You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Crime

With previous works titled "Filth," and "Porno," Irvine Welsh is one of the originals of transgressive fiction, not unlike a Scottish Chuck Palahniuk or Bret Easton Ellis. His newest novel, "Crime," doesn't deviate from that milieu, for in the past it has served him well. It's just that this time the shtick seems tiresome.

With previous works titled “Filth,” and “Porno,” Irvine Welsh is one of the originals of transgressive fiction, not unlike a Scottish Chuck Palahniuk or Bret Easton Ellis.

His newest novel, “Crime,” doesn’t deviate from that milieu, for in the past it has served him well. It’s just that this time the shtick seems tiresome.

“Crime” follows Edinburgh Det. Ray Lennox, a recurring character who made his first appearance in “Filth.” In this installment, Lennox is on leave for a mental break; a forced hiatus from work disguised as a vacation in Miami. The getaway comes in the wake of a child rape-murder investigation that has struck Lennox with a serious bout of post-traumatic stress disorder. Instead of finding quiet and respite in Miami, the detective — who himself has a history of addiction and fits of violence — embarks on the dangerous, perhaps futile mission of rescuing a young American girl from a ring of pedophiles.

Welsh’s fans won’t be surprised to find explicit passages of drug use, deviant sex and tortured inner monologue in “Crime.” He used similar devices in the much-appreciated “Trainspotting” and made those passages terrifyingly elegant. While “Crime” contains sections of the same poignance, it’s used to too little effect. Readers get mired in a plot that reads more like a script from “CSI” than a serious piece of crime fiction. If Lennox can be construed as a contemporary Philip Marlowe, he has all of the same pathos but none of the style.

Put simply, there’s not enough edge in “Crime.” Still, as a writer who often gives his characters significant, if grim complexities, Welsh does scrutinize certain relevant topics in his oblique way here.

The author’s grotesque portrait of Miami is a fitting exaggeration, and in it, Lennox is a fascinated outsider. Seeking out booze, drugs and sex in the seedy underbelly of the city, he’s a mortal given to monstrous proclivities. In him, readers are told that even the good sometimes falter.

More broadly, Lennox’s bender is a reminder that moral turpitude spans continents, cultures and infects even our leaders and agents of law enforcement. Though the detective looks to exonerate himself, Welsh is capturing the deterioration of a society.

Unfortunately, however prescient Welsh may be with observing contemporary dystopia, it’s not new for him. If optioned to the bigscreen, there’s certainly enough action to make an exciting film out of “Crime.” Yet, as the newest piece of fiction from a great author, it falls short.

More Reviews

  • 'Same Kind of Different as Me'

    Film Review: 'Same Kind of Different as Me'

    With previous works titled “Filth,” and “Porno,” Irvine Welsh is one of the originals of transgressive fiction, not unlike a Scottish Chuck Palahniuk or Bret Easton Ellis. His newest novel, “Crime,” doesn’t deviate from that milieu, for in the past it has served him well. It’s just that this time the shtick seems tiresome. “Crime” […]

  • Progression Image 3 of 3: Final

    Film Review: Pixar's 'Coco'

    With previous works titled “Filth,” and “Porno,” Irvine Welsh is one of the originals of transgressive fiction, not unlike a Scottish Chuck Palahniuk or Bret Easton Ellis. His newest novel, “Crime,” doesn’t deviate from that milieu, for in the past it has served him well. It’s just that this time the shtick seems tiresome. “Crime” […]

  • Margo Price

    Album Review: Margo Price's 'All American Made'

    With previous works titled “Filth,” and “Porno,” Irvine Welsh is one of the originals of transgressive fiction, not unlike a Scottish Chuck Palahniuk or Bret Easton Ellis. His newest novel, “Crime,” doesn’t deviate from that milieu, for in the past it has served him well. It’s just that this time the shtick seems tiresome. “Crime” […]

  • Concert Review: Haim Light Up L.A.'s

    Concert Review: Haim Light Up L.A.'s Greek Theatre With Homecoming Show

    With previous works titled “Filth,” and “Porno,” Irvine Welsh is one of the originals of transgressive fiction, not unlike a Scottish Chuck Palahniuk or Bret Easton Ellis. His newest novel, “Crime,” doesn’t deviate from that milieu, for in the past it has served him well. It’s just that this time the shtick seems tiresome. “Crime” […]

  • Geostorm

    Film Review: 'Geostorm'

    With previous works titled “Filth,” and “Porno,” Irvine Welsh is one of the originals of transgressive fiction, not unlike a Scottish Chuck Palahniuk or Bret Easton Ellis. His newest novel, “Crime,” doesn’t deviate from that milieu, for in the past it has served him well. It’s just that this time the shtick seems tiresome. “Crime” […]

  • Taylor Swift Reputation

    Song Review: Taylor Swift's 'Gorgeous'

    With previous works titled “Filth,” and “Porno,” Irvine Welsh is one of the originals of transgressive fiction, not unlike a Scottish Chuck Palahniuk or Bret Easton Ellis. His newest novel, “Crime,” doesn’t deviate from that milieu, for in the past it has served him well. It’s just that this time the shtick seems tiresome. “Crime” […]

  • Torch Song review

    Off Broadway Review: Harvey Fierstein's 'Torch Song' With Michael Urie

    With previous works titled “Filth,” and “Porno,” Irvine Welsh is one of the originals of transgressive fiction, not unlike a Scottish Chuck Palahniuk or Bret Easton Ellis. His newest novel, “Crime,” doesn’t deviate from that milieu, for in the past it has served him well. It’s just that this time the shtick seems tiresome. “Crime” […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content