And All for Love

Alison Lawrence's carefully researched look at the first two women to appear on the English stage.

With:
Winifred Gosnell - Kelly McIntosh Elizabeth Barry - Helen Taylor Samuel Pepys, Edward Kynaston, John Wilmott, Thomas Otway - Michael Spencer-Davis

 A delightful verse prologue, Restoration-style, sets the scene for “And All for Love,” Alison Lawrence’s carefully researched look at the first two women to appear on the English stage. The world premiere focuses on the progression from mentoring to friendship, rivalry and destruction between the actresses, Winifred Gosnell and Elizabeth Barry, while commenting on the changing stage conventions and acting styles of their times.

 Until King Charles II called for women to replace boy thesps, young men had played all the female roles in English theater. In addition, up to the early 20th century, acting was much more declamatory and artificial. So, when Gosnell (Kelly McIntosh), some 200 years before her time, appears on stage and attempts a more naturalistic presentation, she falls by the wayside. This gives the ambitious Barry (Helen Taylor) the chance to brush her aside and become a star.

Lawrence draws a clear picture of the well-documented life of Barry as the ruthless diva who clawed her way to the top. Historical material about Gosnell is much more sparse.

A niece of the famous diarist Samuel Pepys (one of four roles brilliantly played by Michael Spencer-Davis), she is mentioned in his diaries as the maid who ran off to be an actress and was, at first, the more successful of the two women. Then she fades from view, apparently overshadowed by her rival.

The portrait of the catfight between the two is well done, but the play’s ending feels contrived and unrealistic, screaming for a rewrite. The episodic structure — a series of snapshots of the two careers on and off the stage –could also benefit from some rearrangement.

However, Spencer-Davis’ well-contrasted characterizations of various male roles do their part to keep audiences riveted.

Lawrence changes her style to fit various moments in the play, from the iambic pentameter of the prologue to the melodrama of the conclusion, while Eo Sharp’s set design provides workable areas for the play within the play, despite the cramped inner stage. Daryl Cloran’s direction is true to the spirit of the script, although neither the writing nor format involve the audience emotionally. The sense of distance from the characters appears to be the result of trying to thread the two actresses’ conflict too didactically into the theatrical history that brought them together.

Perhaps best considered as a work in progress, “And All for Love” provides an interesting but not totally involving evening of theater.

And All for Love

National Arts Center Studio Theater, Ottawa, Canada; 300 seats; C$35 $34.50 top

Production: An NAC English Theater presentation of a play in one act by Alison Lawrence. Directed by Daryl Cloran.

Creative: Sets and costumes, Eo Sharp; lighting, Tim Fort; original music and sound, Kevin Tighe. Opened, reviewed April 24, 2008. Running time: 1 HOUR, 30 MIN.

Cast: Winifred Gosnell - Kelly McIntosh Elizabeth Barry - Helen Taylor Samuel Pepys, Edward Kynaston, John Wilmott, Thomas Otway - Michael Spencer-Davis

More Legit

  • Eric McCormack First Time in Variety

    'Will & Grace' Star Eric McCormack Looks Back on Early Stage Roles

     A delightful verse prologue, Restoration-style, sets the scene for “And All for Love,” Alison Lawrence’s carefully researched look at the first two women to appear on the English stage. The world premiere focuses on the progression from mentoring to friendship, rivalry and destruction between the actresses, Winifred Gosnell and Elizabeth Barry, while commenting on the […]

  • Lin-Manuel Miranda Announces The Hamildrops (Listen)

    Lin-Manuel Miranda Announces 'Hamilton' Mixtape Vol. 2 With 'Ben Franklin's Song'

     A delightful verse prologue, Restoration-style, sets the scene for “And All for Love,” Alison Lawrence’s carefully researched look at the first two women to appear on the English stage. The world premiere focuses on the progression from mentoring to friendship, rivalry and destruction between the actresses, Winifred Gosnell and Elizabeth Barry, while commenting on the […]

  • Pinocchio review

    London Theater Review: 'Pinocchio'

     A delightful verse prologue, Restoration-style, sets the scene for “And All for Love,” Alison Lawrence’s carefully researched look at the first two women to appear on the English stage. The world premiere focuses on the progression from mentoring to friendship, rivalry and destruction between the actresses, Winifred Gosnell and Elizabeth Barry, while commenting on the […]

  • The Children review

    Broadway Review: 'The Children'

     A delightful verse prologue, Restoration-style, sets the scene for “And All for Love,” Alison Lawrence’s carefully researched look at the first two women to appear on the English stage. The world premiere focuses on the progression from mentoring to friendship, rivalry and destruction between the actresses, Winifred Gosnell and Elizabeth Barry, while commenting on the […]

  • Marilyn Stasio's 10 Best New York

    10 Best New York Theater Productions of 2017

     A delightful verse prologue, Restoration-style, sets the scene for “And All for Love,” Alison Lawrence’s carefully researched look at the first two women to appear on the English stage. The world premiere focuses on the progression from mentoring to friendship, rivalry and destruction between the actresses, Winifred Gosnell and Elizabeth Barry, while commenting on the […]

  • Adam Driver

    Adam Driver to Star in 'Burn This' on Broadway

     A delightful verse prologue, Restoration-style, sets the scene for “And All for Love,” Alison Lawrence’s carefully researched look at the first two women to appear on the English stage. The world premiere focuses on the progression from mentoring to friendship, rivalry and destruction between the actresses, Winifred Gosnell and Elizabeth Barry, while commenting on the […]

  • The Twilight Zone review

    London Theater Review: 'The Twilight Zone'

     A delightful verse prologue, Restoration-style, sets the scene for “And All for Love,” Alison Lawrence’s carefully researched look at the first two women to appear on the English stage. The world premiere focuses on the progression from mentoring to friendship, rivalry and destruction between the actresses, Winifred Gosnell and Elizabeth Barry, while commenting on the […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content