Review: ‘Secrets of State’

Espionage thriller "Secrets of State" tosses a fresh glass of Bordeaux in the face of anyone still ordering a side of "freedom fries."

Going to great lengths to promote France’s engagement in the global war on terror, espionage thriller “Secrets of State” tosses a fresh glass of Bordeaux in the face of anyone still ordering a side of “freedom fries.” Gripping suspenser from scribe-helmer Philippe Haim pits a rookie Nikita against a homegrown jihad recruit, using frenzied direction and multiple plot twists to reveal the human capital expended in the murky conflict. Still, for anyone who’s already seen “Syriana,” “Body of Lies” or “24,” there’s a strong sense of deja vu here. Pic assails Gaul Dec. 10.

French-language addition to Hollywood’s recent slew of terrorist-themed blockbusters focuses on the down-and-dirty methods of the DGSE, Gaul’s version of the CIA. Based on extensive research involving seven credited consultants, the script provides a more detailed portrait of the undercover agency than has been previously featured onscreen, but is less convincing in its depiction of the bomb-rigging, video-making baddies.

A fragmented opening sequence promptly introduces the story’s three protags, whose lives will criss-cross, break apart and eventually collide by the end of the narrative.

Diane (Vahina Giocante), an ex-prostitute turned Arab translator, fails a college exam and finds herself coerced by no-joke DGSA trainer Alex (vet Gerard Lanvin) into becoming a secret agent. Miles away in the northern city of Lille, drug dealer Pierre (Nicolas Duvauchelle) gets incarcerated, and his awful prison experience (think “Oz”) leads him to embrace a band of Islamist recruiters.

Middle section follows Diane’s and Pierre’s parallel trajectories as they learn, often less than willingly, to embody their newfound identities.

A more conventional subplot involves the attempts of two other agents (Medhi Nebbou, Rachida Brakni) to pin down terrorist mastermind Al-Barad (Simon Abkarian). When their efforts fail, Alex convinces Diane to step up to the plate to prevent a chemical bomb from penetrating France’s borders.

Helmer/co-writer Philippe Haim (“The Daltons”) manages to add some unexpected nuance to what is basically a race-against-the-clock scenario, and thesps Giocante and Duvauchelle give their characters a touch of tragic innocence that’s rare for the genre. But as with so much recent Hollywood fare, the terrorism theme is merely an all-purpose MacGuffin, its origins explained in the kind of cliche scene where several bearded men sit in a room and talk about how much they hate the West.

A truly gut-wrenching finale set in the Paris metro adds to the pic’s pulsating tone, which is maintained by ace editor Sylvie Landra’s (“The Professional”) rapid-fire cutting. D.p. Jerome Almeras gives the material an edgy contempo look and pulls off a few breathtaking cityscape shots.

Music by Alexandre Azaria vaguely recalls “The Bourne Ultimatum,” as does an even more familiar cell phone-in-pocket gag and open-space situation room.

Secrets of State



A UGC Distribution release of a UGC YM, France 3 Cinema, France 2 Cinema production, with participation of Canal Plus, TPS Star. (International sales: UGC Intl., Paris.) Produced by Yves Marmion. Executive producer, Olivier Thaon. Directed by Philippe Haim. Screenplay, Haim, Julien Sibony.


Camera (color, widescreen), Jerome Almeras; editor, Sylvie Landra; music, Alexandre Azaria; production designer, Ambre Sansonetti; costume designer, Eric Perron; sound (Dolby SRD/DTS Digital), Pierre Gamet, Vincent Mauduit, Frederic Le Louet, Francois-Joseph Hors; assistant director, Dominique Delany; casting, Laurence Wayser. Reviewed at UGC screening room, Paris, Oct. 9, 2008. Running time: 99 MIN.


Gerard Lanvin, Vahina Giocante, Nicolas Duvauchelle, Simon Abkarian, Rachida Brakni, Medhi Nebbou, Aurelien Wiik, Nicolas Marie, Katia Lewkowicz, Catherine Hiegel.
Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety