Review: ‘The Audition’

A love -- or even tolerance -- of opera proves optional to full enjoyment of "The Audition."

A love — or even tolerance — of opera proves optional to full enjoyment of “The Audition,” Susan Froemke’s absorbing, sumptuously crafted docu about aspiring tenors, baritones and sopranos vying for glory on the stage of the Metropolitan Opera. Although the venue’s competitive nature generates a certain “American Idol”-esque suspense, what resonates more strongly is a sense of shared purpose and passion. Playing nationwide in 400 theaters April 19 (prior to a summer DVD release and fall PBS airing), the docu adds an accessible strain to the highly successful “The Met: Live on HD” theatrical lineup.

Veteran helmer Froemke uses the semifinals of the National Council Auditions, involving 22 professional singers from across the country, to introduce several main players, lay out the Met’s imposing topography (later exploited more dramatically) and stress the competitive aspect of the proceedings, subsequently muted in collaborative efforts. Pic later focuses on the 11 finalists (from which five or six winners will be chosen): They are instantly welcomed into the fold, the Met’s vast resources deployed to accommodate, polish and refine their talents.

Ultimately, the intense weeklong preparations by voice, breath and dramatic coaches — and by pixieish orchestra conductor Marco Armiliato, the smiling antithesis of the temperamental maestro — are ministered with so much supportive, flattering attention that every finalist emerges stronger.

The looming musical showdown sharpens the contestants’ consciousness of their weak points: Three zaftig chanteuses fear their expansive physiques might weigh against the current preference for sexier divas, while petite soprano Kiera Duffy frets about prejudice against lesser lung power. Tenor Alek Shrader’s choice of “A mes amis” brings a new dimension to the table, as the aria’s notorious nine high Cs make it evident that difficulty will count. But to Shader, the chance to sing an aria he once only dreamt of mastering seems prize enough.

Froemke deftly maintains a dynamic balance, following the throughline of a particular artist’s development while keeping track of several singers at once without losing clarity or depth. This complex interweaving of individual and collective strands grants the docu a rare richness that climaxes spectacularly.

By the time the big night arrives and each singer must perform in front of a packed house, the viewer is intimately acquainted with the strengths and weaknesses of most of the participants, having heard snatches of their selections at various phases of mastery. The docu’s finale is a triumph for Froemke and editor Kathleen Dougherty, as the long, winding backstage corridors are transformed into labyrinths of the mind. The performances are intercut with glimpses of satin-clad figures caught gesturing behind still-undrawn curtains or tragically scurrying off through blackness after a disastrous turn, anxiously waiting in the wings or suddenly exiting after their 10 minutes in the limelight.

The Audition


A Metropolitan Opera/NCM Fathom release of a Freyda B. Lindemann presentation of a Susan Foremke production. Produced by Froemke, Douglas Graves. Executive producer, Peter Gelb. Directed by Susan Froemke.


Camera (color, HD), Don Lenzer, Buddy Squires; editor, Kathleen Dougherty; music producer, Jay David Saks; sound, Roger Phenix. Reviewed on DVD, New York, April 7, 2009. Running time: 109 MIN.


Jamie Barton, Kiera Duffy, Michael Fabiano, Disella Larusdottir, Ryan McKinny, Angela Meade, Nicholas Pallesen, Matthew Plenk, Alek Shrader, Ryan Smith, Amber Wagner, Marco Armiliato, Renee Fleming.
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety