Review: ‘Sandstorm’

When righteous indignation comes in the door, drama often jumps out the window.

When righteous indignation comes in the door, drama often jumps out the window, and “Sandstorm” — a well-intended, awkwardly executed parable about China’s crackdown on the spiritual movement Falun Gong — is airborne from the outset. Admittedly, followers of Falun Gong will revel in the vicarious vengeance wrought against Beijing via bad-karma-fueled weather, and with a membership estimated between 70 million and 100 million people, that’s quite a fan base. Finding a crossover aud, however, will be no day at the beach for the pic, which opens Sept. 4, more than five years after first hitting the fest circuit.

The conceit: The brutal treatment of Falun Gong, as perpetrated by former president Ziang Jemin, has brought China a sandstorm that has buried much of the landscape, cut off power and immobilized the population (“special effects” are limited to static shots of sand-strewn streets). An equally critical storm is happening within the psyches of the principals, specifically Hetian Ying (Rong Tian), a midlevel police official who’s assigned to torture “confessions” out of Falun Gong subscribers, and who’s tortured himself by the cruelty and unfairness of his job.

Ying and his wife (Zeng Ziyu) are living by candlelight, burning the furniture for fuel, wracked by the disappearance of their young daughter (Annie Li), who had been waiting at school for her father when the sandstorm struck. Mom, who has done her share of Falun Gong-bashing, is a mess; Dad is trying to hold things together and revisit the events that have led to this cosmic payback. His recollections include the brutal interrogation (it’s actually pretty tame) of a schoolteacher whose adherence to the Falun Gong principles of “truthfulness, compassion and forbearance” shame all those around her, including a young policewoman (Angela Huang) who acts as our stand-in.

“Sandstorm” is prefaced by titles that explain how, throughout history, mankind has had to pay the price for its shortsightedness and inhumanity through natural and man-made disasters that have come as a direct result of bad behavior. It’s a premise that sets up the movie, of course, but leaves one wondering about all the acts of human stupidity that weren’t followed by earthquakes, floods, planetary collisions or, yes, sandstorms. The viewer could make the leap, one supposes, if anything else in the film were convincing, but helmer Michael Mahonen seems too intent on creating a heartfelt pro-Falun Gong message than in converting the skeptical — or anyone looking for plausible storytelling.

The pic was reportedly produced for less than $5,000, and it looks it. Great drama can, of course, be fashioned with no production values whatsoever, but this requires the kind of direction and acting not to be found within the maelstrom of “Sandstorm.” (Lead actor Rong came on at the last minute and should probably be forgiven.) Mahonen’s movie is preaching to the choir, and even they might have a problem.




A Requisite Films release of an NTD Films/Requisite Films production. Produced by Rebecca Boudreau, Michael Mahonen. Executive producer, Joe Wang. Directed, written by Michael Mahonen.


Camera (color), David Chai; editors, Danielle Zhu, David Chai, Corban Hu; music, Carlos Campos, Susan Liu; production coordinator, Peijong Hsieh; set decorators, Manna Hu, David Tompkins; costume designer, Ni MIngda; sound, Corban Hu; sound editors, Corban Hu, Chai; visual effects, Kalle Scoten, Lilian Staf, Jaya Gibson; special effects, Chai, Corban Hu, Gibson; first assistant director, Zhu; casting, Mahonen. Reviewed on DVD, New York, Aug. 14, 2009. Running time: 75 MIN.


Rong Tian, Lili Li, Angela Huang, Steve Hong, Zeng Ziyu, Annie Li. (Mandarin dialogue)
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety