'El General'

Documentary on Mexican Gen.-president Plutarco Elias Calles is almost dreamlike in its structure.

Any documentarian could do a straightforward history of Mexican Gen.-turned-president Plutarco Elias Calles, but when the man’s great-granddaughter, Natalia Almada, decides to examine her controversial ancestor, she personalizes it. That means rejecting biographical research in favor of weaving together charged artifacts: newsreel and old-movie footage, a taped interview with her grandmother (Calles’ daughter) and stolen glimpses of contemporary Mexican culture. Her assembled reflections, tied together through elliptical wisps of narration, offer a meditative portrait less of Calles himself than the amorphous and often contradictory nature of history and memory — an exercise better suited for fests than public exhibition.

Incubated with the help of the Sundance Institute, “El General” feels deliberately experimental, almost dreamlike in its structure. For non-Mexican auds, Almada’s observations of present-day street vendors will prove most compelling, offering glimpses of “the people” that Calles and his comrades in the Mexican Revolution aimed to liberate, still disempowered several generations on. But few will be surprised the filmmaker’s grandmother’s fond impressions of Calles don’t match the facts (including Calles’ ordered execution of clergy and the pressures he exerted over successors). Somber music and heavy subtitling make pic a tricky sit.

El General



An Altamura Films/Independent Television Service production in association with Latino Public Broadcasting, with funding provided by the Corp. for Public Broadcasting and American Documentary/P.O.V. Produced by Daniela Alatorre, Natalia Almada. Directed, edited by Natalia Almada.


Camera (color DV), Chuy Chavez; music, John Zorn, Marc Ribot. Reviewed at Sundance Film Festival (competing), Jan. 18, 2009. Spanish dialogue. Running time: 83 MIN.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0