You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

“How I Met Your Mother” Goes the Lasagna Route

Mother_1016 “If we were friends with Garfield, we wouldn’t set him up with Mondays.”

That was a joke on CBS’ “How I Met Your Mother” this week.  And it was offered without qualification, without irony.

I kept thinking that surely it was a set-up line, that surely, on a show in which the characters are constantly testing and teasing each other’s coolness, Marshall (Jason Segel) would be mocked for making an “Garfield” analogy.

Nope.  That was it. Just a bunch of cool twentysomethings in the 21st century, batting no eyes at a reference to a comic most people last enjoyed nearly 30 years ago.

This wasn’t “Peanuts” or even “Family Circus.” This was “Garfield,” perhaps the most cachet-free, zeitgeist-immune comic one can think of. Did the “Mother” generation ever even like Garfield? I really think it was one of the oddest moments I’ve seen on TV so far this season.

Of course, I shouldn’t get too holier-than-thou.  After all, I understood the joke …

— Jon Weisman

More TV

  • Will and Grace

    TV Ratings: 'Will & Grace' Tops Thursday Scripted Shows

    “If we were friends with Garfield, we wouldn’t set him up with Mondays.” That was a joke on CBS’ “How I Met Your Mother” this week.  And it was offered without qualification, without irony. I kept thinking that surely it was a set-up line, that surely, on a show in which the characters are constantly […]

  • Andrew Lincoln as Rick Grimes, Chandler

    'Walking Dead' Boss Greg Nicotero Says Zombies Will Win the Rick-Negan War

    “If we were friends with Garfield, we wouldn’t set him up with Mondays.” That was a joke on CBS’ “How I Met Your Mother” this week.  And it was offered without qualification, without irony. I kept thinking that surely it was a set-up line, that surely, on a show in which the characters are constantly […]

  • Harvey Weinstein

    TV Academy Votes to Begin Disciplinary Proceedings Against Harvey Weinstein

    “If we were friends with Garfield, we wouldn’t set him up with Mondays.” That was a joke on CBS’ “How I Met Your Mother” this week.  And it was offered without qualification, without irony. I kept thinking that surely it was a set-up line, that surely, on a show in which the characters are constantly […]

  • Tracy Morgan TCA

    Tracy Morgan's 'The Last O.G.' Loses Showrunner, Delayed Until 2018

    “If we were friends with Garfield, we wouldn’t set him up with Mondays.” That was a joke on CBS’ “How I Met Your Mother” this week.  And it was offered without qualification, without irony. I kept thinking that surely it was a set-up line, that surely, on a show in which the characters are constantly […]

  • Roy Price's Top Amazon Lieutenants Under

    Roy Price's Top Amazon Lieutenants Under Scrutiny (EXCLUSIVE)

    “If we were friends with Garfield, we wouldn’t set him up with Mondays.” That was a joke on CBS’ “How I Met Your Mother” this week.  And it was offered without qualification, without irony. I kept thinking that surely it was a set-up line, that surely, on a show in which the characters are constantly […]

  • Chelsea Handler Netflix trailer

    'Chelsea' Proves Netflix Can't Always Beat TV at Its Own Game (Opinion)

    “If we were friends with Garfield, we wouldn’t set him up with Mondays.” That was a joke on CBS’ “How I Met Your Mother” this week.  And it was offered without qualification, without irony. I kept thinking that surely it was a set-up line, that surely, on a show in which the characters are constantly […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content