Review: ‘The Gathering’

Alan Bennett

An amusing bit of hokum through its first night, Lifetime's slow-moving supernatural melodrama "The Gathering" gradually falls apart in its second amid lots of loud music, wind-blown hair and chanting in tongues.

An amusing bit of hokum through its first night, Lifetime’s slow-moving supernatural melodrama “The Gathering” gradually falls apart in its second amid lots of loud music, wind-blown hair and chanting in tongues. An able cast buys into the silliness with seeming conviction as this hollow mini about a coven of witches draws on everything from “Salem’s Lot” to “Rosemary’s Baby” but will ultimately leave those who hang on for the full ride feeling more hoaxed than hexed.

John Shiban, who cut his teeth writing for “The X-Files,” employs many of the same tricks, beginning with Jeff Rona’s spooky score. The structure, however, requires prolonging the core mystery well beyond its weight, diluting the horror by teasing it out over four hours.

Peter Gallagher plays Michael Foster, a doctor who wakes up after a freaky nightmare to discover that his wife Ann (Kristin Lehman) has disappeared. His investigation into her absence puts him in touch with Maggy (Jamie-Lynn Sigler of “The Sopranos,” who isn’t seen much despite the prominent billing), a teacher at the school attended by his teenage daughter, Zee (Jenna Boyd).

Maggy dribbles out vague clues about Ann’s absence, and others come from a cop (Hugh Dillon) who has also lost somebody. All signs point to a powerful coven under the stewardship of mogul Thomas Carrier (Peter Fonda, in full snarl), though the goals of the witches’ fiendish plot and wailing incantations remain as fuzzy at the end, frankly, as they do at the beginning.

Practicing a kind of voodoo, the witches use their collective power to try influencing local politics and indulge various carnal whims. Mostly, though, as directed by Bill Eagles, they produce a lot of slow-motion shots of flapping ravens, strange rituals and evil spells that cause the victims to spit blood.

Gallagher’s hero proves rather tepid through little fault of his own, and the various subplots involving Carrier’s grown kids and the awakening of Foster’s daughter (something about a “good blood line”) gradually feel like filler as part two crawls toward the finish line.

For Lifetime, the Halloween-themed project does represent a bit of an ambitious stretch from its usual movies, which have a tendency to focus on earthbound problems culled from the pages of women’s magazines. This mini may be fun for a while, but with so much repetition and so little direction, it’s perhaps inevitable that for all its toil and trouble, “The Gathering” doesn’t so much enthrall us as simply go “poof.”

The Gathering

Lifetime, Sat.-Sun. Oct. 13-14, 9 p.m.


Filmed in Toronto by Patriarch Pictures and Cine Pico in association with Sony Pictures Television. Executive producers, David Eick, John Shiban, Tom Patricia; producer, John Eckert; director, Bill Eagles; writer, Shiban;


camera, Steve Cosens; editors, Paul Trejo, Lynne M. Whitlock; music, Jeff Rona; production designer, John Dondertman; casting, Donna Rosenstein. 4 HOURS


Dr. Michael Foster - Peter Gallagher Maggy Rule - Jamie-Lynn Sigler Ann Foster - Kristin Lehman Zee Foster - Jenna Boyd Detective Gamble - Hugh Dillon Dr. Jerry Tanner - James Carroll Andrew Carrier - Mike Shara Thomas Carrier Jr. - Greg Bryk Elaine Tanner - Susanna Thompson Thomas Carrier - Peter Fonda

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 0

Leave a Reply

No Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More Scene News from Variety