeta, based on the novel by Skarmeta.


Camera (color/B&W, widescreen), Julian Ledesma; editor, Carmen Frias; production designer, Veronica Astudillo; costume designer, Lala Huete; sound (Dolby Digital), Pierre Gamet, Pelayo Gutierrez, Ignacio Royo; associate producer, Andres Mardones. Reviewed at San Sebastian Film Festival (noncompeting), Sept. 18, 2009. Running time: 126 MIN.


Ricardo Darin, Abel Ayala, Miranda Bodenhofer, Ariadna Gil, Luis Dubo, Mario Guerra, Julio Jung, Mariana Loyola, Marcia Haydee, Gloria Munchmeyer, Gregory Cohen, Ernesto Malibran, Catalina Guerra, Catalina Saavedra, Sergio Hernandez, Antonio Skarmeta.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety