You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

My Bloody Valentine

The group's Wednesday performance transcended the notion of a mere reunion; devastatingly loud, as expected, but the volume only served to promulgate the dream-like aesthetic My Bloody Valentine mastered on 1988's "Isn't Anything" and their 1991 magnum opus "Loveless." The band largely succeeded in providing a powerful realization of "Loveless." Kevin Shields' and Bilinda Butcher's voices were buried deep in the mix, often to the point of inaudibility; at times the complexity of the material was lost in the murky swell of guitar and drums (most notably on "To Here Knows When"). Standout single "Soon" was a highlight, with its dynamic dance backbeat and emotive A-B-A structure.</b>

Cast:
Band: Bilinda Butcher, Debbie Googe, Colm O Ciosoig, Kevin Shields. Also appearing: Spectrum.

Band reunions are delicate undertakings. The volatile combination of egos, grudges and expectations often lead to a set of shows that, while nostalgic, only further solidify an aging band’s irrelevance. But My Bloody Valentine was never a “rock band” in the traditional sense of the phrase. The group’s Wednesday performance transcended the notion of a mere reunion; devastatingly loud, as expected, but the volume only served to promulgate the dream-like aesthetic My Bloody Valentine mastered on 1988’s “Isn’t Anything” and their 1991 magnum opus “Loveless.”

The band largely succeeded in providing a powerful realization of “Loveless.” Kevin Shields’ and Bilinda Butcher’s voices were buried deep in the mix, often to the point of inaudibility; at times the complexity of the material was lost in the murky swell of guitar and drums (most notably on “To Here Knows When”). Standout single “Soon” was a highlight, with its dynamic dance backbeat and emotive A-B-A structure.

Songs from the band’s pre-“Loveless” LP, the more punk-based (and criminally overlooked) “Isn’t Anything,” were well suited to the live setting. Whether it was the stop-start madness of “Nothing Much To Lose” or the relentless “(When You Wake) You’re Still In A Dream,” MBV’s performance revealed their strengths in the traditional rock vein.

From the start, Colm O Ciosoig’s drumming was established as the focal point of the performance. His wild, often unsteady technique injected a sense of humanity into a sound that, in its recorded incarnation, is based on texture and nuance rather than emotion.

The show culminated with the 20-minute version of “You Made Me Realise,” which boasts a 15-minute noise freak-out detour known as the “holocaust” section. The sheer amount of sound created during that segment defies simple explanation; it’s an entirely physical experience that forces a unique reaction out of each and every concertgoer.

My Bloody Valentine

Santa Monica Civic Auditorium; 3,500 Capacity; $48 top

Production: Presented by Goldenvoice. Reviewed Oct. 1, 2008.

Cast: Band: Bilinda Butcher, Debbie Googe, Colm O Ciosoig, Kevin Shields. Also appearing: Spectrum.

More Music

  • Justin Timberlake

    It's Official: Justin Timberlake to Headline Super Bowl Halftime

    Band reunions are delicate undertakings. The volatile combination of egos, grudges and expectations often lead to a set of shows that, while nostalgic, only further solidify an aging band’s irrelevance. But My Bloody Valentine was never a “rock band” in the traditional sense of the phrase. The group’s Wednesday performance transcended the notion of a […]

  • Sam SmithCBS RADIO's 'We Can Survive'

    Pink, Lorde, Sam Smith, and Two One Directioners Stand Up to Cancer at Hollywood Bowl

    Band reunions are delicate undertakings. The volatile combination of egos, grudges and expectations often lead to a set of shows that, while nostalgic, only further solidify an aging band’s irrelevance. But My Bloody Valentine was never a “rock band” in the traditional sense of the phrase. The group’s Wednesday performance transcended the notion of a […]

  • Twiggy Ramirez Marilyn Manson Rape

    Twiggy Ramirez, Marilyn Manson Bassist, Accused of Rape

    Band reunions are delicate undertakings. The volatile combination of egos, grudges and expectations often lead to a set of shows that, while nostalgic, only further solidify an aging band’s irrelevance. But My Bloody Valentine was never a “rock band” in the traditional sense of the phrase. The group’s Wednesday performance transcended the notion of a […]

  • Foo Fighters Show Canceled Dave Grohl

    Foo Fighters Postpone Three Tour Dates Due to Family Emergency

    Band reunions are delicate undertakings. The volatile combination of egos, grudges and expectations often lead to a set of shows that, while nostalgic, only further solidify an aging band’s irrelevance. But My Bloody Valentine was never a “rock band” in the traditional sense of the phrase. The group’s Wednesday performance transcended the notion of a […]

  • Gibson Les Paul Traditional 2008 Standard

    Gibson Guitars Vacating Memphis Factory for Smaller Plant

    Band reunions are delicate undertakings. The volatile combination of egos, grudges and expectations often lead to a set of shows that, while nostalgic, only further solidify an aging band’s irrelevance. But My Bloody Valentine was never a “rock band” in the traditional sense of the phrase. The group’s Wednesday performance transcended the notion of a […]

  • Pink

    The Philadelphia Experiment: How Pink and Collaborator Billy Mann Forged a 15-Year Friendship

    Band reunions are delicate undertakings. The volatile combination of egos, grudges and expectations often lead to a set of shows that, while nostalgic, only further solidify an aging band’s irrelevance. But My Bloody Valentine was never a “rock band” in the traditional sense of the phrase. The group’s Wednesday performance transcended the notion of a […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content