You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Carrie Underwood

Carrie Underwood is reaching something entirely different than her route to fame in 2005 as an "American Idol"-winning country girl. Her concert at the Nokia Theater wasn't always successful, but one has to admire the attempt.

With:
Band: Carrie Underwood, Mark Childers, Ed Eason, Jamie Fraley, Garrett Goodwin, Jonathan Hamby, Jimmy Herman, Chad Jeffers, Shawn Tubbs.
Also appearing: Little Big Town.

Carrie Underwood is reaching something entirely different than her route to fame in 2005 as an “American Idol”-winning country girl. Her concert at the Nokia Theater wasn’t always successful, but one has to admire the attempt.

The muddled 90-minute show feels like three performers shoehorned into one — the down-home singer who still remembers when her hometown of Checotah, Okla., had only one stop light; the uplifting, big voiced country balladeer; and the sassy gal who just wants to rock.

She can soar like Martina McBride on the redemptive “Jesus Take The Wheel,” but when she stands on top of a rising platform and pummels her way through the bathetic climax of “I Know You Won’t,” she turns into a south of the Mason-Dixon Line Celine Dion. She high-steps it as a honky tonk Cinderella looking for her prince on “The Boys I Meet,” but the more aggressive, country-fried metal of “Flat on the Floor” comes off as forced.

Underwood appears most comfortable singing the Broadway-inflected country of “Some Hearts,” but that side of her personality was given short shift; the show’s most sustained country sequence was a video montage (shown to fill a costume change) of her being asked to join the Grand Ole Opry, shots of magazine covers and clips from various awards shows, focusing, not un-coincidently, on the Country Music Awards, which she will be co-hosting with Brad Paisley on Wednesday.

No matter what style she’s assaying, the staging and often the arrangements, looked to the classic rock of the late ’70s and early ’80s for inspiration. The two-tiered stage comes equipped with lasers and hydraulics, and while her band is accessorized with fiddles, dobros and pedal steel guitar, when it’s time for the band to stretch out, they take on the Who’s “Won’t Get Fooled Again” (which leads into the crunchy hedonism of “Last Name,” where a good girl looking for some excitement ends up married in Vegas). But even this meets with mixed results.

A cover of Fleetwood Mac’s “Go Your Own Way” — in the vernacular of Idol is “pitchy” and “shouty” — is saved by opening act Little Big Town, an attractive, well scrubbed quartet whose plush harmonies are far superior to their often tepid material. In the encore, she gets a chance to howl away on Guns ‘N’ Roses “Paradise City.”

Carrie Underwood

Nokia Theater; 7,100 seats; $57.50 top

Production: Presented by AEG Live. Reviewed Nov. 5, 2008.

Cast: Band: Carrie Underwood, Mark Childers, Ed Eason, Jamie Fraley, Garrett Goodwin, Jonathan Hamby, Jimmy Herman, Chad Jeffers, Shawn Tubbs.
Also appearing: Little Big Town.

More Scene

  • Beautycon Festival

    Laverne Cox, Paris Hilton Promote Self-Love at Beautycon NYC

    Carrie Underwood is reaching something entirely different than her route to fame in 2005 as an “American Idol”-winning country girl. Her concert at the Nokia Theater wasn’t always successful, but one has to admire the attempt. The muddled 90-minute show feels like three performers shoehorned into one — the down-home singer who still remembers when […]

  • Duke and Duchess of Cambridge

    The Duchess of Cambridge Gives Birth to Baby Boy

    Carrie Underwood is reaching something entirely different than her route to fame in 2005 as an “American Idol”-winning country girl. Her concert at the Nokia Theater wasn’t always successful, but one has to admire the attempt. The muddled 90-minute show feels like three performers shoehorned into one — the down-home singer who still remembers when […]

  • J.K. Rowling on the Future of

    J.K. Rowling on the Future of Harry Potter Stories on Stage

    Carrie Underwood is reaching something entirely different than her route to fame in 2005 as an “American Idol”-winning country girl. Her concert at the Nokia Theater wasn’t always successful, but one has to admire the attempt. The muddled 90-minute show feels like three performers shoehorned into one — the down-home singer who still remembers when […]

  • Chanel x Tribeca Film Festival Women's

    Chanel's Tribeca Film Fest Luncheon Toasts to Women's Movements in Industry

    Carrie Underwood is reaching something entirely different than her route to fame in 2005 as an “American Idol”-winning country girl. Her concert at the Nokia Theater wasn’t always successful, but one has to admire the attempt. The muddled 90-minute show feels like three performers shoehorned into one — the down-home singer who still remembers when […]

  • Doug Davis Power of Law

    Doug Davis Discusses Using Music for a Cause at Variety's Power of Law Event

    Carrie Underwood is reaching something entirely different than her route to fame in 2005 as an “American Idol”-winning country girl. Her concert at the Nokia Theater wasn’t always successful, but one has to admire the attempt. The muddled 90-minute show feels like three performers shoehorned into one — the down-home singer who still remembers when […]

  • 'The Handmaid's Tale'

    'The Handmaid's Tale' Cast, Creator Talk Season 2 in #MeToo Era, Expanding Gilead

    Carrie Underwood is reaching something entirely different than her route to fame in 2005 as an “American Idol”-winning country girl. Her concert at the Nokia Theater wasn’t always successful, but one has to admire the attempt. The muddled 90-minute show feels like three performers shoehorned into one — the down-home singer who still remembers when […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content