Review: ‘When a Man Falls in the Forest’

Film is unlikely to make much of a sound theatrically.

Few will notice “When a Man Falls in the Forest,” so derivative and flaccid are its art-film tropes about loneliness and ennui. Though exec producer Sharon Stone is quite good as a wife mired in misery, most auds will feel the same way. Sophomore effort from bright young “Madness and Genius” helmer-scribe Ryan Eslinger is unlikely to make much of a sound theatrically, with fest play and offshore sales a more likely way through the woods.

In an unnamed city, a handful of lives overlap. The night shift of tightly wrapped office custodian Bill (Dylan Baker) puts him in contact with Gary (Timothy Hutton), apparently a lawyer of some sort who has a habit of falling asleep at his desk until well into the evening.

While Bill is terrified of the world, Gary exudes a cheerfulness that seems hollow and distracted. So excited is he to discover the janitor’s an old classmate, Gary promptly calls another school chum, Travis (Pruitt Taylor Vince), whom he hasn’t seen in the four years that have elapsed since a hinted-at traffic tragedy stopped his life cold.

Meanwhile, Gary’s watery-eyed white-collar wife Karen (Stone) gazes enviously at younger, happier couples and finds some solace in regular bouts of shoplifting. No wonder Gary snoozes at his desk, as their few conversations, whether in their sterile kitchen or a chance supermarket aisle encounter, suggest a union past the point of salvage. Even their college-age son, Will (David Williams), seems an afterthought.

For his part, Bill keeps busy playing a self-help tape he found while compulsively rearranging the cassette collection at his local library. The soothing female voice encourages him to embrace the newfound fantasies of “lucid dreaming,” a (real-life) technique he eventually brings to bear on his battered single-mother neighbor, Sadie (Stacie Bono), with startling results.

When one of this sad quartet brings about his own fall, influence on the others dictates their paths forward.

This brand of urban angst, peppered with sinister eccentricity, has been the meat and potatoes of precocious Amerindie cinema for so long now that nothing here seems startling, or even fresh. What might have come across as profound on the page plays onscreen as empty pretension. If Eslinger’s point is that most of these lost souls talk a lot but don’t actually say very much or even functionally communicate, that point’s success comes at the expense of originality that rendered helmer’s confident debut a genuine eye-opener.

Acting chops are split down the middle. Baker’s broad perf is undone by ill-advised mugging, while Hutton, who plays the first half-hour in a baseball cap he seldom doffs after that, never seems to settle comfortably into Gary’s midlife crisis despite a show-stopping monologue of “I’ll do better” cliches he delivers into Karen’s answering machine. Far better are Stone’s deep well of quiet anguish and the always-dependable Vince’s stock-in-trade evocation of nice-guy melancholia.

Tech credits are crisp on Vancouver-area locations. Three tunes written and sung by former Smashing Pumpkins frontman Billy Corgan and some operatic passages are scattered throughout. A thicket of additional executive producers are buried in closing credits.

When a Man Falls in the Forest

Germany - Canada - U.S.


A Rigel Entertainment presentation of a Torati Active Film (Germany), Insight Film Studios (Canada), Rigel Entertainment (U.S.) production, in association with Proud Mary Entertainment. (International sales: Rigel Entertainment, Vancouver.) Produced by Kirk Shaw, Mary Aloe, Christian Arnold-Beutel. Executive producers, Sharon Stone, John F.S. Laing, Michael Dimanno. Directed, written by Ryan Eslinger.


Camera (color, widescreen), Lawrence Sher; editors, Jamie Alain, Eslinger; music, Paul Michael Thomas, John Sereda; production designer, Andy Deskin; costume designer, Ken Shapkin; sound (Dolby Digital), Tad Nazar, Mark Schroeder; assistant director, Patricia Dyer Walden. Reviewed at Berlin Film Festival (competing), Feb. 12, 2007. Running time: 86 MIN.


Bill - Dylan Baker Sadie - Stacie Bono Gary Fields - Timothy Hutton Karen Fields - Sharon Stone Travis - Pruitt Taylor Vince Will - David Williams
With: Nicholas Elia, Melanie Yeats.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Scene News from Variety