TWC loses its ‘Precious’ suit

Oral deal discarded by federal judge

Nothing is more precious in dealmaking than a signed contract, says a federal judge.

And a signed contract is just what Weinstein Co. doesn’t have in its claim of distribution rights to Lee Daniels’ “Precious: Based on the Novel ‘Push’ by Sapphire,” which Lionsgate is slated to release Nov. 6.

In February, two days after Lionsgate announced its purchase of the film, the Weinstein Co. filed a lawsuit against “Precious” producer Smokewood Prods., claiming that TWC had already made a deal for the title.

On Friday, U.S. District Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald for the Southern District of New York disagreed, dismissing one of four lawsuits the Weinstein Co. has filed in connection with the film.

In a memorandum to dismiss the Weinstein Co. suit, Smokewood attorney Steven Hayes pointed out that TWC did not have a signed contract for a “Precious” deal and, as such, could have no claim on the film. Furthermore, he pointed out that Weinstein used the same argument to wrest “Project Runway” from Bravo to Lifetime.

Judge Buchwald’s judgment agreed with his opinion, pointing out that under the Copyright Act, the transfer of distribution rights demands “a signed writing from the copyright owner or its agent.”

Buchwald wrote: “Notably, the complaint does not allege a written, legally binding agreement for the licensing and distribution rights to ‘Push.’ Rather, the complaint alleges that there were negotiations between Jan. 24, 2009, and Jan. 27, 2009, resulting in an agreement that was never finalized in writing.”

“Precious,” then titled “Push: Based on a Novel by Sapphire,” premiered at this year’s Sundance Film Festival, where it was represented by John Sloss and Bart Walker at Cinetic Media. Weinstein Co. claims that the Cinetic reps made a deal for the film and then reneged when Lionsgate entered the picture.

At the time, Weinstein Co. attorney Bert Fields described the companies’ pact on the film as “a firm agreement…Lionsgate was well aware of the TWC contract but went forward anyway” (Daily Variety, Feb. 6).

More Film

  • China Box Office: 'Solo' Opens Third

    China Box Office: 'Solo' Opens Third Behind 'How Long' and 'Avengers'

    Nothing is more precious in dealmaking than a signed contract, says a federal judge. And a signed contract is just what Weinstein Co. doesn’t have in its claim of distribution rights to Lee Daniels’ “Precious: Based on the Novel ‘Push’ by Sapphire,” which Lionsgate is slated to release Nov. 6. In February, two days after […]

  • Solo A Star Wars Story

    'Solo: A Star Wars Story' Stumbles Overseas With $65 Million Launch

    Nothing is more precious in dealmaking than a signed contract, says a federal judge. And a signed contract is just what Weinstein Co. doesn’t have in its claim of distribution rights to Lee Daniels’ “Precious: Based on the Novel ‘Push’ by Sapphire,” which Lionsgate is slated to release Nov. 6. In February, two days after […]

  • 'Solo': What That Surprise Cameo Means

    'Solo': What a 'Character Too Secret to Ever Name' Means for the 'Star Wars' Spinoff

    Nothing is more precious in dealmaking than a signed contract, says a federal judge. And a signed contract is just what Weinstein Co. doesn’t have in its claim of distribution rights to Lee Daniels’ “Precious: Based on the Novel ‘Push’ by Sapphire,” which Lionsgate is slated to release Nov. 6. In February, two days after […]

  • Rebel Wilson and Taye Diggs

    Concert Review: 'Beauty and the Beast' Gets Adoring Tribute at Hollywood Bowl

    Nothing is more precious in dealmaking than a signed contract, says a federal judge. And a signed contract is just what Weinstein Co. doesn’t have in its claim of distribution rights to Lee Daniels’ “Precious: Based on the Novel ‘Push’ by Sapphire,” which Lionsgate is slated to release Nov. 6. In February, two days after […]

  • Solo a Star Wars Story Deadpool

    It's Official: Deadpool Is Now Cooler Than Han Solo

    Nothing is more precious in dealmaking than a signed contract, says a federal judge. And a signed contract is just what Weinstein Co. doesn’t have in its claim of distribution rights to Lee Daniels’ “Precious: Based on the Novel ‘Push’ by Sapphire,” which Lionsgate is slated to release Nov. 6. In February, two days after […]

  • solo a star wars story

    Box Office: 'Solo: A Star Wars Story' Headed for Underwhelming Holiday Weekend Debut

    Nothing is more precious in dealmaking than a signed contract, says a federal judge. And a signed contract is just what Weinstein Co. doesn’t have in its claim of distribution rights to Lee Daniels’ “Precious: Based on the Novel ‘Push’ by Sapphire,” which Lionsgate is slated to release Nov. 6. In February, two days after […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content