Review: ‘Quid Pro Quo’

Gillian Brooks

An exceedingly odd meeting of the minds (and bodies) occurs in "Quid Pro Quo," a strikingly original and provocative first feature from scribe-helmer Carlos Brooks.

An exceedingly odd meeting of the minds (and bodies) occurs in “Quid Pro Quo,” a strikingly original and provocative first feature from scribe-helmer Carlos Brooks. Touching on one of New York’s weirder subcultures — perfectly mobile, able-bodied people with paralysis envy — this very funny two-hander has the wit to treat potentially offensive material with an offhand drollery that is immediately disarming, even as it builds a disturbing level of intimacy between its excellent leads, Nick Stahl and Vera Farmiga. Bizarro subject matter and minor-key execution will keep wider audiences at bay, but consider Brooks a talent to watch.

A detective story that morphs into a twisted romance, “Quid Pro Quo” is narrated by Gotham public radio personality Isaac Knott (Stahl), who’s been in a wheelchair since the car accident that killed his parents and deprived him of the use of his legs at age 8. With his wry wit (“If you’re wondering, yes, I can have sex — I just can’t catch a cab”) and utter lack of self-pity, Isaac would be ideal company even if he didn’t guide the audience into such intriguingly murky territory.

Tipped off about a secret group of paraplegic “wannabes,” some of whom have sought to induce paralysis via amputation and other means, Isaac smells a potential story and soon gets in touch with the mysterious Fiona (Farmiga, with a Veronica Lake hairdo). A conservator of artifacts and Chinese-culture enthusiast, Fiona turns out to be one strange cookie; Isaac is the first person she tells about her wheelchair, to which she wants to be confined forever.

But Fiona doesn’t spill her guts without a price, and the film’s title refers at least in part to the fair exchange of secrets between the two characters. Brooks’ sardonic screenplay yields one of the cinema’s more unique portraits of co-dependency, as Isaac and Fiona’s initial guardedness gives way to their mutual need to get inside each other’s heads (and, of course, their growing sexual attraction). Fascinating questions are raised along the way — not only why some people would want to paralyze themselves, but also why they might view their freedom as a form of paralysis.

The sly perversity of “Quid Pro Quo’s” setup — which takes an even odder turn when Isaac magically starts to regain feeling in his legs, while Fiona mulls her options — would keep a viewer watching even if the film completely derailed. It doesn’t, but given the pretzel-logic intrigue that precedes it, the film’s final revelation is arguably too pat, even psychologically reductive, although Brooks definitely has an impressive way with a red herring.

Lead thesps are beautifully matched, with Stahl’s imperturbable Isaac acting as the perfect straight-man foil to Farmiga’s neurotic, impassioned Fiona. One of their early dates, as Fiona tests out her wheelchair for the first time in public, reps a comic high point.

Lenser Michael McDonough amplifies the film’s detective-fiction undercurrents and dreamlike feel with a noirish, amber-glow lighting scheme. Tech package is decent.

Quid Pro Quo


A Magnolia Pictures release of an HDNet Films presentation of a Sanford/Pillsbury production. Produced by Sarah Pillsbury, Midge Sanford. Executive producers, Jason Kliot, Joana Vicente, Todd Wagner, Mark Cuban. Co-producer, Per Melita. Directed, written by Carlos Brooks.


Camera (color, HD), Michael McDonough; editors, Lauren Zuckerman, Charles Ireland; music, Mark Mothersbaugh; music supervisor, Robin Urdang; production designer, Roshelle Berliner; art director, Mary Beth Kuhn; set decorator, Siobain Flaherty; costume designer, Eric Daman; sound (Dolby Digital), Antonio Arroyo; sound designer, Sandy Berman; re-recording mixer, David West; visual effects supervisor, Dan Schmidt; visual effects, Engine Room; stunt coordinators, Cort Hessler, Gene Harrison; assistant director, Jason "Rowdy" Rody; casting, Randi Hiller, Sarah Halley Finn. Reviewed at Sundance Film Festival (Spectrum), Jan. 20, 2008. Running time: 81 MIN.


Nick Stahl, Vera Farmiga, Jacob Pitts, Aimee Mullins, Jeane Fournier, Kate Burton, Jessica Hecht, Dylan Bruno, Rachel Black, Phil LaMarr, Pablo Schreiber, Leonardo Nam, Michal Sinnott, Joshua Leonard.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Film News from Variety