Proposition 8 Passes


Proposition 8, which puts a constitutional ban on same-sex marriage into California’s state constitution, was passed by voters, according to late returns that came in this morning.

It’s a crushing defeat for many who had seen it as a breakthrough in the struggle for equality of same-sex partners.

It also puts into doubt some of the 18,000 marriages performed since the state Supreme Court cleared the way for such nuptials in May — although some legal scholars believe that those unions will be grandfathered in.

In a conference call with reporters, Geoff Kors and Kate Kendall of the No on 8 campaign said they were still waiting for outstanding absentee and provisional ballots to come in. They estimate that three to four million are still outstanding.

“It’s going to be a bumpy ride,” Kendall said.

The Los Angeles Times puts the vote at 52% Yes and 48% No.

The San Francisco city attorney plans to challenge the validity of the ballot measure in court, and other cities and counties are expected to join in as well.

The first lesbian couple married in Los Angeles County in June also plans to announce a lawsuit, arguing that the measure is unconstitutional, according to the Associated Press.

What went wrong?

There will be consternation and fingerpointing, and an assessment of what could have been done better.  The campaign was energized in October, but it was too late. Some are calling for a shakeup in the leadership of gay rights orgs.

Willie Brown was on MSNBC this morning and he said that the failure of the No side speaks to the need to mount a more aggressive ground game in the state. Yes on 8 supporters were blanketing neighborhoods where the No on 8 campaign was not, he said.

But  I suspect that there also will be a look at the extent to which out of state money flowed into the Yes on 8 coffers, particularly from the members of the Mormon church.  No on 8 had its share of well-heeled donors from across the country, but it was nothing like the organization that had been mounted from Utah.

I have a combination of anger, frustration and optimism. The margin of defeat was far different than the lopsided nature of the measure in 2000. The future, i.e. younger voters, voted overwhelming against the proposition. Some 18,000 couples got married, the traditions and nature of matrimony didn’t collapse and the gay community may have established bonds with other organizations that will last far longer than the certification of this year’s results. The path is still clear.

Update: Chad Griffin, a consultant to the No on 8 campaign, offers this statement: “The passage of Prop 8 will be seen has a dark spot on the history of this great state.  This country passed a major milestone with the election our first black president but the results in California, Arkansas and Florida are grim reminders that discrimination and bigotry remain a reality in this country.  The struggle for equality is a marathon that we’ll eventually win. The fight goes on…now back to the courts.”

Update: Equality California has filed a suit on behalf of six same-sex couples who planned to marry.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 4

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. William Bauer, MD says:

    Correction: the first sentence should read “I think the opposition to prop 8 was doomed …”

  2. William Bauer, MD says:

    I think prop 8 was doomed the minute the Billionaire Bailout Bill (BBB)passed, as I have mention before in my comments on your blog. The BBB was thought at the time and proved to be a pro-elitist sop. It allowed billionaire bankers and Wall Street insiders to collect $70 biliion in bonuses and stick the taxpayers with a $700 billion tab just as the average taxpayers are becoming unemployed. The opposition against the BBB was overwhelming but in the end ignored. impotent rage became rightous anger. Rightly or wrongly they looked for elitist causes to attack and it was at this time that the polls on prop 8 flipped and never returned. Its opposition was wrongly viewed as an elitist cause backed by elitist money and fame against the average to poor middle class families and church going voters. Correctly the opponents of this proposition sensed this and shifted some of their advertising and PR, but the impression was fixed and they did not have enough time to undo it. Prop 8 passed.
    As I think of this misguided anger that caused the defeat of this bill and at the approaching depression this country is entering, I am reminded of the famous German Jewish scientist who went on to win the Noble prize. He( and his name escapes me) once said, when asked what was the greatest achievement of his life, he responded it was “leaving Germany the day the Riechstag burned”(on that day the trains to Switzerland were empty and passage unblocked and unchecked — the next day people on the packed trains were prevented from leaving). The reason behind his answer was understood …. for had he not left Germany that day, he would have never survived to accomplish everything else.
    I hope, no, pray that all of us do not face the need for such achievements in the future but beware anger is a funny, tricky, and dangerous thing as we have all just seen.

  3. The saddest aspect of this to me is that people don’t seem to realize that yesterday we really weren’t voting about gay marriage. We were voting whether or not to take away people’s constitutional rights, and that should have just about every person worried.
    Check this out:

  4. marioc says:

    Will someone please tell gavin newson to keep his piehole shut, his raspy words about the door being wide open was the most effective add on this or any other ballot measure. The last thing we need to fight a “family issue” matter is help from someone who screws his friend’s wife and is proud of it. He is a pompous self serving maggot as far as I am concern, we do not need his help at all.

More Biz News from Variety