You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Senate fails to approve shield bill

Panel can't agree on protection for journalists

WASHINGTON — The Senate Judiciary Committee Thursday failed to approve a bill that would establish a federal shield law to protect journalists from certain suits requiring them to reveal news sources. Bowing to opposition from the panel’s Republican members, Chairman Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) decided to postpone markup of the measure to a later date.

Republican opponents including Sen. Jon Kyl (R-Ariz.) said they objected to current language balancing protection for journalists and national security concerns. He said his objections to the measure have not been satisfied by a recent compromise among Democrats and news organizations. Kyl planned to offer numerous amendments that would require protracted debate by the committee.

Journalism orgs including the Radio Television Digital News Assn. had been optimistic that the Judiciary Committee would approve the federal shield bill on its 16th attempt. RTDNA chairman Stacey Woelfel said that while he was disappointed the committee did not vote to pass the bill Thursday, “my hope is that senators can regroup to bring a strong version of the bill back for consideration as soon as possible.”

Woelfel said the continued attempts by opponents to allow the government to override the current law would make it “a paper shield at best.”

The recent compromise OK’d by the White House would offer protection for professional journalists, freelancers, student journalists and bloggers engaged in journalism.

More Scene

  • Chanel x Tribeca Film Festival Women's

    Chanel's Tribeca Film Fest Luncheon Toasts to Women's Movements in Industry

    WASHINGTON — The Senate Judiciary Committee Thursday failed to approve a bill that would establish a federal shield law to protect journalists from certain suits requiring them to reveal news sources. Bowing to opposition from the panel’s Republican members, Chairman Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) decided to postpone markup of the measure to a later date. Republican […]

  • Doug Davis Power of Law

    Doug Davis Discusses Using Music for a Cause at Variety's Power of Law Event

    WASHINGTON — The Senate Judiciary Committee Thursday failed to approve a bill that would establish a federal shield law to protect journalists from certain suits requiring them to reveal news sources. Bowing to opposition from the panel’s Republican members, Chairman Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) decided to postpone markup of the measure to a later date. Republican […]

  • Ken Ziffren and Claudia EllerVariety Power

    Attorney Ken Ziffren Offers Sobering Take on Film Business at Variety's Power of Law Breakfast

    WASHINGTON — The Senate Judiciary Committee Thursday failed to approve a bill that would establish a federal shield law to protect journalists from certain suits requiring them to reveal news sources. Bowing to opposition from the panel’s Republican members, Chairman Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) decided to postpone markup of the measure to a later date. Republican […]

  • 'The Handmaid's Tale'

    'The Handmaid's Tale' Cast, Creator Talk Season 2 in #MeToo Era, Expanding Gilead

    WASHINGTON — The Senate Judiciary Committee Thursday failed to approve a bill that would establish a federal shield law to protect journalists from certain suits requiring them to reveal news sources. Bowing to opposition from the panel’s Republican members, Chairman Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) decided to postpone markup of the measure to a later date. Republican […]

  • Pamela Adlon Better Things

    Pamela Adlon: When 'Better Things' 'Stops Being Relatable Is When I Stop Doing My Show'

    WASHINGTON — The Senate Judiciary Committee Thursday failed to approve a bill that would establish a federal shield law to protect journalists from certain suits requiring them to reveal news sources. Bowing to opposition from the panel’s Republican members, Chairman Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) decided to postpone markup of the measure to a later date. Republican […]

  • The Future She Built

    Inventor of the Inclusion Rider Discusses Why the Initiative Is Necessary at Panel

    WASHINGTON — The Senate Judiciary Committee Thursday failed to approve a bill that would establish a federal shield law to protect journalists from certain suits requiring them to reveal news sources. Bowing to opposition from the panel’s Republican members, Chairman Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) decided to postpone markup of the measure to a later date. Republican […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content