You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Marie Antoinette: The Color of Flesh

Joel Gross' windy three-character period drama has the benefit of one wonderful performance and one very good one, but no three actors in the world can sustain this deeply serious bodice-ripper's entertainment value for more than 90 minutes.

With:
Elisabeth Louise Vigee le Brun - Samantha Ives Marie Antoinette - Amanda Jones Count Alexis de Ligne - Jonathan Kells Phillips Footman - Hugo Salazar Jr.

Off with its second act! Joel Gross’ windy three-character period drama (four, if you count Hugo Salazar Jr. as the wordless, increasingly annoyed footman) has the benefit of one wonderful performance and one very good one, but no three actors in the world can sustain this deeply serious bodice-ripper’s entertainment value for more than 90 minutes. “Marie Antoinette: The Color of Flesh” returns to the Gotham stage after a well-reviewed first run last year, but it still needs the help of a dramaturg who’s not afraid to employ the guillotine.

It all starts off so well, much like the monarchy: Samantha Ives plays the lavishly named Elisabeth Louise Vigee le Brun, a painter of lowly birth who has bitten and scratched her way up the social ladder. Now she’s almost at the top: The aristocracy employ her to indulge them with flattering portraiture and then recommend her to their friends.

Ives does her femme fatale thing quite well, with Jonathan Kells Phillips a little less acute as her leering suitor, Count Alexis de Ligne.

Elisabeth beds the Count to get to his friends and, by extension, their friends — a straight line of connections and bedfellows that leads directly to the ultimate paintee: Marie Antoinette (Amanda Jones).

The play’s success hinges on the chemistry between Ives and Phillips, and they don’t quite pull it off: Phillips appears a little uncomfortable (this may have something to do with T. Michael Hall’s unflattering costumes), which behooves neither his character’s status nor his rep as a ladykiller.

The more successful romance is the platonic mutual seduction between Elisabeth and Marie in the confines of Kevin Judge’s palace sets, which manage to be both minimal and lavish. Jones plays Marie with a wonderful and frightening woman-child innocence; it’s a difficult role to make both probable and sympathetic — the character was basically a spoiled rich kid, after all — but Jones pulls it off, cooing her lines and occasionally trying for a grandeur that Marie can’t quite manage. She’s an adorable failure in Jones’ hands, and it makes large sections of the play worth the running time.

Large sections, but not all of it. Ultimately, this is a story with one too many subplots, and it’s hard to blame all of the Count’s failings on Phillips: Gross wants de Ligne to be a heroic rake straight out of a Harlequin Romance, and he doesn’t quite fit in with the mature and complex Elisabeth and Marie.

It’s an interesting story, but the oppressive length and the clumsiness of the de Ligne character should leave it to the mercies of the National Razor.

Marie Antoinette: The Color of Flesh

St. Luke's Theater; 175 seats; $56.50 top

Production: An Earl Prods. presentation of a play in two acts by Joel Gross. Directed by Robert Kalfin.

Creative: Sets, Kevin Judge; costumes, T. Michael Hall; lighting, Paul Hudson; sound, Marek Royce Press; production stage manager, D.C. Rosenberg. Opened July 10, 2008. Reviewed July 19. Running time: 2 HOURS, 20 MIN.

Cast: Elisabeth Louise Vigee le Brun - Samantha Ives Marie Antoinette - Amanda Jones Count Alexis de Ligne - Jonathan Kells Phillips Footman - Hugo Salazar Jr.

More Legit

  • Saint Joan review

    Broadway Review: 'Saint Joan' Starring Condola Rashad

    Off with its second act! Joel Gross’ windy three-character period drama (four, if you count Hugo Salazar Jr. as the wordless, increasingly annoyed footman) has the benefit of one wonderful performance and one very good one, but no three actors in the world can sustain this deeply serious bodice-ripper’s entertainment value for more than 90 […]

  • Branded Game Events, Escape Rooms Scale

    Immersive, Branded Game Content Scales Up With New Merger

    Off with its second act! Joel Gross’ windy three-character period drama (four, if you count Hugo Salazar Jr. as the wordless, increasingly annoyed footman) has the benefit of one wonderful performance and one very good one, but no three actors in the world can sustain this deeply serious bodice-ripper’s entertainment value for more than 90 […]

  • Tom Hollander

    Broadway Review: 'Travesties' Starring Tom Hollander

    Off with its second act! Joel Gross’ windy three-character period drama (four, if you count Hugo Salazar Jr. as the wordless, increasingly annoyed footman) has the benefit of one wonderful performance and one very good one, but no three actors in the world can sustain this deeply serious bodice-ripper’s entertainment value for more than 90 […]

  • Tony Awards 2018: Nick Scandalios to

    Tony Awards 2018: Nick Scandalios to Receive Isabelle Stevenson Award

    Off with its second act! Joel Gross’ windy three-character period drama (four, if you count Hugo Salazar Jr. as the wordless, increasingly annoyed footman) has the benefit of one wonderful performance and one very good one, but no three actors in the world can sustain this deeply serious bodice-ripper’s entertainment value for more than 90 […]

  • Chris Evans

    Chris Evans Talks 'Infinity War,' Broadway and His Future With Captain America

    Off with its second act! Joel Gross’ windy three-character period drama (four, if you count Hugo Salazar Jr. as the wordless, increasingly annoyed footman) has the benefit of one wonderful performance and one very good one, but no three actors in the world can sustain this deeply serious bodice-ripper’s entertainment value for more than 90 […]

  • Summer musical review

    Broadway Review: 'Summer,' The Donna Summer Musical

    Off with its second act! Joel Gross’ windy three-character period drama (four, if you count Hugo Salazar Jr. as the wordless, increasingly annoyed footman) has the benefit of one wonderful performance and one very good one, but no three actors in the world can sustain this deeply serious bodice-ripper’s entertainment value for more than 90 […]

  • Duncan Sheik, Steven Sater, Jason Robert

    Duncan Sheik, Steven Sater, Jason Robert Brown Set for 2018 Powerhouse Season

    Off with its second act! Joel Gross’ windy three-character period drama (four, if you count Hugo Salazar Jr. as the wordless, increasingly annoyed footman) has the benefit of one wonderful performance and one very good one, but no three actors in the world can sustain this deeply serious bodice-ripper’s entertainment value for more than 90 […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content